Homage to the Blessed One, the Worthy One, the Perfectly Enlightened One

Canon of the Higher Teaching

Yamaka Pāḷi (First Part)

1.

Pairs on Roots

Synopsis

1.

Root Section

1.

Wholesome Mental States

(1) Root Method

1. Whatever mental states are wholesome, are all of them wholesome roots?

Or else, whatever are wholesome roots, are all those mental states wholesome?

2. Whatever mental states are wholesome, are all of them of one root with a wholesome root?

Or else, whatever are of one root with a wholesome root, are all those mental states wholesome?

3. Whatever mental states are of one root with a wholesome root, are all of them mutually rooted with a wholesome root?

Or else, whatever are mutually rooted with a wholesome root, are all those mental states wholesome?

(2) Root-Root Method

4. Whatever mental states are wholesome, are all of them roots of wholesome roots?

Or else, whatever are roots of wholesome roots, are all those mental states wholesome?

5. Whatever mental states are wholesome, are all of them of one root with a wholesome root?

Or else, whatever are of one root with a wholesome root, are all those mental states wholesome?

6. Whatever mental states are of one root rooted with a wholesome root, are all of them mutually rooted with a wholesome root?

Or else, whatever are mutually rooted with a wholesome root, are all those mental states wholesome?

(3) Possessing-Root Method

7. Whatever mental states are wholesome, are all of them rooted in the wholesome?

Or else, whatever are rooted in the wholesome, are all those mental states wholesome?

8. Whatever mental states are wholesome, are all of them of one root with a wholesome root?

Or else, whatever are of one root with a wholesome root, are all those mental states wholesome?

9. Whatever mental states are of one root with a wholesome root, are all of them mutually rooted with a wholesome root?

Or else, whatever are mutually rooted with a wholesome root, are all those mental states wholesome?

(4) Root-Possessing-Root Method

10. Whatever mental states are wholesome, are all of them rooted in wholesome roots?

Or else, whatever are rooted in wholesome roots, are all those mental states wholesome?

11. Whatever mental states are wholesome, are all of them of one root rooted in a wholesome root?

Or else, whatever are of one root rooted in a wholesome root, are all those mental states wholesome?

12. Whatever mental states are of one root rooted in a wholesome root, are all of them mutually rooted with a wholesome root?

Or else, whatever are mutually rooted with a wholesome root, are all those mental states wholesome?

2.

Unwholesome Mental States (1) Root Method

13. Whatever mental states are unwholesome, are all of them unwholesome roots?

Or else, whatever are unwholesome roots, are all those mental states unwholesome?

14. Whatever mental states are unwholesome, are all of them of one root with an unwholesome root?

Or else, whatever are of one root with an unwholesome root, are all those mental states unwholesome?

15. Whatever mental states are of one root with an unwholesome root, are all of them mutually rooted with an unwholesome root?

Or else, whatever are mutually rooted with an unwholesome root, are all those mental states unwholesome?

(2) Root-Root Method

16. Whatever mental states are unwholesome, are all of them roots of unwholesome roots?

Or else, whatever are roots of unwholesome roots, are all those mental states unwholesome?

17. Whatever mental states are unwholesome, are all of them of one root with an unwholesome root?

Or else, whatever are of one root with an unwholesome root, are all those mental states unwholesome?

18. Whatever mental states are of one root rooted with an unwholesome root, are all of them mutually rooted with an unwholesome root?

Or else, whatever are mutually rooted with an unwholesome root, are all those mental states unwholesome?

(3) Possessing-Root Method

19. Whatever mental states are unwholesome, are all of them having unwholesome roots?

Or else, whatever have unwholesome roots, are all those mental states unwholesome?

20. Whatever mental states are unwholesome, are all of them of one root with an unwholesome root?

Or else, whatever are of one root with an unwholesome root, are all those mental states unwholesome?

21. Whatever mental states are of one root with an unwholesome root, are all of them mutually rooted with an unwholesome root?

Or else, whatever are mutually rooted with an unwholesome root, are all those mental states unwholesome?

(4) Root-Possessing-Root Method

22. Whatever mental states are unwholesome, are all of them rooted in unwholesome roots?

Or else, whatever are rooted in unwholesome roots, are all those mental states unwholesome?

23. Whatever mental states are unwholesome, are all of them of one root rooted in an unwholesome root?

Or else, whatever are of one root rooted in an unwholesome root, are all those mental states unwholesome?

24. Whatever mental states are of one root rooted in an unwholesome root, are all of them mutually rooted with an unwholesome root?

Or else, whatever are mutually rooted with an unwholesome root, are all those mental states unwholesome?

3.

Indeterminate Mental States (1) Root Method

25. Whatever mental states are indeterminate, are all of them indeterminate roots?

Or else, whatever are indeterminate roots, are all those mental states indeterminate?

26. Whatever mental states are indeterminate, are all of them of one root with an indeterminate root?

Or else, whatever are of one root with an indeterminate root, are all those mental states indeterminate?

27. Whatever mental states are of one root with an indeterminate root, are all of them mutually rooted with an indeterminate root?

Or else, whatever are mutually rooted with an indeterminate root, are all those mental states indeterminate?

(2) Root-Root Method

28. Whatever mental states are indeterminate, are all of them roots of indeterminate roots?

Or else, whatever are roots of indeterminate roots, are all those mental states indeterminate?

29. Whatever mental states are indeterminate, are all of them of one root with an indeterminate root?

Or else, whatever are of one root with an indeterminate root, are all those mental states indeterminate?

30. Whatever mental states are of one root rooted with an indeterminate root, are all of them mutually rooted with an indeterminate root?

Or else, whatever are mutually rooted with an indeterminate root, are all those mental states indeterminate?

(3) Possessing-Root Method

31. Whatever mental states are indeterminate, are all of them having indeterminate root?

Or else, whatever have indeterminate root, are all those mental states indeterminate?

32. Whatever mental states are indeterminate, are all of them of one root with an indeterminate root?

Or else, whatever are of one root with an indeterminate root, are all those mental states indeterminate?

33. Whatever mental states are of one root with an indeterminate root, are all of them mutually rooted with an indeterminate root?

Or else, whatever are mutually rooted with an indeterminate root, are all those mental states indeterminate?

(4) Root-Possessing-Root Method

34. Whatever mental states are indeterminate, are all of them having indeterminate root as root?

Or else, whatever have indeterminate root as root, are all those mental states indeterminate?

35. Whatever mental states are indeterminate, are all of them of one root rooted in an indeterminate root?

Or else, whatever are of one root rooted in an indeterminate root, are all those mental states indeterminate?

36. Whatever mental states are of one root rooted in an indeterminate root, are all of them mutually rooted with an indeterminate root?

Or else, whatever are mutually rooted with an indeterminate root, are all those mental states indeterminate?

4.

Mental Phenomena (1) Root Method

37. Whatever mental states are mental, are all of them mentality root?

Or else, whatever are mentality root, are all those mental states mental?

38. Whatever mental states are mental, are all of them of one root with a mentality root?

Or else, whatever are of one root with a mentality root, are all those mental states mental?

39. Whatever mental states are of one root with a mentality root, are all of them mutually rooted with a mentality root?

Or else, whatever are mutually rooted with a mentality root, are all those mental states mental?

(2) Root-Root Method

40. Whatever mental states are mental, are all of them mentality root root?

Or else, whatever are mentality root root, are all those mental states mental?

41. Whatever mental states are mental, are all of them of one root with a mentality root?

Or else, whatever are of one root with a mentality root, are all those mental states mental?

42. Whatever mental states are of one root rooted with a mentality root, are all of them mutually rooted with a mentality root?

Or else, whatever are mutually rooted with a mentality root, are all those mental states mental?

(3) Possessing-Root Method

43. Whatever mental states are mental, are all of them mentality root?

Or else, whatever are mentality root, are all those mental states mental?

44. Whatever mental states are mental, are all of them of one root with a mentality root?

Or else, whatever are of one root with a mentality root, are all those mental states mental?

45. Whatever mental states are of one root with a mentality root, are all of them mutually rooted with a mentality root?

Or else, whatever are mutually rooted with a mentality root, are all those mental states mental?

(4) Root-Possessing-Root Method

46. Whatever mental states are mental, are all of them having mentality root as root?

Or else, whatever have mentality root as root, are all those mental states mental?

47. Whatever mental states are mental, are all of them of one root rooted in a mentality root?

Or else, whatever are of one root rooted in a mentality root, are all those mental states mental?

48. Whatever mental states are of one root rooted in a mentality root, are all of them mutually rooted with a mentality root?

Or else, whatever are mutually rooted with a mentality root, are all those mental states mental?

The Synopsis of the Root Section.

2-10.

Cause Section and so on

49. Whatever mental states are wholesome, all of them have a wholesome root... etc. have a wholesome source... etc. have a wholesome origin... etc. have a wholesome production... etc. have a wholesome origination... etc. have a wholesome nutriment... etc. have a wholesome object... etc. have a wholesome condition... etc. have a wholesome arising... etc.

The Section on Synopsis is concluded.

Exposition

1.

Root Section

1.

Wholesome mental states (1) the root method

50. Whatever mental states are wholesome, are all of them wholesome roots? There are only three wholesome roots. The remaining wholesome mental states are not wholesome roots.

Or else, whatever are wholesome roots, are all those mental states wholesome? Yes.

51. Whatever mental states are wholesome, are all of them of one root with a wholesome root? Yes.

Or else, whatever are of one root with a wholesome root, are all those mental states wholesome?

Wholesome (mind)-originated materiality is of one root with a wholesome root, but is not wholesome. The wholesome is both of one root with a wholesome root and wholesome.

52. Whatever mental states are of one root with a wholesome root, are all of them mutually rooted with a wholesome root?

The roots which arise together, the wholesome roots, are both of one root and mutually rooted. The remaining mental states connascent with a wholesome root are of one root with a wholesome root, but not mutually rooted.

Or else, whatever are mutually rooted with a wholesome root, are all those mental states wholesome? Yes.

(2) Root-Root Method

53. Whatever mental states are wholesome, are all of them roots of wholesome roots? There are only three roots of wholesome roots. The remaining wholesome mental states are not roots of wholesome roots.

Or else, whatever are roots of wholesome roots, are all those mental states wholesome? Yes.

54. Whatever mental states are wholesome, are all of them of one root-root with a wholesome root? Yes.

Or else, whatever are of one root-root with a wholesome root, are all those mental states wholesome?

Wholesome (mind)-originated materiality is of one root-root with a wholesome root, but is not wholesome. The wholesome is both of one root-root with a wholesome root and wholesome.

55. Whatever mental states are of one root rooted with a wholesome root, are all of them mutually rooted with a wholesome root?

The roots which arise together, the wholesome roots, are both of one root rooted and mutually rooted. The remaining mental states connascent with a wholesome root are of one root rooted with a wholesome root, but not mutually rooted.

Or else, whatever are mutually rooted with a wholesome root, are all those mental states wholesome? Yes.

(3) Possessing-Root Method

56. Whatever mental states are wholesome, are all of them rooted in the wholesome? Yes.

Or else, whatever are rooted in the wholesome, are all those mental states wholesome?

Wholesome (mind)-originated materiality is rooted in the wholesome, but is not wholesome. The wholesome is both rooted in the wholesome and wholesome.

57. Whatever mental states are wholesome, are all of them of one root with a wholesome root? Yes.

Or else, whatever are of one root with a wholesome root, are all those mental states wholesome?

Wholesome (mind)-originated materiality is of one root with a wholesome root, but is not wholesome. The wholesome is both of one root with a wholesome root and wholesome.

58. Whatever mental states are of one root with a wholesome root, are all of them mutually rooted with a wholesome root?

The roots which arise together, the wholesome roots, are both of one root and mutually rooted. The remaining mental states connascent with a wholesome root are of one root with a wholesome root, but not mutually rooted.

Or else, whatever are mutually rooted with a wholesome root, are all those mental states wholesome? Yes.

(4) Root-Possessing-Root Method

59. Whatever mental states are wholesome, are all of them rooted in wholesome roots? Yes.

Or else, whatever are rooted in wholesome roots, are all those mental states wholesome?

Wholesome (mind)-originated materiality is rooted in wholesome roots, but is not wholesome. The wholesome is both rooted in wholesome roots and wholesome.

60. Whatever mental states are wholesome, are all of them of one root rooted in a wholesome root? Yes.

Or else, whatever are of one root rooted in a wholesome root, are all those mental states wholesome?

Wholesome (mind)-originated materiality is of one root rooted in a wholesome root, but is not wholesome. The wholesome is both of one root rooted in a wholesome root and wholesome.

61. Whatever mental states are of one root rooted in a wholesome root, are all of them mutually rooted with a wholesome root?

The roots which arise together, the wholesome roots, are both of one root rooted and mutually rooted. The remaining mental states connascent with a wholesome root are of one root rooted in a wholesome root, but not mutually rooted.

Or else, whatever are mutually rooted with a wholesome root, are all those mental states wholesome? Yes.

2.

Unwholesome Mental States (1) Root Method

62. Whatever mental states are unwholesome, are all of them unwholesome roots?

There are only three unwholesome roots. The remaining unwholesome mental states are not unwholesome roots.

Or else, whatever are unwholesome roots, are all those mental states unwholesome? Yes.

63. Whatever mental states are unwholesome, are all of them of one root with an unwholesome root?

Rootless unwholesome is not of one root with an unwholesome root. Unwholesome with root is of one root with an unwholesome root.

Or else, whatever are of one root with an unwholesome root, are all those mental states unwholesome?

Unwholesome (mind)-originated materiality is of one root with an unwholesome root, but is not unwholesome. The unwholesome is both of one root with an unwholesome root and unwholesome.

64. Whatever mental states are of one root with an unwholesome root, are all of them mutually rooted with an unwholesome root?

The roots which arise together, the unwholesome roots, are both of one root and mutually rooted. The remaining mental states connascent with an unwholesome root are of one root with an unwholesome root, but not mutually rooted.

Or else, whatever are mutually rooted with an unwholesome root, are all those mental states unwholesome? Yes.

(2) Root-Root Method

65. Whatever mental states are unwholesome, are all of them roots of unwholesome roots?

There are only three roots of unwholesome roots. The remaining unwholesome mental states are not roots of unwholesome roots.

Or else, whatever are roots of unwholesome roots, are all those mental states unwholesome? Yes.

66. Whatever mental states are unwholesome, are all of them of one root-root with an unwholesome root?

Rootless unwholesome is not of one root-root with an unwholesome root. Unwholesome with root is of one root-root with an unwholesome root.

Or else, whatever are of one root-root with an unwholesome root, are all those mental states unwholesome?

Unwholesome (mind)-originated materiality is of one root-root with an unwholesome root, but is not unwholesome. The unwholesome is both of one root-root with an unwholesome root and unwholesome.

67. Whatever mental states are of one root rooted with an unwholesome root, are all of them mutually rooted with an unwholesome root?

The roots which arise together, the unwholesome roots, are both of one root rooted and mutually rooted. The remaining mental states connascent with an unwholesome root are of one root rooted with an unwholesome root, but not mutually rooted.

Or else, whatever are mutually rooted with an unwholesome root, are all those mental states unwholesome? Yes.

(3) Possessing-Root Method

68. Whatever mental states are unwholesome, are all of them having unwholesome roots?

Rootless unwholesome is not having unwholesome roots. Unwholesome with root is having unwholesome roots.

Or else, whatever have unwholesome roots, are all those mental states unwholesome?

Unwholesome (mind)-originated materiality has unwholesome roots but is not unwholesome. The unwholesome both has unwholesome roots and is unwholesome.

69. Whatever mental states are unwholesome, are all of them of one root with an unwholesome root?

Rootless unwholesome is not of one root with an unwholesome root. Unwholesome with root is of one root with an unwholesome root.

Or else, whatever are of one root with an unwholesome root, are all those mental states unwholesome?

Unwholesome (mind)-originated materiality is of one root with an unwholesome root, but is not unwholesome. The unwholesome is both of one root with an unwholesome root and unwholesome.

70. Whatever mental states are of one root with an unwholesome root, are all of them mutually rooted with an unwholesome root?

The roots which arise together, the unwholesome roots, are both of one root and mutually rooted. The remaining mental states connascent with an unwholesome root are of one root with an unwholesome root, but not mutually rooted.

Or else, whatever are mutually rooted with an unwholesome root, are all those mental states unwholesome? Yes.

(4) Root-Possessing-Root Method

71. Whatever mental states are unwholesome, are all of them rooted in unwholesome roots?

Rootless unwholesome is not rooted in unwholesome roots. Unwholesome with root is rooted in unwholesome roots.

Or else, whatever are rooted in unwholesome roots, are all those mental states unwholesome?

Unwholesome (mind)-originated materiality is rooted in unwholesome roots but is not unwholesome. The unwholesome is both rooted in unwholesome roots and unwholesome.

72. Whatever mental states are unwholesome, are all of them of one root rooted in an unwholesome root?

Rootless unwholesome is not of one root rooted in an unwholesome root. Unwholesome with root is of one root rooted in an unwholesome root.

Or else, whatever are of one root rooted in an unwholesome root, are all those mental states unwholesome?

Unwholesome (mind)-originated materiality is of one root rooted in an unwholesome root, but is not unwholesome. The unwholesome is both of one root rooted in an unwholesome root and unwholesome.

73. Whatever mental states are of one root rooted in an unwholesome root, are all of them mutually rooted with an unwholesome root?

The roots which arise together, the unwholesome roots, are both of one root rooted and mutually rooted. The remaining mental states connascent with an unwholesome root are of one root rooted in an unwholesome root, but not mutually rooted.

Or else, whatever are mutually rooted with an unwholesome root, are all those mental states unwholesome? Yes.

3.

Indeterminate Mental States (1) Root Method

74. Whatever mental states are indeterminate, are all of them indeterminate roots?

Only three are indeterminate roots. The remaining indeterminate mental states are not indeterminate roots.

Or else, whatever are indeterminate roots, are all those mental states indeterminate? Yes.

75. Whatever mental states are indeterminate, are all of them of one root with an indeterminate root?

Rootless indeterminate is not of one root with an indeterminate root. Indeterminate with root is of one root with an indeterminate root.

Or else, whatever are of one root with an indeterminate root, are all those mental states indeterminate? Yes.

76. Whatever mental states are of one root with an indeterminate root, are all of them mutually rooted with an indeterminate root?

The roots which arise together, the indeterminate roots, are both of one root and mutually rooted. The remaining mental states connascent with an indeterminate root are of one root with an indeterminate root, but not mutually rooted.

Or else, whatever are mutually rooted with an indeterminate root, are all those mental states indeterminate? Yes.

(2) Root-Root Method

77. Whatever mental states are indeterminate, are all of them roots of indeterminate roots?

Only three are roots of indeterminate roots. The remaining indeterminate mental states are not roots of indeterminate roots.

Or else, whatever are roots of indeterminate roots, are all those mental states indeterminate? Yes.

78. Whatever mental states are indeterminate, are all of them of one root-root with an indeterminate root?

Rootless indeterminate is not of one root-root with an indeterminate root. Indeterminate with root is of one root-root with an indeterminate root.

Or else, whatever are of one root-root with an indeterminate root, are all those mental states indeterminate? Yes.

79. Whatever mental states are of one root rooted with an indeterminate root, are all of them mutually rooted with an indeterminate root?

The roots which arise together, the indeterminate roots, are both of one root rooted and mutually rooted. The remaining mental states connascent with an indeterminate root are of one root rooted with an indeterminate root, but not mutually rooted.

Or else, whatever are mutually rooted with an indeterminate root, are all those mental states indeterminate? Yes.

(3) Possessing-Root Method

80. Whatever mental states are indeterminate, are all of them having indeterminate root?

Rootless indeterminate is not having indeterminate root. Indeterminate with root is having indeterminate root.

Or else, whatever have indeterminate root, are all those mental states indeterminate? Yes.

81. Whatever mental states are indeterminate, are all of them of one root with an indeterminate root?

Rootless indeterminate is not of one root with an indeterminate root. Indeterminate with root is of one root with an indeterminate root.

Or else, whatever are of one root with an indeterminate root, are all those mental states indeterminate? Yes.

82. Whatever mental states are of one root with an indeterminate root, are all of them mutually rooted with an indeterminate root?

The roots which arise together, the indeterminate roots, are both of one root and mutually rooted. The remaining mental states connascent with an indeterminate root are of one root with an indeterminate root, but not mutually rooted.

Or else, whatever are mutually rooted with an indeterminate root, are all those mental states indeterminate? Yes.

(4) Root-Possessing-Root Method

83. Whatever mental states are indeterminate, are all of them having indeterminate root as root?

Rootless indeterminate is not having indeterminate root as root. Indeterminate with root is having indeterminate root as root.

Or else, whatever have indeterminate root as root, are all those mental states indeterminate? Yes.

84. Whatever mental states are indeterminate, are all of them of one root rooted in an indeterminate root?

Rootless indeterminate is not of one root rooted in an indeterminate root. Indeterminate with root is of one root rooted in an indeterminate root.

Or else, whatever are of one root rooted in an indeterminate root, are all those mental states indeterminate? Yes.

85. Whatever mental states are of one root rooted in an indeterminate root, are all of them mutually rooted with an indeterminate root?

The roots which arise together, the indeterminate roots, are both of one root rooted and mutually rooted. The remaining mental states connascent with an indeterminate root are of one root rooted in an indeterminate root, but not mutually rooted.

Or else, whatever are mutually rooted with an indeterminate root, are all those mental states indeterminate? Yes.

4.

Mental Phenomena (1) Root Method

86. Whatever mental states are mental, are all of them mentality root?

There are only nine mentality roots. The remaining mental states are not mentality root.

Or else, whatever are mentality root, are all those mental states mental? Yes.

87. Whatever mental states are mental, are all of them of one root with a mentality root?

Rootless mentality is not of one root with a mentality root. Mentality with root is of one root with a mentality root.

Or else, whatever are of one root with a mentality root, are all those mental states mental?

Mentality-originated materiality is of one root with a mentality root, but is not mental. Mentality is both of one root with a mentality root and mental.

88. Whatever mental states are of one root with a mentality root, are all of them mutually rooted with a mentality root?

The roots which arise together, the mentality roots, are both of one root and mutually rooted. The remaining mental states connascent with a mentality root are of one root with a mentality root, but not mutually rooted.

Or else, whatever are mutually rooted with a mentality root, are all those mental states mental? Yes.

(2) Root-Root Method

89. Whatever mental states are mental, are all of them mentality root root?

Only nine are mentality root root. The remaining mental states are not mentality root root.

Or else, whatever are mentality root root, are all those mental states mental? Yes.

90. Whatever mental states are mental, are all of them of one root-root with a mentality root?

Rootless mentality is not of one root-root with a mentality root. Mentality with root is of one root-root with a mentality root.

Or else, whatever are of one root-root with a mentality root, are all those mental states mental?

Mentality-originated materiality is of one root-root with a mentality root, but is not mental. Mentality is both of one root-root with a mentality root and mental.

91. Whatever mental states are of one root rooted with a mentality root, are all of them mutually rooted with a mentality root?

The roots which arise together, the mentality roots, are both of one root rooted and mutually rooted. The remaining mental states connascent with a mentality root are of one root rooted with a mentality root, but not mutually rooted.

Or else, whatever are mutually rooted with a mentality root, are all those mental states mental? Yes.

(3) Possessing-Root Method

92. Whatever mental states are mental, are all of them mentality rooted?

Rootless mentality is not mentality rooted. Mentality with root is mentality rooted.

Or else, whatever are mentality rooted, are all those mental states mental?

Mentality-originated materiality is mentality rooted, but is not mental. Mentality is both mentality rooted and mental.

93. Whatever mental states are mental, are all of them of one root with a mentality root?

Rootless mentality is not of one root with a mentality root. Mentality with root is of one root with a mentality root.

Or else, whatever are of one root with a mentality root, are all those mental states mental?

Mentality-originated materiality is of one root with a mentality root, but is not mental. Mentality is both of one root with a mentality root and mental.

94. Whatever mental states are of one root with a mentality root, are all of them mutually rooted with a mentality root?

The roots which arise together, the mentality roots, are both of one root and mutually rooted. The remaining mental states connascent with a mentality root are of one root with a mentality root, but not mutually rooted.

Or else, whatever are mutually rooted with a mentality root, are all those mental states mental? Yes.

(4) Root-Possessing-Root Method

95. Whatever mental states are mental, are all of them having mentality root as root?

Rootless mentality does not have mentality root as root. Mentality with root has mentality root as root.

Or else, whatever have mentality root as root, are all those mental states mental?

Mentality-originated materiality has mentality root as root, but is not mental. Mentality both has mentality root as root and is mental.

96. Whatever mental states are mental, are all of them of one root rooted in a mentality root?

Rootless mentality is not of one root rooted in a mentality root. Mentality with root is of one root rooted in a mentality root.

Or else, whatever are of one root rooted in a mentality root, are all those mental states mental?

Mentality-originated materiality is of one root rooted in a mentality root, but is not mental. Mentality is both of one root rooted in a mentality root and mental.

97. Whatever mental states are of one root rooted in a mentality root, are all of them mutually rooted with a mentality root?

The roots which arise together, the mentality roots, are both of one root rooted and mutually rooted. The remaining mental states connascent with a mentality root are of one root rooted in a mentality root, but not mutually rooted.

Or else, whatever are mutually rooted with a mentality root, are all those mental states mental?

Yes.

The Analytic Explanation of the Root Section.

2-10.

Cause Section and so on

98. Whatever mental states are wholesome, are all of them wholesome roots?

Only three are wholesome roots, the remaining wholesome mental states are not wholesome roots... etc. have a wholesome source... have a wholesome origin... have a wholesome production... have a wholesome origination... have a wholesome nutriment... have a wholesome object... have a wholesome condition... have a wholesome arising...

99. Whatever mental states are unwholesome... whatever mental states are indeterminate... whatever mental states are mental, all of them have mentality as cause... have mentality as source... have mentality as origin... have mentality as production... have mentality as origination... have mentality as nutriment... have mentality as object... have mentality as condition... have mentality as arising...

The Section on Analytic Explanation is concluded.

The Pāḷi on the Pairs on Roots is concluded.

Homage to the Blessed One, the Worthy One, the Perfectly Enlightened One

2.

Pairs on Aggregates

1.

The Description Section

Synopsis

1. The five aggregates – the aggregate of matter, the aggregate of feeling, the aggregate of perception, the aggregate of mental activities, the aggregate of consciousness.

1.

The Section on Term Clarification

Conformity

2. Is matter the aggregate of matter?

Is the aggregate of matter matter?

Is feeling the aggregate of feeling?

Is the aggregate of feeling feeling?

Is perception the aggregate of perception?

Is the aggregate of perception perception?

Are activities the aggregate of mental activities?

Is the aggregate of mental activities activities?

Is consciousness the aggregate of consciousness?

Is the aggregate of consciousness consciousness?

Opposite

3. Is what is not matter not the aggregate of matter?

Is what is not the aggregate of matter not matter?

Is what is not feeling not the aggregate of feeling?

Is what is not the aggregate of feeling not feeling?

Is what is not perception not the aggregate of perception?

Is what is not the aggregate of perception not perception?

Is what is not activities not the aggregate of mental activities?

Is what is not the aggregate of mental activities not activities?

Is what is not consciousness not the aggregate of consciousness?

Is what is not the aggregate of consciousness not consciousness?

2.

The Section on Term Clarification Root Wheel

Conformity

4. Is matter the aggregate of matter?

Are the aggregates the aggregate of feeling?

Is matter the aggregate of matter?

Are the aggregates the aggregate of perception?

Is matter the aggregate of matter?

Are the aggregates the aggregate of mental activities?

Is matter the aggregate of matter?

Are the aggregates the aggregate of consciousness?

5. Is feeling the aggregate of feeling?

Are the aggregates the aggregate of matter?

Is feeling the aggregate of feeling?

Are the aggregates the aggregate of perception?

Is feeling the aggregate of feeling?

Are the aggregates the aggregate of mental activities?

Is feeling the aggregate of feeling?

Are the aggregates the aggregate of consciousness?

6. Is perception the aggregate of perception?

Are the aggregates the aggregate of matter?

Is perception the aggregate of perception?

Are the aggregates the aggregate of feeling?

Is perception the aggregate of perception?

Are the aggregates the aggregate of mental activities?

Is perception the aggregate of perception?

Are the aggregates the aggregate of consciousness?

7. Are activities the aggregate of mental activities?

Are the aggregates the aggregate of matter?

Are activities the aggregate of mental activities?

Are the aggregates the aggregate of feeling?

Are activities the aggregate of mental activities?

Are the aggregates the aggregate of perception?

Are activities the aggregate of mental activities?

Are the aggregates the aggregate of consciousness?

8. Is consciousness the aggregate of consciousness?

Are the aggregates the aggregate of matter?

Is consciousness the aggregate of consciousness?

Are the aggregates the aggregate of feeling?

Is consciousness the aggregate of consciousness?

Are the aggregates the aggregate of perception?

Is consciousness the aggregate of consciousness?

Are the aggregates the aggregate of mental activities?

Opposite

9. Is what is not matter not the aggregate of matter?

Is what is not aggregates not the aggregate of feeling?

Is what is not matter not the aggregate of matter?

Is what is not aggregates not the aggregate of perception?

Is what is not matter not the aggregate of matter?

Is what is not aggregates not the aggregate of mental activities?

Is what is not matter not the aggregate of matter?

Is what is not aggregates not the aggregate of consciousness?

10. Is what is not feeling not the aggregate of feeling?

Is what is not aggregates not the aggregate of matter?

Is what is not feeling not the aggregate of feeling?

Is what is not aggregates not the aggregate of perception?

Is what is not feeling not the aggregate of feeling?

Is what is not aggregates not the aggregate of mental activities?

Is what is not feeling not the aggregate of feeling?

Is what is not aggregates not the aggregate of consciousness?

11. Is what is not perception not the aggregate of perception?

Is what is not aggregates not the aggregate of matter?

Is what is not perception not the aggregate of perception?

Is what is not aggregates not the aggregate of feeling?

Is what is not perception not the aggregate of perception?

Is what is not aggregates not the aggregate of mental activities?

Is what is not perception not the aggregate of perception?

Is what is not aggregates not the aggregate of consciousness?

12. Is what is not activities not the aggregate of mental activities?

Is what is not aggregates not the aggregate of matter?

Is what is not activities not the aggregate of mental activities?

Is what is not aggregates not the aggregate of feeling?

Is what is not activities not the aggregate of mental activities?

Is what is not aggregates not the aggregate of perception?

Is what is not activities not the aggregate of mental activities?

Is what is not aggregates not the aggregate of consciousness?

13. Is what is not consciousness not the aggregate of consciousness?

Is what is not aggregates not the aggregate of matter?

Is what is not consciousness not the aggregate of consciousness?

Is what is not aggregates not the aggregate of feeling?

Is what is not consciousness not the aggregate of consciousness?

Is what is not aggregates not the aggregate of perception?

Is what is not consciousness not the aggregate of consciousness?

Is what is not aggregates not the aggregate of mental activities?

3.

The Section on Pure Aggregates

Conformity

14. Is matter an aggregate?

Are the aggregates matter?

Is feeling an aggregate?

Are the aggregates feeling?

Is perception an aggregate?

Are the aggregates perception?

Are activities an aggregate?

Are the aggregates activities?

Is consciousness an aggregate?

Are the aggregates consciousness?

Opposite

15. Is what is not matter not an aggregate?

Is what is not aggregates not matter?

Is what is not feeling not an aggregate?

Is what is not aggregates not feeling?

Is what is not perception not an aggregate?

Is what is not aggregates not perception?

Is what is not activities not an aggregate?

Is what is not aggregates not activities?

Is what is not consciousness not an aggregate?

Is what is not aggregates not consciousness?

4.

The Section on Pure Aggregates Root Wheel

Conformity

16. Is matter an aggregate?

Are the aggregates feeling?

Is matter an aggregate?

Are the aggregates perception?

Is matter an aggregate?

Are the aggregates activities?

Is matter an aggregate?

Are the aggregates consciousness?

17. Is feeling an aggregate?

Are the aggregates matter?

Is feeling an aggregate?

Are the aggregates perception?

Is feeling an aggregate?

Are the aggregates activities?

Is feeling an aggregate?

Are the aggregates consciousness?

18. Is perception an aggregate?

Are the aggregates matter?

Is perception an aggregate?

Are the aggregates feeling?

Is perception an aggregate?

Are the aggregates activities?

Is perception an aggregate?

Are the aggregates consciousness?

19. Are activities an aggregate?

Are the aggregates matter?

Are activities an aggregate?

Are the aggregates feeling?

Are activities an aggregate?

Are the aggregates perception?

Are activities an aggregate?

Are the aggregates consciousness?

20. Is consciousness an aggregate?

Are the aggregates matter?

Is consciousness an aggregate?

Are the aggregates feeling?

Is consciousness an aggregate?

Are the aggregates perception?

Is consciousness an aggregate?

Are the aggregates activities?

Opposite

21. Is what is not matter not an aggregate?

Is what is not aggregates not feeling?

Is what is not matter not an aggregate?

Is what is not aggregates not perception?

Is what is not matter not an aggregate?

Is what is not aggregates not activities?

Is what is not matter not an aggregate?

Is what is not aggregates not consciousness?

22. Is what is not feeling not an aggregate?

Is what is not aggregates not matter?

Is what is not feeling not an aggregate?

Is what is not aggregates not perception?

Is what is not feeling not an aggregate?

Is what is not aggregates not activities?

Is what is not feeling not an aggregate?

Is what is not aggregates not consciousness?

23. Is what is not perception not an aggregate?

Is what is not aggregates not matter?

Is what is not perception not an aggregate?

Is what is not aggregates not feeling?

Is what is not perception not an aggregate?

Is what is not aggregates not activities?

Is what is not perception not an aggregate?

Is what is not aggregates not consciousness?

24. Is what is not activities not an aggregate?

Is what is not aggregates not matter?

Is what is not activities not an aggregate?

Is what is not aggregates not feeling?

Is what is not activities not an aggregate?

Is what is not aggregates not perception?

Is what is not activities not an aggregate?

Is what is not aggregates not consciousness?

25. Is what is not consciousness not an aggregate?

Is what is not aggregates not matter?

Is what is not consciousness not an aggregate?

Is what is not aggregates not feeling?

Is what is not consciousness not an aggregate?

Is what is not aggregates not perception?

Is what is not consciousness not an aggregate?

Is what is not aggregates not activities?

The Section on Synopsis of Description.

Exposition

1.

Analytic Explanation of the Description Section

1.

The Section on Term Clarification

Conformity

26. Is matter the aggregate of matter?

What has a dear nature and a pleasant nature is matter, not the aggregate of matter. The aggregate of matter is both matter and the aggregate of matter.

Is the aggregate of matter matter? Yes.

Is feeling the aggregate of feeling? Yes.

Is the aggregate of feeling feeling? Yes.

Is perception the aggregate of perception?

Perception of view is perception, not the aggregate of perception. The aggregate of perception is both perception and the aggregate of perception.

Is the aggregate of perception perception? Yes.

Are activities the aggregate of mental activities?

Setting aside the aggregate of mental activities, the remaining activities are not the aggregate of mental activities. The aggregate of mental activities is both activities and the aggregate of mental activities.

Is the aggregate of mental activities activities? Yes.

Is consciousness the aggregate of consciousness? Yes.

Is the aggregate of consciousness consciousness? Yes.

Opposite

27. Is what is not matter not the aggregate of matter? Yes.

Is what is not the aggregate of matter not matter?

What has a dear nature and a pleasant nature is not the aggregate of matter, but is matter. Setting aside matter and the aggregate of matter, the remainder is neither matter nor the aggregate of matter.

Is what is not feeling not the aggregate of feeling? Yes.

Is what is not the aggregate of feeling not feeling? Yes.

Is what is not perception not the aggregate of perception? Yes.

Is what is not the aggregate of perception not perception?

Perception of view is not the aggregate of perception, but is perception. Setting aside perception and the aggregate of perception, the remainder is neither perception nor the aggregate of perception.

Is what is not activities not the aggregate of mental activities? Yes.

Is what is not the aggregate of mental activities not activities?

Setting aside the aggregate of mental activities, the remainder is not the aggregate of mental activities, but is activities. Setting aside activities and the aggregate of mental activities, the remainder is neither activities nor the aggregate of mental activities.

Is what is not consciousness not the aggregate of consciousness? Yes.

Is what is not the aggregate of consciousness not consciousness? Yes.

2.

The Section on Term Clarification Root Wheel

Conformity

28. Is matter the aggregate of matter?

What has a dear nature and a pleasant nature is matter, not the aggregate of matter. The aggregate of matter is both matter and the aggregate of matter.

Are aggregates the aggregate of feeling?

The aggregate of feeling is both an aggregate and the aggregate of feeling.

The remaining aggregates are not the aggregate of feeling.

Is matter the aggregate of matter?

What has a dear nature and a pleasant nature is matter, not the aggregate of matter. The aggregate of matter is both matter and the aggregate of matter.

Are aggregates the aggregate of perception?

The aggregate of perception is both an aggregate and the aggregate of perception. The remaining aggregates are not the aggregate of perception.

Is matter the aggregate of matter?

What has a dear nature and a pleasant nature is matter, not the aggregate of matter. The aggregate of matter is both matter and the aggregate of matter.

Are aggregates the aggregate of mental activities?

The aggregate of mental activities is both an aggregate and the aggregate of mental activities. The remaining aggregates are not the aggregate of mental activities.

Is matter the aggregate of matter?

What has a dear nature and a pleasant nature is matter, not the aggregate of matter. The aggregate of matter is both matter and the aggregate of matter.

Are aggregates the aggregate of consciousness?

The aggregate of consciousness is both an aggregate and the aggregate of consciousness. The remaining aggregates are not the aggregate of consciousness.

29. Is feeling the aggregate of feeling? Yes.

Are aggregates the aggregate of matter?

The aggregate of matter is both an aggregate and the aggregate of matter. The remaining aggregates are not the aggregate of matter.

Is feeling the aggregate of feeling? Yes.

Are aggregates the aggregate of perception?

The aggregate of perception is both an aggregate and the aggregate of perception. The remaining aggregates are not the aggregate of perception.

Is feeling the aggregate of feeling? Yes.

Are aggregates the aggregate of mental activities?

The aggregate of mental activities is both an aggregate and the aggregate of mental activities. The remaining aggregates are not the aggregate of mental activities.

Is feeling the aggregate of feeling? Yes.

Are aggregates the aggregate of consciousness?

The aggregate of consciousness is both an aggregate and the aggregate of consciousness. The remaining aggregates are not the aggregate of consciousness.

30. Is perception the aggregate of perception?

Perception of view is perception, not the aggregate of perception. The aggregate of perception is both perception and the aggregate of perception.

Are aggregates the aggregate of matter?

The aggregate of matter is both an aggregate and the aggregate of matter. The remaining aggregates are not the aggregate of matter.

Is perception the aggregate of perception?

Perception of view is perception, not the aggregate of perception. The aggregate of perception is both perception and the aggregate of perception.

Are aggregates the aggregate of feeling?

The aggregate of feeling is both an aggregate and the aggregate of feeling. The remaining aggregates are not the aggregate of feeling.

Is perception the aggregate of perception?

Perception of view is perception, not the aggregate of perception. The aggregate of perception is both perception and the aggregate of perception.

Are aggregates the aggregate of mental activities?

The aggregate of mental activities is both an aggregate and the aggregate of mental activities. The remaining aggregates are not the aggregate of mental activities.

Is perception the aggregate of perception?

Perception of view is perception, not the aggregate of perception. The aggregate of perception is both perception and the aggregate of perception.

Are aggregates the aggregate of consciousness?

The aggregate of consciousness is both an aggregate and the aggregate of consciousness. The remaining aggregates are not the aggregate of consciousness.

31. Are activities the aggregate of mental activities?

Setting aside the aggregate of mental activities, the remaining activities are not the aggregate of mental activities. The aggregate of mental activities is both activities and the aggregate of mental activities.

Are aggregates the aggregate of matter?

The aggregate of matter is both an aggregate and the aggregate of matter. The remaining aggregates are not the aggregate of matter.

Are activities the aggregate of mental activities?

Setting aside the aggregate of mental activities, the remaining activities are not the aggregate of mental activities. The aggregate of mental activities is both activities and the aggregate of mental activities.

Are aggregates the aggregate of feeling?

The aggregate of feeling is both an aggregate and the aggregate of feeling. The remaining aggregates are not the aggregate of feeling.

Are activities the aggregate of mental activities?

Setting aside the aggregate of mental activities, the remaining activities are not the aggregate of mental activities. The aggregate of mental activities is both activities and the aggregate of mental activities.

Are aggregates the aggregate of perception?

The aggregate of perception is both an aggregate and the aggregate of perception. The remaining aggregates are not the aggregate of perception.

Are activities the aggregate of mental activities?

Setting aside the aggregate of mental activities, the remaining activities are not the aggregate of mental activities. The aggregate of mental activities is both activities and the aggregate of mental activities.

Are aggregates the aggregate of consciousness?

The aggregate of consciousness is both an aggregate and the aggregate of consciousness. The remaining aggregates are not the aggregate of consciousness.

32. Is consciousness the aggregate of consciousness? Yes.

Are aggregates the aggregate of matter?

The aggregate of matter is both an aggregate and the aggregate of matter. The remaining aggregates are not the aggregate of matter.

Is consciousness the aggregate of consciousness? Yes.

Are aggregates the aggregate of feeling?

The aggregate of feeling is both an aggregate and the aggregate of feeling. The remaining aggregates are not the aggregate of feeling.

Is consciousness the aggregate of consciousness? Yes.

Are aggregates the aggregate of perception?

The aggregate of perception is both an aggregate and the aggregate of perception. The remaining aggregates are not the aggregate of perception.

Is consciousness the aggregate of consciousness? Yes.

Are aggregates the aggregate of mental activities?

The aggregate of mental activities is both an aggregate and the aggregate of mental activities. The remaining aggregates are not the aggregate of mental activities.

Opposite

33. Is what is not matter not the aggregate of matter? Yes.

Is what is not aggregates not the aggregate of feeling? Yes.

Is what is not matter not the aggregate of matter? Yes.

Is what is not aggregates not the aggregate of perception? Yes.

Is what is not matter not the aggregate of matter? Yes.

Is what is not aggregates not the aggregate of mental activities? Yes.

Is what is not matter not the aggregate of matter? Yes.

Is what is not aggregates not the aggregate of consciousness? Yes.

34. Is what is not feeling not the aggregate of feeling? Yes.

Is what is not aggregates not the aggregate of matter? Yes.

Is what is not feeling not the aggregate of feeling? Yes.

Is what is not aggregates not the aggregate of perception? Yes.

Is what is not feeling not the aggregate of feeling? Yes.

Is what is not aggregates not the aggregate of mental activities? Yes.

Is what is not feeling not the aggregate of feeling? Yes.

Is what is not aggregates not the aggregate of consciousness? Yes.

35. Is what is not perception not the aggregate of perception? Yes.

Is what is not aggregates not the aggregate of matter? Yes.

Is what is not perception not the aggregate of perception? Yes.

Is what is not aggregates not the aggregate of feeling? Yes.

Is what is not perception not the aggregate of perception? Yes.

Is what is not aggregates not the aggregate of mental activities? Yes.

Is what is not perception not the aggregate of perception? Yes.

Is what is not aggregates not the aggregate of consciousness? Yes.

36. Is what is not activities not the aggregate of mental activities? Yes.

Is what is not aggregates not the aggregate of matter? Yes.

Is what is not activities not the aggregate of mental activities? Yes.

Is what is not aggregates not the aggregate of feeling? Yes.

Is what is not activities not the aggregate of mental activities? Yes.

Is what is not aggregates not the aggregate of perception? Yes.

Is what is not activities not the aggregate of mental activities? Yes.

Is what is not aggregates not the aggregate of consciousness? Yes.

37. Is what is not consciousness not the aggregate of consciousness? Yes.

Is what is not aggregates not the aggregate of matter? Yes.

Is what is not consciousness not the aggregate of consciousness? Yes.

Is what is not aggregates not the aggregate of feeling? Yes.

Is what is not consciousness not the aggregate of consciousness? Yes.

Is what is not aggregates not the aggregate of perception? Yes.

Is what is not consciousness not the aggregate of consciousness? Yes.

Is what is not aggregates not the aggregate of mental activities? Yes.

3.

The Section on Pure Aggregates

Conformity

38. Is matter an aggregate? Yes.

Are aggregates the aggregate of matter?

The aggregate of matter is both an aggregate and the aggregate of matter. The remaining aggregates are not the aggregate of matter.

Is feeling an aggregate? Yes.

Are aggregates the aggregate of feeling?

The aggregate of feeling is both an aggregate and the aggregate of feeling. The remaining aggregates are not the aggregate of feeling.

Is perception an aggregate? Yes.

Are aggregates the aggregate of perception?

The aggregate of perception is both an aggregate and the aggregate of perception. The remaining aggregates are not the aggregate of perception.

Are activities an aggregate? Yes.

Are aggregates the aggregate of mental activities?

The aggregate of mental activities is both an aggregate and the aggregate of mental activities. The remaining aggregates are not the aggregate of mental activities.

Is consciousness an aggregate? Yes.

Are aggregates the aggregate of consciousness?

The aggregate of consciousness is both an aggregate and the aggregate of consciousness. The remaining aggregates are not the aggregate of consciousness.

Opposite

39. Is what is not matter not an aggregate?

Setting aside matter, the remaining aggregates are not matter, but are aggregates. Setting aside matter and the aggregates, the remainder is neither matter nor aggregates.

Is what is not aggregates not the aggregate of matter? Yes.

Is what is not feeling not an aggregate?

Setting aside feeling, the remaining aggregates are not feeling, but are aggregates. Setting aside feeling and the aggregates, the remainder is neither feeling nor aggregates.

Is what is not aggregates not the aggregate of feeling? Yes.

Is what is not perception not an aggregate?

Setting aside perception, the remaining aggregates are not perception, but are aggregates. Setting aside perception and the aggregates, the remainder is neither perception nor aggregates.

Is what is not aggregates not the aggregate of perception? Yes.

Is what is not activities not an aggregate? Yes.

Is what is not aggregates not the aggregate of mental activities? Yes.

Is what is not consciousness not an aggregate?

Setting aside consciousness, the remaining aggregates are not consciousness, but are aggregates. Setting aside consciousness and the aggregates, the remainder is neither consciousness nor aggregates.

Is what is not aggregates not the aggregate of consciousness? Yes.

4.

The Section on Pure Aggregates Root Wheel

Conformity

40. Is matter an aggregate? Yes.

Are aggregates the aggregate of feeling?

The aggregate of feeling is both an aggregate and the aggregate of feeling. The remaining aggregates are not the aggregate of feeling.

Is matter an aggregate? Yes.

Are aggregates the aggregate of perception?

The aggregate of perception is both an aggregate and the aggregate of perception. The remaining aggregates are not the aggregate of perception.

Is matter an aggregate? Yes.

Are aggregates the aggregate of mental activities?

The aggregate of mental activities is both an aggregate and the aggregate of mental activities. The remaining aggregates are not the aggregate of mental activities.

Is matter an aggregate? Yes.

Are aggregates the aggregate of consciousness?

The aggregate of consciousness is both an aggregate and the aggregate of consciousness. The remaining aggregates are not the aggregate of consciousness.

41. Is feeling an aggregate? Yes.

Are aggregates the aggregate of matter?

The aggregate of matter is both an aggregate and the aggregate of matter. The remaining aggregates are not the aggregate of matter.

Is feeling an aggregate? Yes.

Are aggregates the aggregate of perception?

The aggregate of perception is both an aggregate and the aggregate of perception. The remaining aggregates are not the aggregate of perception.

Is feeling an aggregate? Yes.

Are aggregates the aggregate of mental activities?

The aggregate of mental activities is both an aggregate and the aggregate of mental activities. The remaining aggregates are not the aggregate of mental activities.

Is feeling an aggregate? Yes.

Are aggregates the aggregate of consciousness?

The aggregate of consciousness is both an aggregate and the aggregate of consciousness. The remaining aggregates are not the aggregate of consciousness.

42. Is perception an aggregate? Yes.

Are aggregates the aggregate of matter?

The aggregate of matter is both an aggregate and the aggregate of matter. The remaining aggregates are not the aggregate of matter.

Is perception an aggregate? Yes.

Are aggregates the aggregate of feeling?

The aggregate of feeling is both an aggregate and the aggregate of feeling. The remaining aggregates are not the aggregate of feeling.

Is perception an aggregate? Yes.

Are aggregates the aggregate of mental activities?

The aggregate of mental activities is both an aggregate and the aggregate of mental activities. The remaining aggregates are not the aggregate of mental activities.

Is perception an aggregate? Yes.

Are aggregates the aggregate of consciousness?

The aggregate of consciousness is both an aggregate and the aggregate of consciousness. The remaining aggregates are not the aggregate of consciousness.

43. Are activities an aggregate? Yes.

Are aggregates the aggregate of matter?

The aggregate of matter is both an aggregate and the aggregate of matter. The remaining aggregates are not the aggregate of matter.

Are activities an aggregate? Yes.

Are aggregates the aggregate of feeling?

The aggregate of feeling is both an aggregate and the aggregate of feeling. The remaining aggregates are not the aggregate of feeling.

Are activities an aggregate? Yes.

Are aggregates the aggregate of perception?

The aggregate of perception is both an aggregate and the aggregate of perception. The remaining aggregates are not the aggregate of perception.

Are activities an aggregate? Yes.

Are aggregates the aggregate of consciousness?

The aggregate of consciousness is both an aggregate and the aggregate of consciousness. The remaining aggregates are not the aggregate of consciousness.

44. Is consciousness an aggregate? Yes.

Are aggregates the aggregate of matter?

The aggregate of matter is both an aggregate and the aggregate of matter. The remaining aggregates are not the aggregate of matter.

Is consciousness an aggregate? Yes.

Are aggregates the aggregate of feeling?

The aggregate of feeling is both an aggregate and the aggregate of feeling. The remaining aggregates are not the aggregate of feeling.

Is consciousness an aggregate?

Yes.

Are aggregates the aggregate of perception?

The aggregate of perception is both an aggregate and the aggregate of perception. The remaining aggregates are not the aggregate of perception.

Is consciousness an aggregate? Yes.

Are aggregates the aggregate of mental activities?

The aggregate of mental activities is both an aggregate and the aggregate of mental activities. The remaining aggregates are not the aggregate of mental activities.

Opposite

45. Is what is not matter not an aggregate?

Setting aside matter, the remaining aggregates are not matter, but are aggregates. Setting aside matter and the aggregates, the remainder is neither matter nor aggregates.

Is what is not aggregates not the aggregate of feeling? Yes.

Is what is not matter not an aggregate?

Setting aside matter, the remaining aggregates are not matter, but are aggregates. Setting aside matter and the aggregates, the remainder is neither matter nor aggregates.

Is what is not aggregates not the aggregate of perception? Yes.

Is what is not matter not an aggregate?

Setting aside matter, the remaining aggregates are not matter, but are aggregates. Setting aside matter and the aggregates, the remainder is neither matter nor aggregates.

Is what is not aggregates not the aggregate of mental activities? Yes.

Is what is not matter not an aggregate?

Setting aside matter, the remaining aggregates are not matter, but are aggregates. Setting aside matter and the aggregates, the remainder is neither matter nor aggregates.

Is what is not aggregates not the aggregate of consciousness? Yes.

46. Is what is not feeling not an aggregate?

Setting aside feeling, the remaining aggregates are not feeling, but are aggregates. Setting aside feeling and the aggregates, the remainder is neither feeling nor aggregates.

Is what is not aggregates not the aggregate of matter? Yes.

Is what is not feeling not an aggregate?

Setting aside feeling, the remaining aggregates are not feeling, but are aggregates. Setting aside feeling and the aggregates, the remainder is neither feeling nor aggregates.

Is what is not aggregates not the aggregate of perception? Yes.

Is what is not feeling not an aggregate?

Setting aside feeling, the remaining aggregates are not feeling, but are aggregates. Setting aside feeling and the aggregates, the remainder is neither feeling nor aggregates.

Is what is not aggregates not the aggregate of mental activities? Yes.

Is what is not feeling not an aggregate?

Setting aside feeling, the remaining aggregates are not feeling, but are aggregates. Setting aside feeling and the aggregates, the remainder is neither feeling nor aggregates.

Is what is not aggregates not the aggregate of consciousness? Yes.

47. Is what is not perception not an aggregate?

Setting aside perception, the remaining aggregates are not perception, but are aggregates. Setting aside perception and the aggregates, the remainder is neither perception nor aggregates.

Is what is not aggregates not the aggregate of matter? Yes.

Is what is not perception not an aggregate?

Setting aside perception, the remaining aggregates are not perception, but are aggregates. Setting aside perception and the aggregates, the remainder is neither perception nor aggregates.

Is what is not aggregates not the aggregate of feeling? Yes.

Is what is not perception not an aggregate?

Setting aside perception, the remaining aggregates are not perception, but are aggregates. Setting aside perception and the aggregates, the remainder is neither perception nor aggregates.

Is what is not aggregates not the aggregate of mental activities? Yes.

Is what is not perception not an aggregate?

Setting aside perception, the remaining aggregates are not perception, but are aggregates. Setting aside perception and the aggregates, the remainder is neither perception nor aggregates.

Is what is not aggregates not the aggregate of consciousness? Yes.

48. Is what is not activities not an aggregate? Yes.

Is what is not aggregates not the aggregate of matter? Yes.

Is what is not activities not an aggregate? Yes.

Is what is not aggregates not the aggregate of feeling? Yes.

Is what is not activities not an aggregate? Yes.

Is what is not aggregates not the aggregate of perception? Yes.

Is what is not activities not an aggregate? Yes.

Is what is not aggregates not the aggregate of consciousness? Yes.

49. Is what is not consciousness not an aggregate?

Setting aside consciousness, the remaining aggregates are not consciousness, but are aggregates. Setting aside consciousness and the aggregates, the remainder is neither consciousness nor aggregates.

Is what is not aggregates not the aggregate of matter? Yes.

Is what is not consciousness not an aggregate?

Setting aside consciousness, the remaining aggregates are not consciousness, but are aggregates. Setting aside consciousness and the aggregates, the remainder is neither consciousness nor aggregates.

Is what is not aggregates not the aggregate of feeling? Yes.

Is what is not consciousness not an aggregate?

Setting aside consciousness, the remaining aggregates are not consciousness, but are aggregates. Setting aside consciousness and the aggregates, the remainder is neither consciousness nor aggregates.

Is what is not aggregates not the aggregate of perception? Yes.

Is what is not consciousness not an aggregate?

Setting aside consciousness, the remaining aggregates are not consciousness, but are aggregates. Setting aside consciousness and the aggregates, the remainder is neither consciousness nor aggregates.

Is what is not aggregates not the aggregate of mental activities? Yes.

The Section on Analytic Explanation of Description.

2.

The Section on Occurrence 1.

The Section on Arising

(1) The Section on the Present

Conformity Person

50. For whom the aggregate of matter arises, does the aggregate of feeling arise for that one?

For those being reborn in the non-percipient being realm, for them the aggregate of matter arises, but the aggregate of feeling does not arise for them. For those being reborn in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them both the aggregate of matter arises and the aggregate of feeling arises.

Or else, for whom the aggregate of feeling arises, does the aggregate of matter arise for that one?

For those being reborn in the immaterial realm, for them the aggregate of feeling arises, but the aggregate of matter does not arise for them. For those being reborn in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them both the aggregate of feeling arises and the aggregate of matter arises.

Conformity Place

51.

In the non-percipient being realm, there the aggregate of matter arises, but the aggregate of feeling does not arise there. In the five-aggregate constituent realm, there both the aggregate of matter arises and the aggregate of feeling arises.

Or else, where the aggregate of feeling arises, does the aggregate of matter arise there?

In the immaterial-sphere of existence, there the aggregate of feeling arises, but the aggregate of matter does not arise there. In the five-aggregate constituent realm, there both the aggregate of feeling arises and the aggregate of matter arises.

Conformity - Person - Place

52. For whom and where the aggregate of matter arises, does the aggregate of feeling arise for that one there?

For those being reborn in the non-percipient being realm, for them there the aggregate of matter arises, but the aggregate of feeling does not arise for them there. For those being reborn in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them there both the aggregate of matter arises and the aggregate of feeling arises.

Or else, for whom and where the aggregate of feeling arises, does the aggregate of matter arise for that one there?

For those being reborn in the immaterial realm, for them there the aggregate of feeling arises, but the aggregate of matter does not arise for them there. For those being reborn in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them there both the aggregate of feeling arises and the aggregate of matter arises.

Negative Person

53. For whom the aggregate of matter does not arise, does the aggregate of feeling not arise for that one?

For those being reborn in the immaterial realm, for them the aggregate of matter does not arise, but the aggregate of feeling does arise for them. For all those passing away, for them both the aggregate of matter does not arise and the aggregate of feeling does not arise.

Or else, for whom the aggregate of feeling does not arise, does the aggregate of matter not arise for that one?

For those being reborn in the non-percipient being realm, for them the aggregate of feeling does not arise, but the aggregate of matter does arise for them. For all those passing away, for them both the aggregate of feeling does not arise and the aggregate of matter does not arise.

The Negative Section on Place

54. Where the aggregate of matter does not arise, does the aggregate of feeling not arise there? It arises.

Or else, where the aggregate of feeling does not arise, does the aggregate of matter not arise there? It arises.

Negative - Person - Place

55. For whom and where the aggregate of matter does not arise, does the aggregate of feeling not arise for that one there?

For those being reborn in the immaterial realm, for them there the aggregate of matter does not arise, but the aggregate of feeling does arise for them there. For all those passing away, for them there both the aggregate of matter does not arise and the aggregate of feeling does not arise.

Or else, for whom and where the aggregate of feeling does not arise, does the aggregate of matter not arise for that one there?

For those being reborn in the non-percipient being realm, for them there the aggregate of feeling does not arise, but the aggregate of matter does arise for them there. For all those passing away, for them there both the aggregate of feeling does not arise and the aggregate of matter does not arise.

(2) The Section on the Past

Conformity Person

56. For whom the aggregate of matter arose, did the aggregate of feeling arise for that one? Yes.

Or else, for whom the aggregate of feeling arose, did the aggregate of matter arise for that one? Yes.

Conformity Place

57. Where the aggregate of matter arose, did the aggregate of feeling arise there?

In the non-percipient being realm, there the aggregate of matter arose, but the aggregate of feeling did not arise there. In the five-aggregate constituent realm, there both the aggregate of matter arose and the aggregate of feeling arose.

Or else, where the aggregate of feeling arose, did the aggregate of matter arise there?

In the immaterial-sphere of existence, there the aggregate of feeling arose, but the aggregate of matter did not arise there. In the five-aggregate constituent realm, there both the aggregate of feeling arose and the aggregate of matter arose.

Conformity - Person - Place

58. For whom and where the aggregate of matter arose, did the aggregate of feeling arise for that one there?

For non-percipient beings, for them there the aggregate of matter arose, but the aggregate of feeling did not arise for them there. For five-aggregate constituent beings, for them there both the aggregate of matter arose and the aggregate of feeling arose.

Or else, for whom and where the aggregate of feeling arose, did the aggregate of matter arise for that one there?

For immaterial beings, for them there the aggregate of feeling arose, but the aggregate of matter did not arise for them there. For five-aggregate constituent beings, for them there both the aggregate of feeling arose and the aggregate of matter arose.

Negative Person

59. For whom the aggregate of matter had not arisen, had the aggregate of feeling not arisen for that one? There is not.

Or else, for whom the aggregate of feeling had not arisen, had the aggregate of matter not arisen for that one? There is not.

The Negative Section on Place

60. Where the aggregate of matter had not arisen, had the aggregate of feeling not arisen there? It had arisen.

Or else, where the aggregate of feeling had not arisen, had the aggregate of matter not arisen there? It had arisen.

Negative - Person - Place

61. For whom and where the aggregate of matter had not arisen, had the aggregate of feeling not arisen for that one there?

For immaterial beings, for them there the aggregate of matter had not arisen, but the aggregate of feeling had not not arisen for them there. For those in the Pure Abodes, for them there both the aggregate of matter had not arisen and the aggregate of feeling had not arisen.

Or else, for whom and where the aggregate of feeling had not arisen, had the aggregate of matter not arisen for that one there?

For non-percipient beings, for them there the aggregate of feeling had not arisen, but the aggregate of matter had not not arisen for them there. For those in the Pure Abodes, for them there both the aggregate of feeling had not arisen and the aggregate of matter had not arisen.

(3) The Section on the Future

Conformity Person

62. For whom the aggregate of matter will arise, will the aggregate of feeling arise for that one? Yes.

Or else, for whom the aggregate of feeling will arise, will the aggregate of matter arise for that one?

For those who, having been reborn in the immaterial realm, will attain final nibbāna, for them the aggregate of feeling will arise, but the aggregate of matter will not arise for them. For the others, for them both the aggregate of feeling will arise and the aggregate of matter will arise.

Conformity Place

63. Where the aggregate of matter will arise, will the aggregate of feeling arise there?

In the non-percipient being realm, there the aggregate of matter will arise, but the aggregate of feeling will not arise there. In the five-aggregate constituent realm, there both the aggregate of matter will arise and the aggregate of feeling will arise.

Or else, where the aggregate of feeling will arise, will the aggregate of matter arise there?

In the immaterial-sphere of existence, there the aggregate of feeling will arise, but the aggregate of matter will not arise there. In the five-aggregate constituent realm, there both the aggregate of feeling will arise and the aggregate of matter will arise.

Conformity - Person - Place

64. For whom and where the aggregate of matter will arise, will the aggregate of feeling arise for that one there?

For non-percipient beings, for them there the aggregate of matter will arise, but the aggregate of feeling will not arise for them there. For five-aggregate constituent beings, for them there both the aggregate of matter will arise and the aggregate of feeling will arise.

Or else, for whom and where the aggregate of feeling will arise, will the aggregate of matter arise for that one there?

For immaterial beings, for them there the aggregate of feeling will arise, but the aggregate of matter will not arise for them there. For five-aggregate constituent beings, for them there both the aggregate of feeling will arise and the aggregate of matter will arise.

Negative Person

65. For whom the aggregate of matter will not arise, will the aggregate of feeling not arise for that one?

For those who, having been reborn in the immaterial realm, will attain final nibbāna, for them the aggregate of matter will not arise, but the aggregate of feeling will not fail to arise for them. For those in their last existence, for them both the aggregate of matter will not arise and the aggregate of feeling will not arise.

Or else, for whom the aggregate of feeling will not arise, will the aggregate of matter not arise for that one? Yes.

The Negative Section on Place

66. Where the aggregate of matter will not arise, will the aggregate of feeling not arise there? It will arise.

Or else, where the aggregate of feeling will not arise, will the aggregate of matter not arise there? It will arise.

Negative - Person - Place

67. For whom and where the aggregate of matter will not arise, will the aggregate of feeling not arise for that one there?

For immaterial beings, for them there the aggregate of matter will not arise, but the aggregate of feeling will not fail to arise for them there. For those in their last existence, for them there both the aggregate of matter will not arise and the aggregate of feeling will not arise.

Or else, for whom and where the aggregate of feeling will not arise, will the aggregate of matter not arise for that one there?

For non-percipient beings, for them there the aggregate of feeling will not arise, but the aggregate of matter will not fail to arise for them there. For those in their last existence, for them there both the aggregate of feeling will not arise and the aggregate of matter will not arise.

(4) The Section on Present and Past

Conformity Person

68. For whom the aggregate of matter arises, did the aggregate of feeling arise for that one? Yes.

Or else, for whom the aggregate of feeling arose, does the aggregate of matter arise for that one?

For all those passing away being reborn in the immaterial realm, for them the aggregate of feeling arose, but the aggregate of matter does not arise for them. For those being reborn in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for those being reborn in the non-percipient being realm, for them both the aggregate of feeling arose and the aggregate of matter arises.

69. For whom the aggregate of feeling arises, did the aggregate of perception arise for that one? Yes.

Or else, for whom the aggregate of perception arose, does the aggregate of feeling arise for that one?

For all those passing away being reborn in the non-percipient being realm, for them the aggregate of perception arose, but the aggregate of feeling does not arise for them. For those being reborn in the four-aggregate constituent realm or the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them both the aggregate of perception arose and the aggregate of feeling arises.

Conformity Place

70. Where the aggregate of matter arises, did the aggregate of feeling arise there?

In the non-percipient being realm, there the aggregate of matter arises, but the aggregate of feeling did not arise there. In the five-aggregate constituent realm, there both the aggregate of matter arises and the aggregate of feeling arose.

Or else, where the aggregate of feeling arose, does the aggregate of matter arise there?

In the immaterial-sphere of existence, there the aggregate of feeling arose, but the aggregate of matter does not arise there. In the five-aggregate constituent realm, there both the aggregate of feeling arose and the aggregate of matter arises.

71. Where the aggregate of feeling arises, did the aggregate of perception arise there? Yes.

Or else, where the aggregate of perception arose, does the aggregate of feeling arise there? Yes.

Conformity - Person - Place

72. For whom and where the aggregate of matter arises, did the aggregate of feeling arise for that one there?

For those being reborn in the pure abode, for those being reborn in the non-percipient being realm, for them there the aggregate of matter arises, but the aggregate of feeling did not arise for them there. For the others being reborn in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them there both the aggregate of matter arises and the aggregate of feeling arose.

Or else, for whom and where the aggregate of feeling arose, does the aggregate of matter arise for that one there?

For those passing away from the five-aggregate constituent realm to the immaterial realm, for them there the aggregate of feeling arose, but the aggregate of matter does not arise for them there. For those being reborn in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them there both the aggregate of feeling arose and the aggregate of matter arises.

73. For whom and where the aggregate of feeling arises, did the aggregate of perception arise for that one there?

For those being reborn in the pure abode, for them there the aggregate of feeling arises, but the aggregate of perception did not arise for them there. For the others being reborn in the four-aggregate constituent realm or the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them there both the aggregate of feeling arises and the aggregate of perception arose.

Or else, for whom and where the aggregate of perception arose, does the aggregate of feeling arise for that one there?

For those passing away from the four-aggregate constituent realm or the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them there the aggregate of perception arose, but the aggregate of feeling does not arise for them there. For those being reborn in the four-aggregate constituent realm or the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them there both the aggregate of perception arose and the aggregate of feeling arises.

Negative Person

74. For whom the aggregate of matter does not arise, had the aggregate of feeling not arisen for that one? It had arisen.

Or else, for whom the aggregate of feeling had not arisen, does the aggregate of matter not arise for that one? There is not.

75. For whom the aggregate of feeling does not arise, had the aggregate of perception not arisen for that one? It had arisen.

Or else, for whom the aggregate of perception had not arisen, does the aggregate of feeling not arise for that one? There is not.

The Negative Section on Place

76. Where the aggregate of matter does not arise, had the aggregate of feeling not arisen there? It had arisen.

Or else, where the aggregate of feeling had not arisen, does the aggregate of matter not arise there? It arises.

77. Where the aggregate of feeling does not arise, did the aggregate of perception not arise there? Yes.

Or else, where the aggregate of perception had not arisen, does the aggregate of feeling not arise there? Yes.

Negative - Person - Place

78. For whom and where the aggregate of matter does not arise, had the aggregate of feeling not arisen for that one there?

For those passing away from the five-aggregate constituent realm to the immaterial realm, for them there the aggregate of matter does not arise, but the aggregate of feeling had arisen for them there. For those attaining final nibbana in the Pure Abodes, for those passing away from the non-percipient being realm, for them there both the aggregate of matter does not arise and the aggregate of feeling had not arisen.

Or else, for whom and where the aggregate of feeling had not arisen, does the aggregate of matter not arise for that one there?

For those being reborn in the Pure Abodes, for those being reborn in the non-percipient being realm, for them there the aggregate of feeling had not arisen, but the aggregate of matter does arise for them there. For those attaining final nibbana in the Pure Abodes, for those passing away from the non-percipient being realm, for them there both the aggregate of feeling had not arisen and the aggregate of matter does not arise.

79. For whom and where the aggregate of feeling does not arise, had the aggregate of perception not arisen for that one there?

For those passing away from the four-aggregate constituent realm or the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them there the aggregate of feeling does not arise, but the aggregate of perception had arisen for them there. For those attaining final nibbana in the Pure Abodes, for non-percipient beings, for them there both the aggregate of feeling does not arise and the aggregate of perception had not arisen.

Or else, for whom and where the aggregate of perception had not arisen, does the aggregate of feeling not arise for that one there?

For those being reborn in the Pure Abodes, for them there the aggregate of perception had not arisen, but the aggregate of feeling does arise for them there. For those attaining final nibbana in the Pure Abodes, for non-percipient beings, for them there both the aggregate of perception had not arisen and the aggregate of feeling does not arise.

(5) The Section on Present and Future

Conformity Person

80. For whom the aggregate of matter arises, will the aggregate of feeling arise for that one?

For those in their last existence being reborn in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them the aggregate of matter arises, but the aggregate of feeling will not arise for them. For the others being reborn in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for those being reborn in the non-percipient being realm, for them both the aggregate of matter arises and the aggregate of feeling will arise.

Or else, for whom the aggregate of feeling will arise, does the aggregate of matter arise for that one?

For all those passing away being reborn in the immaterial realm, for them the aggregate of feeling will arise, but the aggregate of matter does not arise for them. For those being reborn in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for those being reborn in the non-percipient being realm, for them both the aggregate of feeling will arise and the aggregate of matter arises.

81. For whom the aggregate of feeling arises, will the aggregate of perception arise for that one?

For those in their last existence being reborn, for them the aggregate of feeling arises, but the aggregate of perception will not arise for them. For the others being reborn in the four-aggregate constituent realm or the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them both the aggregate of feeling arises and the aggregate of perception will arise.

Or else, for whom the aggregate of perception will arise, does the aggregate of feeling arise for that one?

For all those passing away being reborn in the non-percipient being realm, for them the aggregate of perception will arise, but the aggregate of feeling does not arise for them. For those being reborn in the four-aggregate constituent realm or the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them both the aggregate of perception will arise and the aggregate of feeling arises.

Conformity Place

82. Where the aggregate of matter arises, will the aggregate of feeling arise there?

In the non-percipient being realm, there the aggregate of matter arises, but the aggregate of feeling will not arise there. In the five-aggregate constituent realm, there both the aggregate of matter arises and the aggregate of feeling will arise.

Or else, where the aggregate of feeling will arise, does the aggregate of matter arise there?

In the immaterial-sphere of existence, there the aggregate of feeling will arise, but the aggregate of matter does not arise there. In the five-aggregate constituent realm, there both the aggregate of feeling will arise and the aggregate of matter arises.

83. Where the aggregate of feeling arises, will the aggregate of perception arise there? Yes.

Or else, where the aggregate of perception will arise, does the aggregate of feeling arise there? Yes.

Conformity - Person - Place

84. For whom and where the aggregate of matter arises, will the aggregate of feeling arise for that one there?

For those in their last existence being reborn in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for those being reborn in the non-percipient being realm, for them there the aggregate of matter arises, but the aggregate of feeling will not arise for them there. For the others being reborn in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them there both the aggregate of matter arises and the aggregate of feeling will arise.

Or else, for whom and where the aggregate of feeling will arise, does the aggregate of matter arise for that one there?

For those passing away from the five-aggregate constituent realm to the immaterial realm, for them there the aggregate of feeling will arise, but the aggregate of matter does not arise for them there. For those being reborn in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them there both the aggregate of feeling will arise and the aggregate of matter arises.

85. For whom and where the aggregate of feeling arises, will the aggregate of perception arise for that one there?

For those in their last existence who are being reborn, for them there the aggregate of feeling arises, but the aggregate of perception will not arise for them there. For the others being reborn in the four-aggregate constituent realm or the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them there both the aggregate of feeling arises and the aggregate of perception will arise.

Or else, for whom and where the aggregate of perception will arise, does the aggregate of feeling arise for that one there?

For those passing away from the four-aggregate constituent realm or the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them there the aggregate of perception will arise, but the aggregate of feeling does not arise for them there. For those being reborn in the four-aggregate constituent realm or the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them there both the aggregate of perception will arise and the aggregate of feeling arises.

Negative Person

86. For whom the aggregate of matter does not arise, will the aggregate of feeling not arise for that one?

For all those passing away, for those being reborn in the immaterial realm, for them the aggregate of matter does not arise, but the aggregate of feeling will not fail to arise for them. For those attaining final nibbāna in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for those in their last existence in the immaterial-sphere of existence, for them both the aggregate of matter does not arise and the aggregate of feeling will not arise.

Or else, for whom the aggregate of feeling will not arise, does the aggregate of matter not arise for that one?

For those in their last existence being reborn in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them the aggregate of feeling will not arise, but the aggregate of matter does arise for them. For those attaining final nibbāna in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for those in their last existence in the immaterial-sphere of existence, for them both the aggregate of feeling will not arise and the aggregate of matter does not arise.

87. For whom the aggregate of feeling does not arise, will the aggregate of perception not arise for that one?

For all those passing away being reborn in the non-percipient being realm, for them the aggregate of feeling does not arise, but the aggregate of perception will arise for them. For those attaining final nibbāna, for them both the aggregate of feeling does not arise and the aggregate of perception will not arise.

Or else, for whom the aggregate of perception will not arise, does the aggregate of feeling not arise for that one?

For those in their last existence being reborn, for them the aggregate of perception will not arise, but the aggregate of feeling does arise for them. For those attaining final nibbāna, for them both the aggregate of perception will not arise and the aggregate of feeling does not arise.

The Negative Section on Place

88. Where the aggregate of matter does not arise, will the aggregate of feeling not arise there? It will arise.

Or else, where the aggregate of feeling will not arise, does the aggregate of matter not arise there? It arises.

89. Where the aggregate of feeling does not arise, will the aggregate of perception not arise there? Yes.

Or else, where the aggregate of perception will not arise, does the aggregate of feeling not arise there? Yes.

Negative - Person - Place

90. For whom and where the aggregate of matter does not arise, will the aggregate of feeling not arise for that one there?

For those passing away from the five-aggregate constituent realm to the immaterial realm, for them there the aggregate of matter does not arise, but the aggregate of feeling will not fail to arise for them there. For those attaining final nibbāna in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for those in their last existence in the immaterial-sphere of existence, for those passing away from the non-percipient being realm, for them there both the aggregate of matter does not arise and the aggregate of feeling will not arise.

Or else, for whom and where the aggregate of feeling will not arise, does the aggregate of matter not arise for that one there?

For those in their last existence being reborn in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for those being reborn in the non-percipient being realm, for them there the aggregate of feeling will not arise, but the aggregate of matter does not fail to arise for them there. For those attaining final nibbāna in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for those in their last existence in the immaterial-sphere of existence, for those passing away from the non-percipient being realm, for them there both the aggregate of feeling will not arise and the aggregate of matter does not arise.

91. For whom and where the aggregate of feeling does not arise, will the aggregate of perception not arise for that one there?

For those passing away from the four-aggregate constituent realm or the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them there the aggregate of feeling does not arise, but the aggregate of perception will not fail to arise for them there. For non-percipient beings attaining final nibbāna, for them there both the aggregate of feeling does not arise and the aggregate of perception will not arise.

Or else, for whom and where the aggregate of perception will not arise, does the aggregate of feeling not arise for that one there?

For those in their last existence who are being reborn, for them there the aggregate of perception will not arise, but the aggregate of feeling does not fail to arise for them there. For non-percipient beings attaining final nibbāna, for them there both the aggregate of perception will not arise and the aggregate of feeling does not arise.

(6) The Section on Past and Future

Conformity Person

92. For whom the aggregate of matter arose, will the aggregate of feeling arise for that one?

For those in their last existence, for them the aggregate of matter arose, but the aggregate of feeling will not arise for them. For the others, for them both the aggregate of matter arose and the aggregate of feeling will arise.

Or else, for whom the aggregate of feeling will arise, did the aggregate of matter arise for that one? Yes.

93. For whom the aggregate of feeling arose, will the aggregate of perception arise for that one?

For those in their last existence, for them the aggregate of feeling arose, but the aggregate of perception will not arise for them. For the others, for them both the aggregate of feeling arose and the aggregate of perception will arise.

Or else, for whom the aggregate of perception will arise, did the aggregate of feeling arise for that one? Yes.

Conformity Place

94. Where the aggregate of matter arose, will the aggregate of feeling arise there?

In the non-percipient being realm, there the aggregate of matter arose, but the aggregate of feeling will not arise there. In the five-aggregate constituent realm, there both the aggregate of matter arose and the aggregate of feeling will arise.

Or else, where the aggregate of feeling will arise, did the aggregate of matter arise there?

In the immaterial-sphere of existence, there the aggregate of feeling will arise, but the aggregate of matter did not arise there. In the five-aggregate constituent realm, there both the aggregate of feeling will arise and the aggregate of matter arose.

95. Where the aggregate of feeling arose, will the aggregate of perception arise there? Yes.

Or else, where the aggregate of perception will arise, did the aggregate of feeling arise there? Yes.

Conformity - Person - Place

96. For whom and where the aggregate of matter arose, will the aggregate of feeling arise for that one there?

For beings in their last existence among non-percipient beings in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them there the aggregate of matter arose, but the aggregate of feeling will not arise for them there. For the other five-aggregate constituent beings, for them there both the aggregate of matter arose and the aggregate of feeling will arise.

Or else, for whom and where the aggregate of feeling will arise, did the aggregate of matter arise for that one there?

For immaterial beings, for them there the aggregate of feeling will arise, but the aggregate of matter did not arise for them there. For five-aggregate constituent beings, for them there both the aggregate of feeling will arise and the aggregate of matter arose.

97. For whom and where the aggregate of feeling arose, will the aggregate of perception arise for that one there?

For those in their last existence, for them there the aggregate of feeling arose, but the aggregate of perception will not arise for them there. For the others, the four-aggregate constituent beings and the five-aggregate constituent beings, for them there both the aggregate of feeling arose and the aggregate of perception will arise.

Or else, for whom and where the aggregate of perception will arise, did the aggregate of feeling arise for that one there? Yes.

Negative Person

98. For whom the aggregate of matter had not arisen, will the aggregate of feeling not arise for that one? There is not.

Or else, for whom the aggregate of feeling will not arise, had the aggregate of matter not arisen for that one? It had arisen.

99. For whom the aggregate of feeling had not arisen, will the aggregate of perception not arise for that one? There is not.

Or else, for whom the aggregate of perception will not arise, had the aggregate of feeling not arisen for that one? It had arisen.

The Negative Section on Place

100. Where the aggregate of matter had not arisen, will the aggregate of feeling not arise there? It will arise.

Or else, where the aggregate of feeling will not arise, had the aggregate of matter not arisen there? It had arisen.

101. Where the aggregate of feeling had not arisen, will the aggregate of perception not arise there? Yes.

Or else, where the aggregate of perception will not arise, had the aggregate of feeling not arisen there? Yes.

Negative - Person - Place

102. For whom and where the aggregate of matter had not arisen, will the aggregate of feeling not arise for that one there?

For immaterial beings, for them there the aggregate of matter had not arisen, but the aggregate of feeling will not fail to arise for them there. For those in the Pure Abodes, for those in their last existence in the immaterial-sphere of existence, for them there both the aggregate of matter had not arisen and the aggregate of feeling will not arise.

Or else, for whom and where the aggregate of feeling will not arise, had the aggregate of matter not arisen for that one there?

For those in their last existence in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for non-percipient beings, for them there the aggregate of feeling will not arise, but the aggregate of matter had not not arisen for them there. For those in the Pure Abodes, for those in their last existence in the immaterial-sphere of existence, for them there both the aggregate of feeling will not arise and the aggregate of matter had not arisen.

103. For whom and where the aggregate of feeling had not arisen, will the aggregate of perception not arise for that one there? Yes.

Or else, for whom and where the aggregate of perception will not arise, had the aggregate of feeling not arisen for that one there?

For those in their last existence, for them there the aggregate of perception will not arise, but the aggregate of feeling had not failed to arise for them there. For those in the Pure Abodes and for non-percipient beings, for them there both the aggregate of perception will not arise and the aggregate of feeling had not arisen.

The Section on Arising is concluded.

2.

Occurrence 2.

The Section on Cessation

(1) The Section on the Present

Conformity Person

104. For whom the aggregate of matter ceases, does the aggregate of feeling cease for that one?

For those passing away from the non-percipient being realm, for them the aggregate of matter ceases, but the aggregate of feeling does not cease for them. For those passing away from the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them both the aggregate of matter ceases and the aggregate of feeling ceases.

Or else, for whom the aggregate of feeling ceases, does the aggregate of matter cease for that one?

For those passing away from the immaterial realm, for them the aggregate of feeling ceases, but the aggregate of matter does not cease for them. For those passing away from the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them both the aggregate of feeling ceases and the aggregate of matter ceases.

Conformity Place

105. Where the aggregate of matter ceases, does the aggregate of feeling cease there?

In the non-percipient being realm, there the aggregate of matter ceases, but the aggregate of feeling does not cease there. In the five-aggregate constituent realm, there both the aggregate of matter ceases and the aggregate of feeling ceases.

Or else, where the aggregate of feeling ceases, does the aggregate of matter cease there?

In the immaterial-sphere of existence, there the aggregate of feeling ceases, but the aggregate of matter does not cease there. In the five-aggregate constituent realm, there both the aggregate of feeling ceases and the aggregate of matter ceases.

Conformity - Person - Place

106. For whom and where the aggregate of matter ceases, does the aggregate of feeling cease for that one there?

For those passing away from the non-percipient being realm, for them there the aggregate of matter ceases, but the aggregate of feeling does not cease for them there. For those passing away from the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them there both the aggregate of matter ceases and the aggregate of feeling ceases.

Or else, for whom and where the aggregate of feeling ceases, does the aggregate of matter cease for that one there?

For those passing away from the immaterial realm, for them there the aggregate of feeling ceases, but the aggregate of matter does not cease for them there. For those passing away from the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them there both the aggregate of feeling ceases and the aggregate of matter ceases.

Negative Person

107. For whom the aggregate of matter does not cease, does the aggregate of feeling not cease for that one?

For those passing away from the immaterial realm, for them the aggregate of matter does not cease, but the aggregate of feeling does cease for them. For all those being reborn, for them both the aggregate of matter does not cease and the aggregate of feeling does not cease.

Or else, for whom the aggregate of feeling does not cease, does the aggregate of matter not cease for that one?

For those passing away from the non-percipient being realm, for them the aggregate of feeling does not cease, but the aggregate of matter does cease for them. For all those being reborn, for them both the aggregate of feeling does not cease and the aggregate of matter does not cease.

The Negative Section on Place

108. Where the aggregate of matter does not cease, does the aggregate of feeling not cease there? It ceases.

Or else, where the aggregate of feeling does not cease, does the aggregate of matter not cease there? It ceases.

Negative - Person - Place

109. For whom and where the aggregate of matter does not cease, does the aggregate of feeling not cease for that one there?

For those passing away from the immaterial realm, for them there the aggregate of matter does not cease, but the aggregate of feeling does cease for them there. For all those being reborn, for them there both the aggregate of matter does not cease and the aggregate of feeling does not cease.

Or else, for whom and where the aggregate of feeling does not cease, does the aggregate of matter not cease for that one there?

For those passing away from the non-percipient being realm, for them there the aggregate of feeling does not cease, but the aggregate of matter does cease for them there. For all those being reborn, for them there both the aggregate of feeling does not cease and the aggregate of matter does not cease.

(2) The Section on the Past

Conformity Person

110. For whom the aggregate of matter had ceased, did the aggregate of feeling cease for that one? Yes.

Or else, for whom the aggregate of feeling had ceased, did the aggregate of matter cease for that one? Yes.

Conformity Place

111. Where the aggregate of matter had ceased, did the aggregate of feeling cease there?

In the non-percipient being realm, there the aggregate of matter had ceased, but the aggregate of feeling had not ceased there. In the five-aggregate constituent realm, there both the aggregate of matter had ceased and the aggregate of feeling had ceased.

Or else, where the aggregate of feeling had ceased, did the aggregate of matter cease there?

In the immaterial-sphere of existence, there the aggregate of feeling had ceased, but the aggregate of matter had not ceased there. In the five-aggregate constituent realm, there both the aggregate of feeling had ceased and the aggregate of matter had ceased.

Conformity - Person - Place

112. For whom and where the aggregate of matter had ceased, did the aggregate of feeling cease for that one there?

For non-percipient beings, for them there the aggregate of matter had ceased, but the aggregate of feeling had not ceased for them there. For five-aggregate constituent beings, for them there both the aggregate of matter had ceased and the aggregate of feeling had ceased.

Or else, for whom and where the aggregate of feeling had ceased, did the aggregate of matter cease for that one there?

For immaterial beings, for them there the aggregate of feeling had ceased, but the aggregate of matter had not ceased for them there. For five-aggregate constituent beings, for them there both the aggregate of feeling had ceased and the aggregate of matter had ceased.

Negative Person

113. For whom the aggregate of matter had not ceased, did the aggregate of feeling not cease for that one? There is not.

Or else, for whom the aggregate of feeling had not ceased, did the aggregate of matter not cease for that one? There is not.

The Negative Section on Place

114. Where the aggregate of matter had not ceased, did the aggregate of feeling not cease there? It had ceased.

Or else, where the aggregate of feeling had not ceased, did the aggregate of matter not cease there? It had ceased.

Negative - Person - Place

115. For whom and where the aggregate of matter had not ceased, did the aggregate of feeling not cease for that one there?

For immaterial beings, for them there the aggregate of matter had not ceased, but the aggregate of feeling had not not ceased for them there. For those in the Pure Abodes, for them there both the aggregate of matter had not ceased and the aggregate of feeling had not ceased.

Or else, for whom and where the aggregate of feeling had not ceased, did the aggregate of matter not cease for that one there?

For non-percipient beings, for them there the aggregate of feeling had not ceased, but the aggregate of matter had not not ceased for them there. For those in the Pure Abodes, for them there both the aggregate of feeling had not ceased and the aggregate of matter had not ceased.

(3) The Section on the Future

Conformity Person

116. For whom the aggregate of matter will cease, will the aggregate of feeling cease for that one? Yes.

Or else, for whom the aggregate of feeling will cease, will the aggregate of matter cease for that one?

For those in their last existence being reborn in the immaterial realm, and for those who, having been reborn in the immaterial realm, will attain final nibbāna, for them passing away, for them the aggregate of feeling will cease, but the aggregate of matter will not cease for them. For the others, for them both the aggregate of feeling will cease and the aggregate of matter will cease.

Conformity Place

117. Where the aggregate of matter will cease, will the aggregate of feeling cease there?

In the non-percipient being realm, there the aggregate of matter will cease, but the aggregate of feeling will not cease there. In the five-aggregate constituent realm, there both the aggregate of matter will cease and the aggregate of feeling will cease.

Or else, where the aggregate of feeling will cease, will the aggregate of matter cease there?

In the immaterial-sphere of existence, there the aggregate of feeling will cease, but the aggregate of matter will not cease there. In the five-aggregate constituent realm, there both the aggregate of feeling will cease and the aggregate of matter will cease.

Conformity - Person - Place

118. For whom and where the aggregate of matter will cease, will the aggregate of feeling cease for that one there?

For non-percipient beings, for them there the aggregate of matter will cease, but the aggregate of feeling will not cease for them there. For five-aggregate constituent beings, for them there both the aggregate of matter will cease and the aggregate of feeling will cease.

Or else, for whom and where the aggregate of feeling will cease, will the aggregate of matter cease for that one there?

For immaterial beings, for them there the aggregate of feeling will cease, but the aggregate of matter will not cease for them there. For five-aggregate constituent beings, for them there both the aggregate of feeling will cease and the aggregate of matter will cease.

Negative Person

119. For whom the aggregate of matter will not cease, will the aggregate of feeling not cease for that one?

For those in their last existence being reborn in the immaterial realm, and for those who, having been reborn in the immaterial realm, will attain final nibbāna, for them passing away, for them the aggregate of matter will not cease, but the aggregate of feeling will cease for them. For those attaining final nibbāna, for them both the aggregate of matter will not cease and the aggregate of feeling will not cease.

Or else, for whom the aggregate of feeling will not cease, will the aggregate of matter not cease for that one? Yes.

The Negative Section on Place

120. Where the aggregate of matter will not cease, will the aggregate of feeling not cease there? It will cease.

Or else, where the aggregate of feeling will not cease, will the aggregate of matter not cease there? It will cease.

Negative - Person - Place

121. For whom and where the aggregate of matter will not cease, will the aggregate of feeling not cease for that one there?

For immaterial beings, for them there the aggregate of matter will not cease, but the aggregate of feeling will cease for them there. For those attaining final nibbāna, for them there both the aggregate of matter will not cease and the aggregate of feeling will not cease.

Or else, for whom and where the aggregate of feeling will not cease, will the aggregate of matter not cease for that one there?

For non-percipient beings, for them there the aggregate of feeling will not cease, but the aggregate of matter will cease for them there. For those attaining final nibbāna, for them there both the aggregate of feeling will not cease and the aggregate of matter will not cease.

(4) The Section on Present and Past

Conformity Person

122. For whom the aggregate of matter ceases, did the aggregate of feeling cease for that one? Yes.

Or else, for whom the aggregate of feeling had ceased, does the aggregate of matter cease for that one?

For all those being reborn, for those passing away from the immaterial realm, for them the aggregate of feeling had ceased, but the aggregate of matter does not cease for them. For those passing away from the five-aggregate constituent realm, for those passing away from the non-percipient being realm, for them both the aggregate of feeling had ceased and the aggregate of matter ceases.

123. For whom the aggregate of feeling ceases, did the aggregate of perception cease for that one? Yes.

Or else, for whom the aggregate of perception had ceased, does the aggregate of feeling cease for that one?

For all those being reborn, for those passing away from the non-percipient being realm, for them the aggregate of perception had ceased, but the aggregate of feeling does not cease for them. For those passing away from the four-aggregate constituent realm or the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them both the aggregate of perception had ceased and the aggregate of feeling ceases.

Conformity Place

124. Where the aggregate of matter ceases, did the aggregate of feeling cease there?

In the non-percipient being realm, there the aggregate of matter ceases, but the aggregate of feeling had not ceased there. In the five-aggregate constituent realm, there both the aggregate of matter ceases and the aggregate of feeling had ceased.

Or else, where the aggregate of feeling had ceased, does the aggregate of matter cease there?

In the immaterial-sphere of existence, there the aggregate of feeling had ceased, but the aggregate of matter does not cease there. In the five-aggregate constituent realm, there both the aggregate of feeling had ceased and the aggregate of matter ceases.

125. Where the aggregate of feeling ceases, did the aggregate of perception cease there? Yes.

Or else, where the aggregate of perception had ceased, does the aggregate of feeling cease there? Yes.

Conformity - Person - Place

126. For whom and where the aggregate of matter ceases, did the aggregate of feeling cease for that one there?

For those attaining final nibbana in the Pure Abodes, for those passing away from the non-percipient being realm, for them there the aggregate of matter ceases, but the aggregate of feeling had not ceased for them there. For the others passing away from the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them there both the aggregate of matter ceases and the aggregate of feeling had ceased.

Or else, for whom and where the aggregate of feeling had ceased, does the aggregate of matter cease for that one there?

For those being reborn in the five-aggregate constituent realm from the immaterial realm, for them there the aggregate of feeling had ceased, but the aggregate of matter does not cease for them there. For those passing away from the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them there both the aggregate of feeling had ceased and the aggregate of matter ceases.

127. For whom and where the aggregate of feeling ceases, did the aggregate of perception cease for that one there?

For those attaining final nibbana in the Pure Abodes, for them there the aggregate of feeling ceases, but the aggregate of perception had not ceased for them there. For the others passing away from the four-aggregate constituent realm or the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them there both the aggregate of feeling ceases and the aggregate of perception had ceased.

Or else, for whom and where the aggregate of perception had ceased, does the aggregate of feeling cease for that one there?

For those being reborn in the four-aggregate constituent realm or the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them there the aggregate of perception had ceased, but the aggregate of feeling does not cease for them there. For those passing away from the four-aggregate constituent realm or the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them there both the aggregate of perception had ceased and the aggregate of feeling ceases.

Negative Person

128. For whom the aggregate of matter does not cease, did the aggregate of feeling not cease for that one? It had ceased.

Or else, for whom the aggregate of feeling had not ceased, does the aggregate of matter not cease for that one? There is not.

129. For whom the aggregate of feeling does not cease, did the aggregate of perception not cease for that one? It had ceased.

Or else, for whom the aggregate of perception had not ceased, does the aggregate of feeling not cease for that one? There is not.

The Negative Section on Place

130. Where the aggregate of matter does not cease (the 'where' section should be completed in full).

Negative - Person - Place

131. For whom and where the aggregate of matter does not cease, did the aggregate of feeling not cease for that one there?

For those being reborn in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for those in the immaterial realm, for them there the aggregate of matter does not cease, but the aggregate of feeling had ceased for them there. For those being reborn in the pure abode, for those being reborn in the non-percipient being realm, for them there both the aggregate of matter does not cease and the aggregate of feeling had not ceased.

Or else, for whom and where the aggregate of feeling had not ceased, does the aggregate of matter not cease for that one there?

For those attaining final nibbana in the Pure Abodes, for those passing away from the non-percipient being realm, for them there the aggregate of feeling had not ceased, but the aggregate of matter does cease for them there. For those being reborn in the pure abode, for those being reborn in the non-percipient being realm, for them there both the aggregate of feeling had not ceased and the aggregate of matter does not cease.

132. For whom and where the aggregate of feeling does not cease, did the aggregate of perception not cease for that one there?

For those being reborn in the four-aggregate constituent realm or the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them there the aggregate of feeling does not cease, but the aggregate of perception had not not ceased for them there. For those being reborn in the pure abode, for non-percipient beings, for them there both the aggregate of feeling does not cease and the aggregate of perception had not ceased.

Or else, for whom and where the aggregate of perception had not ceased, does the aggregate of feeling not cease for that one there?

For those attaining final nibbana in the Pure Abodes, for them there the aggregate of perception had not ceased, but the aggregate of feeling does cease for them there. For those being reborn in the pure abode, for non-percipient beings, for them there both the aggregate of perception had not ceased and the aggregate of feeling does not cease.

(5) The Section on Present and Future

Conformity Person

133. For whom the aggregate of matter ceases, will the aggregate of feeling cease for that one?

For those attaining final nibbāna in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them the aggregate of matter ceases, but the aggregate of feeling will not cease for them. For the others passing away from the five-aggregate constituent realm, for those passing away from the non-percipient being realm, for them both the aggregate of matter ceases and the aggregate of feeling will cease.

Or else, for whom the aggregate of feeling will cease, does the aggregate of matter cease for that one?

For all those being reborn, for those passing away from the immaterial realm, for them the aggregate of feeling will cease, but the aggregate of matter does not cease for them. For those passing away from the five-aggregate constituent realm, for those passing away from the non-percipient being realm, for them both the aggregate of feeling will cease and the aggregate of matter ceases.

134. For whom the aggregate of feeling ceases, will the aggregate of perception cease for that one?

For those attaining final nibbana, for them the aggregate of feeling ceases, but the aggregate of perception will not cease for them. For the others passing away from the four-aggregate constituent realm or the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them both the aggregate of feeling ceases and the aggregate of perception will cease.

Or else, for whom the aggregate of perception will cease, does the aggregate of feeling cease for that one?

For all those being reborn, for those passing away from the non-percipient being realm, for them the aggregate of perception will cease, but the aggregate of feeling does not cease for them. For those passing away from the four-aggregate constituent realm or the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them both the aggregate of perception will cease and the aggregate of feeling ceases.

Conformity Place

135. Where the aggregate of matter ceases... etc.

Conformity - Person - Place

136. For whom and where the aggregate of matter ceases, will the aggregate of feeling cease for that one there?

For those attaining final nibbana in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for those passing away from the non-percipient being realm, for them there the aggregate of matter ceases, but the aggregate of feeling will not cease for them there. For the others passing away from the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them there both the aggregate of matter ceases and the aggregate of feeling will cease.

Or else, for whom and where the aggregate of feeling will cease, does the aggregate of matter cease for that one there?

For those being reborn in the five-aggregate constituent realm from the immaterial realm, for them there the aggregate of feeling will cease, but the aggregate of matter does not cease for them there. For those passing away from the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them there both the aggregate of feeling will cease and the aggregate of matter ceases.

137. For whom and where the aggregate of feeling ceases, will the aggregate of perception cease for that one there?

For those attaining final nibbana, for them there the aggregate of feeling ceases, but the aggregate of perception will not cease for them there. For the others passing away from the four-aggregate constituent realm or the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them there both the aggregate of feeling ceases and the aggregate of perception will cease.

Or else, for whom and where the aggregate of perception will cease, does the aggregate of feeling cease for that one there?

For those being reborn in the four-aggregate constituent realm or the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them there the aggregate of perception will cease, but the aggregate of feeling does not cease for them there. For those passing away from the four-aggregate constituent realm or the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them there both the aggregate of perception will cease and the aggregate of feeling ceases.

Negative Person

138. For whom the aggregate of matter does not cease, will the aggregate of feeling not cease for that one?

For all those being reborn, for those passing away from the immaterial realm, for them the aggregate of matter does not cease, but the aggregate of feeling will cease for them. For those attaining final nibbāna in the immaterial-sphere of existence, for them both the aggregate of matter does not cease and the aggregate of feeling will not cease.

Or else, for whom the aggregate of feeling will not cease, does the aggregate of matter not cease for that one?

For those attaining final nibbāna in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them the aggregate of feeling will not cease, but the aggregate of matter does cease for them. For those attaining final nibbāna in the immaterial-sphere of existence, for them both the aggregate of feeling will not cease and the aggregate of matter does not cease.

139. For whom the aggregate of feeling does not cease, will the aggregate of perception not cease for that one? It will cease.

Or else, for whom the aggregate of perception will not cease, does the aggregate of feeling not cease for that one? It ceases.

The Negative Section on Place

140. Where the aggregate of matter does not cease... etc.

Negative - Person - Place

141. For whom and where the aggregate of matter does not cease, will the aggregate of feeling not cease for that one there?

For those being reborn in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for those in the immaterial realm, for them there the aggregate of matter does not cease, but the aggregate of feeling will cease for them there. For those attaining final nibbāna in the immaterial-sphere of existence, for those being reborn in the non-percipient being realm, for them there both the aggregate of matter does not cease and the aggregate of feeling will not cease.

Or else, for whom and where the aggregate of feeling will not cease, does the aggregate of matter not cease for that one there?

For those attaining final nibbāna in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for those passing away from the non-percipient being realm, for them there the aggregate of feeling will not cease, but the aggregate of matter ceases for them there. For those attaining final nibbāna in the immaterial-sphere of existence, for those being reborn in the non-percipient being realm, for them there both the aggregate of feeling will not cease and the aggregate of matter does not cease.

142. For whom and where the aggregate of feeling does not cease, will the aggregate of perception not cease for that one there?

For those being reborn in the four-aggregate constituent realm or the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them there the aggregate of feeling does not cease, but the aggregate of perception will not not cease for them there. For non-percipient beings, for them there both the aggregate of feeling does not cease and the aggregate of perception will not cease.

Or else, for whom and where the aggregate of perception will not cease, does the aggregate of feeling not cease for that one there?

For those attaining final nibbāna, for them there the aggregate of perception will not cease, but the aggregate of feeling does cease for them there. For non-percipient beings, for them there both the aggregate of perception will not cease and the aggregate of feeling does not cease.

(6) The Section on Past and Future

Conformity Person

143. For whom the aggregate of matter had ceased, will the aggregate of feeling cease for that one?

For those attaining final nibbāna, for them the aggregate of matter had ceased, but the aggregate of feeling will not cease for them. For the others, for them both the aggregate of matter had ceased and the aggregate of feeling will cease.

Or else, for whom the aggregate of feeling will cease, did the aggregate of matter cease for that one? Yes.

144. For whom the aggregate of feeling had ceased, will the aggregate of perception cease for that one?

For those attaining final nibbana, for them the aggregate of feeling had ceased, but the aggregate of perception will not cease for them. For the others, for them both the aggregate of feeling had ceased and the aggregate of perception will cease.

Or else, for whom the aggregate of perception will cease, did the aggregate of feeling cease for that one? Yes.

Conformity Place

145. Where the aggregate of matter had ceased... etc.

Conformity - Person - Place

146. For whom and where the aggregate of matter had ceased, will the aggregate of feeling cease for that one there?

For those attaining final nibbāna in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for non-percipient beings, for them there the aggregate of matter had ceased, but the aggregate of feeling will not cease for them there. For the other five-aggregate constituent beings, for them there both the aggregate of matter had ceased and the aggregate of feeling will cease.

Or else, for whom and where the aggregate of feeling will cease, did the aggregate of matter cease for that one there?

For those being reborn in the pure abode from the immaterial realm, for them there the aggregate of feeling will cease, but the aggregate of matter had not ceased for them there. For the other five-aggregate constituent beings, for them there both the aggregate of feeling will cease and the aggregate of matter had ceased.

147. For whom and where the aggregate of feeling had ceased, will the aggregate of perception cease for that one there?

For those attaining final nibbana, for them there the aggregate of feeling had ceased, but the aggregate of perception will not cease for them there. For the others, the four-aggregate constituent beings and the five-aggregate constituent beings, for them there both the aggregate of feeling had ceased and the aggregate of perception will cease.

Or else, for whom and where the aggregate of perception will cease, did the aggregate of feeling cease for that one there?

For those being reborn in the pure abode, for them there the aggregate of perception will cease, but the aggregate of feeling had not ceased for them there. For the others, the four-aggregate constituent beings and the five-aggregate constituent beings, for them there both the aggregate of perception will cease and the aggregate of feeling had ceased.

Negative Person

148. For whom the aggregate of matter had not ceased, will the aggregate of feeling not cease for that one? There is not.

Or else, for whom the aggregate of feeling will not cease, had the aggregate of matter not ceased for that one? It had ceased.

149. For whom the aggregate of feeling had not ceased, will the aggregate of perception not cease for that one? There is not.

Or else, for whom the aggregate of perception will not cease, did the aggregate of feeling not cease for that one? It had ceased.

The Negative Section on Place

150. Where the aggregate of matter had not ceased... etc.

Negative - Person - Place

151. For whom and where the aggregate of matter had not ceased, will the aggregate of feeling not cease for that one there?

For those being reborn in the Pure Abodes, for immaterial beings, for them there the aggregate of matter had not ceased, but the aggregate of feeling will not not cease for them there. For those attaining final nibbāna in the Pure Abodes, for those attaining final nibbāna in the immaterial-sphere of existence, for them there both the aggregate of matter had not ceased and the aggregate of feeling will not cease.

Or else, for whom and where the aggregate of feeling will not cease, did the aggregate of matter not cease for that one there?

For those attaining final nibbāna in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for non-percipient beings, for them there the aggregate of feeling will not cease, but the aggregate of matter had not not ceased for them there. For those attaining final nibbāna in the Pure Abodes, for those attaining final nibbāna in the immaterial-sphere of existence, for them there both the aggregate of feeling will not cease and the aggregate of matter had not ceased.

152. For whom and where the aggregate of feeling had not ceased, will the aggregate of perception not cease for that one there?

For those being reborn in the Pure Abodes, for them there the aggregate of feeling had not ceased, but the aggregate of perception will not not cease for them there. For those attaining final nibbāna in the Pure Abodes, for non-percipient beings, for them there both the aggregate of feeling had not ceased and the aggregate of perception will not cease.

Or else, for whom and where the aggregate of perception will not cease, did the aggregate of feeling not cease for that one there?

For those attaining final nibbāna, for them there the aggregate of perception will not cease, but the aggregate of feeling had not not ceased for them there. For those attaining final nibbāna in the Pure Abodes, for non-percipient beings, for them there both the aggregate of perception will not cease and the aggregate of feeling had not ceased.

The Section on Cessation.

3.

The Section on Arising and Cessation

(1) The Section on the Present

Conformity Person

153. For whom the aggregate of matter arises, does the aggregate of feeling cease for that one? No.

Or else, for whom the aggregate of feeling ceases, does the aggregate of matter arise for that one? No.

154. For whom the aggregate of feeling arises, does the aggregate of perception cease for that one? No.

Or else, for whom the aggregate of perception ceases, does the aggregate of feeling arise for that one? No.

Conformity Place

155. Where the aggregate of matter arises, does the aggregate of feeling cease there?

In the non-percipient being realm, there the aggregate of matter arises, but the aggregate of feeling does not cease there. In the five-aggregate constituent realm, there both the aggregate of matter arises and the aggregate of feeling ceases.

Or else, where the aggregate of feeling ceases, does the aggregate of matter arise there?

In the immaterial-sphere of existence, there the aggregate of feeling ceases, but the aggregate of matter does not arise there. In the five-aggregate constituent realm, there both the aggregate of feeling ceases and the aggregate of matter arises.

156. Where the aggregate of feeling arises, does the aggregate of perception cease there? Yes.

Or else, where the aggregate of perception ceases, does the aggregate of feeling arise there? Yes.

Conformity - Person - Place

157. For whom and where the aggregate of matter arises, does the aggregate of feeling cease for that one there? No.

Or else, for whom and where the aggregate of feeling ceases, does the aggregate of matter arise for that one there? No.

158. For whom and where the aggregate of feeling arises, does the aggregate of perception cease for that one there? No.

Or else, for whom and where the aggregate of perception ceases, does the aggregate of feeling arise for that one there? No.

Negative Person

159. For whom the aggregate of matter does not arise, does the aggregate of feeling not cease for that one?

For those passing away from the four-aggregate constituent realm or the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them the aggregate of matter does not arise, but the aggregate of feeling does cease for them. For those being reborn in the immaterial realm, for those passing away from the non-percipient being realm, for them both the aggregate of matter does not arise and the aggregate of feeling does not cease.

Or else, for whom the aggregate of feeling does not cease, does the aggregate of matter not arise for that one?

For those being reborn in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for those being reborn in the non-percipient being realm, for them the aggregate of feeling does not cease, but the aggregate of matter does arise for them. For those being reborn in the immaterial realm, for those passing away from the non-percipient being realm, for them both the aggregate of feeling does not cease and the aggregate of matter does not arise.

160. For whom the aggregate of feeling does not arise, does the aggregate of perception not cease for that one?

For those passing away from the four-aggregate constituent realm or the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them the aggregate of feeling does not arise, but the aggregate of perception does cease for them. For non-percipient beings, for them both the aggregate of feeling does not arise and the aggregate of perception does not cease.

Or else, for whom the aggregate of perception does not cease, does the aggregate of feeling not arise for that one?

For those being reborn in the four-aggregate constituent realm or the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them the aggregate of perception does not cease, but the aggregate of feeling does arise for them. For non-percipient beings, for them both the aggregate of perception does not cease and the aggregate of feeling does not arise.

The Negative Section on Place

161. Where the aggregate of matter does not arise, does the aggregate of feeling not cease there? It ceases.

Or else, where the aggregate of feeling does not cease, does the aggregate of matter not arise there? It arises.

162. Where the aggregate of feeling does not arise, does the aggregate of perception not cease there? Yes.

Or else, where the aggregate of perception does not cease, does the aggregate of feeling not arise there? Yes.

Negative - Person - Place

163. For whom and where the aggregate of matter does not arise, does the aggregate of feeling not cease for that one there?

For those passing away from the four-aggregate constituent realm or the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them there the aggregate of matter does not arise, but the aggregate of feeling does cease for them there. For those being reborn in the immaterial realm, for those passing away from the non-percipient being realm, for them there the aggregate of matter does not arise and the aggregate of feeling does not cease.

Or else, for whom and where the aggregate of feeling does not cease, does the aggregate of matter not arise for that one there?

For those being reborn in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for those being reborn in the non-percipient being realm, for them there the aggregate of feeling does not cease, but the aggregate of matter does arise for them there. For those being reborn in the immaterial realm, for those passing away from the non-percipient being realm, for them there both the aggregate of feeling does not cease and the aggregate of matter does not arise.

164. For whom and where the aggregate of feeling does not arise, does the aggregate of perception not cease for that one there?

For those passing away from the four-aggregate constituent realm or the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them there the aggregate of feeling does not arise, but the aggregate of perception does cease for them there. For non-percipient beings, for them there both the aggregate of feeling does not arise and the aggregate of perception does not cease.

Or else, for whom and where the aggregate of perception does not cease, does the aggregate of feeling not arise for that one there?

For those being reborn in the four-aggregate constituent realm or the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them there the aggregate of perception does not cease, but the aggregate of feeling does arise for them there. For non-percipient beings, for them there both the aggregate of perception does not cease and the aggregate of feeling does not arise.

(2) The Section on the Past

Conformity Person

165. For whom the aggregate of matter arose, did the aggregate of feeling cease for that one? Yes.

Or else, for whom the aggregate of feeling had ceased, did the aggregate of matter arise for that one? Yes.

166. For whom the aggregate of feeling arose, did the aggregate of perception cease for that one? Yes.

Or else, for whom the aggregate of perception had ceased, did the aggregate of feeling arise for that one? Yes.

Conformity Place

167. Where the aggregate of matter arose... etc.

Conformity - Person - Place

168. For whom and where the aggregate of matter arose, did the aggregate of feeling cease for that one there?

For non-percipient beings, for them there the aggregate of matter arose, but the aggregate of feeling had not ceased for them there. For five-aggregate constituent beings, for them there both the aggregate of matter arose and the aggregate of feeling had ceased.

Or else, for whom and where the aggregate of feeling had ceased, did the aggregate of matter arise for that one there?

For immaterial beings, for them there the aggregate of feeling had ceased, but the aggregate of matter had not arisen for them there. For five-aggregate constituent beings, for them there both the aggregate of feeling had ceased and the aggregate of matter arose.

169. For whom and where the aggregate of feeling arose, did the aggregate of perception cease for that one there? Yes.

Or else, for whom and where the aggregate of perception had ceased, did the aggregate of feeling arise for that one there? Yes.

Negative Person

170. For whom the aggregate of matter had not arisen, had the aggregate of feeling not ceased for that one? There is not.

Or else, for whom the aggregate of feeling had not ceased, had the aggregate of matter not arisen for that one? There is not.

171. For whom the aggregate of feeling had not arisen, did the aggregate of perception not cease for that one? There is not.

Or else, for whom the aggregate of perception had not ceased, had the aggregate of feeling not arisen for that one? There is not.

The Negative Section on Place

172. Where the aggregate of matter had not arisen... etc.

Negative - Person - Place

173. For whom and where the aggregate of matter had not arisen, had the aggregate of feeling not ceased for that one there?

For immaterial beings, for them there the aggregate of matter had not arisen, but the aggregate of feeling had not not ceased for them there. For those in the Pure Abodes, for them there both the aggregate of matter had not arisen and the aggregate of feeling had not ceased.

Or else, for whom and where the aggregate of feeling had not ceased, had the aggregate of matter not arisen for that one there?

For non-percipient beings, for them there the aggregate of feeling had not ceased, but the aggregate of matter had not not arisen for them there. For those in the Pure Abodes, for them there both the aggregate of feeling had not ceased and the aggregate of matter had not arisen.

174. For whom and where the aggregate of feeling had not arisen, did the aggregate of perception not cease for that one there? Yes.

Or else, for whom and where the aggregate of perception had not ceased, had the aggregate of feeling not arisen for that one there? Yes.

(3) The Section on the Future

Conformity Person

175. For whom the aggregate of matter will arise, will the aggregate of feeling cease for that one? Yes.

Or else, for whom the aggregate of feeling will cease, will the aggregate of matter arise for that one?

For those in their last existence being reborn, and for those who, having been reborn in the immaterial realm, will attain final nibbāna, for them the aggregate of feeling will cease, but the aggregate of matter will not arise for them. For the others, for them both the aggregate of feeling will cease and the aggregate of matter will arise.

176. For whom the aggregate of feeling will arise, will the aggregate of perception cease for that one? Yes.

Or else, for whom the aggregate of perception will cease, will the aggregate of feeling arise for that one?

For those in their last existence being reborn, for them the aggregate of perception will cease, but the aggregate of feeling will not arise for them. For the others, for them both the aggregate of perception will cease and the aggregate of feeling will arise.

Conformity Place

177. Where the aggregate of matter will arise... etc.

Conformity - Person - Place

178. For whom and where the aggregate of matter will arise, will the aggregate of feeling cease for that one there?

For non-percipient beings, for them there the aggregate of matter will arise, but the aggregate of feeling will not cease for them there. For five-aggregate constituent beings, for them there both the aggregate of matter will arise and the aggregate of feeling will cease.

Or else, for whom and where the aggregate of feeling will cease, will the aggregate of matter arise for that one there?

For those in their last existence being reborn in the five-aggregate constituent realm from the immaterial realm, for them there the aggregate of feeling will cease, but the aggregate of matter will not arise for them there. For the other five-aggregate constituent beings, for them there both the aggregate of feeling will cease and the aggregate of matter will arise.

179. For whom and where the aggregate of feeling will arise, will the aggregate of perception cease for that one there? Yes.

Or else, for whom and where the aggregate of perception will cease, will the aggregate of feeling arise for that one there?

For those in their last existence who are being reborn, for them there the aggregate of perception will cease, but the aggregate of feeling will not arise for them there. For the others, the four-aggregate constituent beings and the five-aggregate constituent beings, for them there both the aggregate of perception will cease and the aggregate of feeling will arise.

Negative Person

180. For whom the aggregate of matter will not arise, will the aggregate of feeling not cease for that one?

For those in their last existence being reborn, and for those who, having been reborn in the immaterial realm, will attain final nibbāna, for them the aggregate of matter will not arise, but the aggregate of feeling will not fail to cease for them. For those attaining final nibbāna, for them both the aggregate of matter will not arise and the aggregate of feeling will not cease.

Or else, for whom the aggregate of feeling will not cease, will the aggregate of matter not arise for that one? Yes.

181. For whom the aggregate of feeling will not arise, will the aggregate of perception not cease for that one?

For those in their last existence being reborn, for them the aggregate of feeling will not arise, but the aggregate of perception will not fail to cease for them. For those attaining final nibbāna, for them both the aggregate of feeling will not arise and the aggregate of perception will not cease.

Or else, for whom the aggregate of perception will not cease, will the aggregate of feeling not arise for that one? Yes.

The Negative Section on Place

182. Where the aggregate of matter will not arise... etc.

Negative - Person - Place

183. For whom and where the aggregate of matter will not arise, will the aggregate of feeling not cease for that one there?

For those in their last existence being reborn in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for immaterial beings, for them there the aggregate of matter will not arise, but the aggregate of feeling will not fail to cease for them there. For those attaining final nibbāna, for them there both the aggregate of matter will not arise and the aggregate of feeling will not cease.

Or else, for whom and where the aggregate of feeling will not cease, will the aggregate of matter not arise for that one there?

For non-percipient beings, for them there the aggregate of feeling will not cease, but the aggregate of matter will not fail to arise for them there. For those attaining final nibbāna, for them there both the aggregate of feeling will not cease and the aggregate of matter will not arise.

184. For whom and where the aggregate of feeling will not arise, will the aggregate of perception not cease for that one there?

For those in their last existence being reborn, for them there the aggregate of feeling will not arise, but the aggregate of perception does not fail to cease for them there. For non-percipient beings attaining final nibbāna, for them there both the aggregate of feeling will not arise and the aggregate of perception will not cease.

Or else, for whom and where the aggregate of perception will not cease, will the aggregate of feeling not arise for that one there? Yes.

(4) The Section on Present and Past

Conformity Person

185. For whom the aggregate of matter arises, did the aggregate of feeling cease for that one? Yes.

Or else, for whom the aggregate of feeling had ceased, does the aggregate of matter arise for that one?

For all those passing away being reborn in the immaterial realm, for them the aggregate of feeling had ceased, but the aggregate of matter does not arise for them. For those being reborn in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for those being reborn in the non-percipient being realm, for them both the aggregate of feeling had ceased and the aggregate of matter arises. Etc.

(As analysed in the section on arising regarding present and past, so it should be analysed here.)

(5) The Section on Present and Future

Conformity Person

186. For whom the aggregate of matter arises, will the aggregate of feeling cease for that one? Yes.

Or else, for whom the aggregate of feeling will cease, does the aggregate of matter arise for that one?

For all those passing away being reborn in the immaterial realm, for them the aggregate of feeling will cease, but the aggregate of matter does not arise for them. For those being reborn in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for those being reborn in the non-percipient being realm, for them both the aggregate of feeling will cease and the aggregate of matter arises.

187. For whom the aggregate of feeling arises, will the aggregate of perception cease for that one? Yes.

Or else, for whom the aggregate of perception will cease, does the aggregate of feeling arise for that one?

For all those passing away being reborn in the non-percipient being realm, for them the aggregate of perception will cease, but the aggregate of feeling does not arise for them. For those being reborn in the four-aggregate constituent realm or the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them both the aggregate of perception will cease and the aggregate of feeling arises.

Conformity Place

188. Where the aggregate of matter arises... etc.

Conformity - Person - Place

189. For whom and where the aggregate of matter arises, will the aggregate of feeling cease for that one there?

For those being reborn in the non-percipient being realm, for them there the aggregate of matter arises, but the aggregate of feeling will not cease for them there. For those being reborn in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them there both the aggregate of matter arises and the aggregate of feeling will cease.

Or else, for whom and where the aggregate of feeling will cease, does the aggregate of matter arise for that one there?

For those passing away from the five-aggregate constituent realm to the immaterial realm, for them there the aggregate of feeling will cease, but the aggregate of matter does not arise for them there. For those being reborn in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them there both the aggregate of feeling will cease and the aggregate of matter arises.

190. For whom and where the aggregate of feeling arises, will the aggregate of perception cease for that one there? Yes.

Or else, for whom and where the aggregate of perception will cease, does the aggregate of feeling arise for that one there?

For those passing away from the four-aggregate constituent realm or the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them there the aggregate of perception will cease, but the aggregate of feeling does not arise for them there. For those being reborn in the four-aggregate constituent realm or the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them there both the aggregate of perception will cease and the aggregate of feeling arises.

Negative Person

191. For whom the aggregate of matter does not arise, will the aggregate of feeling not cease for that one?

For all those passing away, for those being reborn in the immaterial realm, for them the aggregate of matter does not arise, but the aggregate of feeling will not fail to cease for them. For those attaining final nibbana, for them both the aggregate of matter does not arise and the aggregate of feeling will not cease.

Or else, for whom the aggregate of feeling will not cease, does the aggregate of matter not arise for that one? Yes.

192. For whom the aggregate of feeling does not arise, will the aggregate of perception not cease for that one?

For all those passing away being reborn in the non-percipient being realm, for them the aggregate of feeling does not arise, but the aggregate of perception will not fail to cease for them. For those attaining final nibbāna, for them both the aggregate of feeling does not arise and the aggregate of perception will not cease.

Or else, for whom the aggregate of perception will not cease, does the aggregate of feeling not arise for that one? Yes.

The Negative Section on Place

193. Where the aggregate of matter does not arise... etc.

Negative - Person - Place

194. For whom and where the aggregate of matter does not arise, will the aggregate of feeling not cease for that one there?

For those passing away from the five-aggregate constituent realm to the immaterial realm, for them there the aggregate of matter does not arise, but the aggregate of feeling will cease for them there. For those attaining final nibbāna, for those passing away from the non-percipient being realm, for them there both the aggregate of matter does not arise and the aggregate of feeling will not cease.

Or else, for whom and where the aggregate of feeling will not cease, does the aggregate of matter not arise for that one there?

For those being reborn in the non-percipient being realm, for them there the aggregate of feeling will not cease, but the aggregate of matter arises for them there. For those attaining final nibbāna, for those passing away from the non-percipient being realm, for them there both the aggregate of feeling will not cease and the aggregate of matter does not arise.

195. For whom and where the aggregate of feeling does not arise, will the aggregate of perception not cease for that one there?

For those passing away from the four-aggregate constituent realm or the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them there the aggregate of feeling does not arise, but the aggregate of perception will cease for them there. For non-percipient beings attaining final nibbana, for them there both the aggregate of feeling does not arise and the aggregate of perception will not cease.

Or else, for whom and where the aggregate of perception will not cease, does the aggregate of feeling not arise for that one there? Yes.

(6) The Section on Past and Future

Conformity Person

196. For whom the aggregate of matter arose, will the aggregate of feeling cease for that one?

For those attaining final nibbana, for them the aggregate of matter arose, but the aggregate of feeling will not cease for them. For the others, for them both the aggregate of matter arose and the aggregate of feeling will cease.

Or else, for whom the aggregate of feeling will cease, did the aggregate of matter arise for that one? Yes.

197. For whom the aggregate of feeling arose, will the aggregate of perception cease for that one?

For those attaining final nibbana, for them the aggregate of feeling arose, but the aggregate of perception will not cease for them. For the others, for them both the aggregate of feeling arose and the aggregate of perception will cease.

Or else, for whom the aggregate of perception will cease, did the aggregate of feeling arise for that one? Yes.

Conformity Place

198. Where the aggregate of matter arose... etc.

Conformity - Person - Place

199. For whom and where the aggregate of matter arose, will the aggregate of feeling cease for that one there?

For those attaining final nibbāna in the five-aggregate constituent realm and for non-percipient beings, for them there the aggregate of matter arose, but the aggregate of feeling will not cease for them there. For the other five-aggregate constituent beings, for them there both the aggregate of matter arose and the aggregate of feeling will cease.

Or else, for whom and where the aggregate of feeling will cease, did the aggregate of matter arise for that one there?

For those being reborn in the pure abode from the immaterial realm, for them there the aggregate of feeling will cease, but the aggregate of matter did not arise for them there. For the other five-aggregate constituent beings, for them there both the aggregate of feeling will cease and the aggregate of matter arose.

200. For whom and where the aggregate of feeling arose, will the aggregate of perception cease for that one there?

For those attaining final nibbana, for them there the aggregate of feeling arose, but the aggregate of perception will not cease for them there. For the others, the four-aggregate constituent beings and the five-aggregate constituent beings, for them there both the aggregate of feeling arose and the aggregate of perception will cease.

Or else, for whom and where the aggregate of perception will cease, did the aggregate of feeling arise for that one there?

For those being reborn in the pure abode, for them there the aggregate of perception will cease, but the aggregate of feeling had not arisen for them there. For the others, the four-aggregate constituent beings and the five-aggregate constituent beings, for them there both the aggregate of perception will cease and the aggregate of feeling arose.

Negative Person

201. For whom the aggregate of matter had not arisen, will the aggregate of feeling not cease for that one? There is not.

Or else, for whom the aggregate of feeling will not cease, had the aggregate of matter not arisen for that one? It had arisen.

202. For whom the aggregate of feeling had not arisen, will the aggregate of perception not cease for that one? There is not.

Or else, for whom the aggregate of perception will not cease, had the aggregate of feeling not arisen for that one? It had arisen.

The Negative Section on Place

203. Where the aggregate of matter had not arisen... etc.

Negative - Person - Place

204. For whom and where the aggregate of matter had not arisen, will the aggregate of feeling not cease for that one there?

For those being reborn in the Pure Abodes, for immaterial beings, for them there the aggregate of matter had not arisen, but the aggregate of feeling will not not cease for them there. For those attaining final nibbāna in the Pure Abodes, for those attaining final nibbāna in the immaterial-sphere of existence, for them there both the aggregate of matter had not arisen and the aggregate of feeling will not cease.

Or else, for whom and where the aggregate of feeling will not cease, had the aggregate of matter not arisen for that one there?

For those attaining final nibbāna in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for non-percipient beings, for them there the aggregate of feeling will not cease, but the aggregate of matter had not not arisen for them there. For those attaining final nibbāna in the Pure Abodes, for those attaining final nibbāna in the immaterial-sphere of existence, for them there both the aggregate of feeling will not cease and the aggregate of matter had not arisen.

205. For whom and where the aggregate of feeling had not arisen, will the aggregate of perception not cease for that one there?

For those being reborn in the Pure Abodes, for them there the aggregate of feeling had not arisen, but the aggregate of perception will not not cease for them there. For those attaining final nibbāna in the Pure Abodes, for non-percipient beings, for them there both the aggregate of feeling had not arisen and the aggregate of perception will not cease.

Or else, for whom and where the aggregate of perception will not cease, had the aggregate of feeling not arisen for that one there?

For those attaining final nibbāna, for them there the aggregate of perception will not cease, but the aggregate of feeling had arisen for them there. For those attaining final nibbāna in the Pure Abodes, for non-percipient beings, for them there both the aggregate of perception will not cease and the aggregate of feeling had not arisen.

The Section on Arising and Cessation.

The Section on Occurrence is concluded.

3.

The Section on Full Understanding

1.

The Section on Present

206. Whoever fully understands the aggregate of material body, does he fully understand the aggregate of feeling? Yes.

Or else, whoever fully understands the aggregate of feeling, does he fully understand the aggregate of material body? Yes.

Whoever does not fully understand the aggregate of material body, does he not fully understand the aggregate of feeling? Yes.

Or else, whoever does not fully understand the aggregate of feeling, does he not fully understand the aggregate of material body? Yes.

2.

The Section on Past

207. Whoever fully understood the aggregate of material body, did he fully understand the aggregate of feeling? Yes.

Or else, whoever fully understood the aggregate of feeling, did he fully understand the aggregate of material body? Yes.

Whoever did not fully understand the aggregate of material body, did he not fully understand the aggregate of feeling? Yes.

Or else, whoever did not fully understand the aggregate of feeling, did he not fully understand the aggregate of material body? Yes.

3.

The Section on Future

208. Whoever will fully understand the aggregate of material body, will he fully understand the aggregate of feeling? Yes.

Or else, whoever will fully understand the aggregate of feeling, will he fully understand the aggregate of material body? Yes.

Whoever will not fully understand the aggregate of material body, will he not fully understand the aggregate of feeling? Yes.

Or else, whoever will not fully understand the aggregate of feeling, will he not fully understand the aggregate of material body? Yes.

4.

The Section on Present and Past

209. Whoever fully understands the aggregate of material body, did he fully understand the aggregate of feeling? No.

Or else, whoever fully understood the aggregate of feeling, does he fully understand the aggregate of material body? No.

Whoever does not fully understand the aggregate of material body, did he not fully understand the aggregate of feeling?

A Worthy One does not fully understand the aggregate of material body, but it is not that he did not fully understand the aggregate of feeling. Setting aside the possessor of the highest path and the Worthy One, the remaining persons do not fully understand the aggregate of material body and did not fully understand the aggregate of feeling.

Or else, whoever did not fully understand the aggregate of feeling, does he not fully understand the aggregate of material body?

The possessor of the highest path did not fully understand the aggregate of feeling, but it is not that he does not fully understand the aggregate of material body. Setting aside the possessor of the highest path and the Worthy One, the remaining persons did not fully understand the aggregate of feeling and do not fully understand the aggregate of material body.

5.

The Section on Present and Future

210. Whoever fully understands the aggregate of material body, will he fully understand the aggregate of feeling? No.

Or else, whoever will fully understand the aggregate of feeling, does he fully understand the aggregate of material body? No.

Whoever does not fully understand the aggregate of material body, will he not fully understand the aggregate of feeling?

Those who will obtain the path, they do not fully understand the aggregate of material body, but it is not that they will not fully understand the aggregate of feeling. A Worthy One and those worldlings who will not obtain the path, they do not fully understand the aggregate of material body and will not fully understand the aggregate of feeling.

Or else, whoever will not fully understand the aggregate of feeling, does he not fully understand the aggregate of material body?

The possessor of the highest path will not fully understand the aggregate of feeling, but it is not that he does not fully understand the aggregate of material body. A Worthy One and those worldlings who will not obtain the path, they will not fully understand the aggregate of feeling and do not fully understand the aggregate of material body.

6.

The Section on Past and Future

211. Whoever fully understood the aggregate of material body, will he fully understand the aggregate of feeling? No.

Or else, whoever will fully understand the aggregate of feeling, did he fully understand the aggregate of material body? No.

Whoever did not fully understand the aggregate of material body, will he not fully understand the aggregate of feeling?

Those who will obtain the path, they did not fully understand the aggregate of material body, but it is not that they will not fully understand the aggregate of feeling. The possessor of the highest path and those worldlings who will not obtain the path, they did not fully understand the aggregate of material body and will not fully understand the aggregate of feeling.

Or else, whoever will not fully understand the aggregate of feeling, did he not fully understand the aggregate of material body?

A Worthy One will not fully understand the aggregate of feeling, but it is not that he did not fully understand the aggregate of material body. The possessor of the highest path and those worldlings who will not obtain the path, they will not fully understand the aggregate of feeling and did not fully understand the aggregate of material body.

The Section on Full Understanding.

The Pāḷi on the Pairs on Aggregates is concluded.

Homage to the Blessed One, the Worthy One, the Perfectly Enlightened One

3.

Pairs on Sense Bases

1.

The Description Section

Synopsis

1. The twelve sense bases - the eye sense base, the ear sense base, the nose sense base, the tongue sense base, the body sense base, the visible form sense base, the sound sense base, the odour sense base, the flavour sense base, the touch sense base, the mind sense base, the mind-object sense base.

1.

The Section on Term Clarification

Conformity

2. Is the eye the eye sense base?

Is the eye sense base the eye?

Is the ear the ear sense base?

Is the ear sense base the ear?

Is the nose the nose sense base?

Is the nose sense base the nose?

Is the tongue the tongue sense base?

Is the tongue sense base the tongue?

Is the body the body sense base?

Is the body sense base the body?

Is visible form the visible form sense base?

Is the visible form sense base visible form?

Is sound the sound sense base?

Is the sound sense base sound?

Is odour the odour sense base?

Is the odour sense base odour?

Is flavour the flavour sense base?

Is the flavour sense base flavour?

Is touch the touch sense base?

Is the touch sense base touch?

Is mind the mind sense base?

Is the mind sense base mind?

Is a mental phenomenon the mind-object sense base?

Is the mind-object sense base a mental phenomenon?

Opposite

3. Is what is not eye not the eye sense base?

Is what is not the eye sense base not eye?

Is what is not ear not the ear sense base?

Is what is not the ear sense base not ear?

Is what is not nose not the nose sense base?

Is what is not the nose sense base not nose?

Is what is not tongue not the tongue sense base?

Is what is not the tongue sense base not tongue?

Is what is not body not the body sense base?

Is what is not the body sense base not body?

Is what is not visible form not the visible form sense base?

Is what is not the visible form sense base not visible form?

Is what is not sound not the sound sense base?

Is what is not the sound sense base not sound?

Is what is not odour not the odour sense base?

Is what is not the odour sense base not odour?

Is what is not flavour not the flavour sense base?

Is what is not the flavour sense base not flavour?

Is what is not tangible object not the touch sense base?

Is what is not the touch sense base not tangible object?

Is what is not mind not the mind sense base?

Is what is not the mind sense base not mind?

Is what is not mental phenomenon not the mind-object sense base?

Is what is not the mind-object sense base not mental phenomenon?

2.

The Section on Term Clarification Root Wheel

Conformity

4. Is the eye the eye sense base?

Is a sense base the ear sense base?

Is the eye the eye sense base?

Is a sense base the nose sense base?

Is the eye the eye sense base?

Is a sense base the tongue sense base? Etc.

Is the eye the eye sense base?

Is a sense base the mind-object sense base?

Is the ear the ear sense base?

Is a sense base the eye sense base?

Is the ear the ear sense base?

Is a sense base the nose sense base? Etc.

Is the ear the ear sense base?

Is a sense base the mind-object sense base?

Is the nose the nose sense base?

Is a sense base the eye sense base? Etc.

Is the nose the nose sense base?

Is a sense base the mind-object sense base? Etc.

Is a mental phenomenon the mind-object sense base?

Is a sense base the eye sense base?

Is a mental phenomenon the mind-object sense base?

Is a sense base the ear sense base? Etc.

Is a mental phenomenon the mind-object sense base?

Is a sense base the mind sense base?

(A wheel should be bound)

Opposite

5. Is what is not eye not the eye sense base?

Is what is not a sense base not the ear sense base?

Is what is not eye not the eye sense base?

Is what is not a sense base not the nose sense base? Etc.

Is what is not eye not the eye sense base?

Is what is not a sense base not the mind-object sense base?

Is what is not ear not the ear sense base?

Is what is not a sense base not the eye sense base? Etc.

Is what is not ear not the ear sense base?

Is what is not a sense base not the mind-object sense base?

Is what is not nose not the nose sense base?

Is what is not a sense base not the eye sense base? Etc.

Is what is not nose not the nose sense base?

Is what is not a sense base not the mind-object sense base? Etc.

Is what is not mental phenomenon not the mind-object sense base?

Is what is not a sense base not the eye sense base?

Is what is not mental phenomenon not the mind-object sense base?

Is what is not a sense base not the ear sense base? Etc.

Is what is not mental phenomenon not the mind-object sense base?

Is what is not a sense base not the mind sense base?

(A wheel should be bound)

3.

The Pure Sense Base Section

Conformity

6. Is eye a sense base?

Is a sense base eye?

Is ear a sense base?

Is a sense base ear?

Is nose a sense base?

Is a sense base nose?

Is tongue a sense base?

Is a sense base tongue?

Is body a sense base?

Is a sense base body?

Is visible form a sense base?

Is a sense base visible form?

Is sound a sense base?

Is a sense base sound?

Is odour a sense base?

Is a sense base odour?

Is flavour a sense base?

Is a sense base flavour?

Is tangible object a sense base?

Is a sense base tangible object?

Is mind a sense base?

Is a sense base mind?

Is mental phenomenon a sense base?

Is a sense base mental phenomenon?

Opposite

7. Is what is not eye not a sense base?

Is what is not a sense base not eye?

Is what is not ear not a sense base?

Is what is not a sense base not ear?

Is what is not nose not a sense base?

Is what is not a sense base not nose?

Is what is not tongue not a sense base?

Is what is not a sense base not tongue?

Is what is not body not a sense base?

Is what is not a sense base not body?

Is what is not matter not a sense base?

Is what is not a sense base not matter?

Is what is not sound not a sense base?

Is what is not a sense base not sound?

Is what is not odour not a sense base?

Is what is not a sense base not odour?

Is what is not flavour not a sense base?

Is what is not a sense base not flavour?

Is what is not tangible object not a sense base?

Is what is not a sense base not tangible object?

Is what is not mind not a sense base?

Is what is not a sense base not mind?

Is what is not mental phenomenon not a sense base?

Is what is not a sense base not mental phenomenon?

4.

The Pure Sense Base Root Wheel Section

Conformity

8. Is eye a sense base?

Is a sense base ear? Etc.

Is eye a sense base?

Is a sense base mental phenomenon?

Is ear a sense base?

Is a sense base eye? Etc.

Is ear a sense base?

Is a sense base mental phenomenon?

Is nose a sense base?

Is a sense base eye? Etc.

Is nose a sense base?

Is a sense base mental phenomenon? Etc.

Is mental phenomenon a sense base?

Is a sense base eye?

Is mental phenomenon a sense base?

Is a sense base ear? Etc.

Is mental phenomenon a sense base?

Is a sense base mind?

(A wheel should be bound)

Opposite

9. Is what is not eye not a sense base?

Is what is not a sense base not ear?

Is what is not eye not a sense base?

Is what is not a sense base not nose? Etc.

Is what is not eye not a sense base?

Is what is not a sense base not mental phenomenon?

Is what is not ear not a sense base?

Is what is not a sense base not eye? Etc.

Is what is not ear not a sense base?

Is what is not a sense base not mental phenomenon?

Is what is not nose not a sense base?

Is what is not a sense base not eye? Etc.

Is what is not nose not a sense base?

Is what is not a sense base not mental phenomenon? Etc.

Is what is not mental phenomenon not a sense base?

Is what is not a sense base not eye?

Is what is not mental phenomenon not a sense base?

Is what is not a sense base not ear? Etc.

Is what is not mental phenomenon not a sense base?

Is what is not a sense base not mind?

(A wheel should be bound)

The Section on Synopsis of Description.

Exposition

1.

Analytic Explanation of the Description Section

1.

The Section on Term Clarification

Conformity

10. Is eye the eye sense base?

The divine eye and the eye of wisdom are eye, not the eye sense base. The eye sense base is both eye and the eye sense base.

Is the eye sense base eye? Yes.

Is ear the ear sense base?

The divine ear and the stream of craving are ear, not the ear sense base. The ear sense base is both ear and the ear sense base.

Is the ear sense base ear? Yes.

Is nose the nose sense base? Yes.

Is the nose sense base nose? Yes.

Is tongue the tongue sense base? Yes.

Is the tongue sense base tongue? Yes.

Is body the body sense base?

Setting aside the body sense base, the remaining body is not the body sense base. The body sense base is both body and the body sense base.

Is the body sense base body? Yes.

Is matter the visible form sense base?

Setting aside the visible form sense base, the remaining matter is not the visible form sense base. The visible form sense base is both matter and the visible form sense base.

Is the visible form sense base matter? Yes.

Is sound the sound sense base? Yes.

Is the sound sense base sound? Yes.

Is odour the odour sense base?

The odour of morality, the odour of concentration, the odour of wisdom are odour, not the odour sense base. The odour sense base is both odour and the odour sense base.

Is the odour sense base odour? Yes.

Is flavour the flavour sense base?

The flavour of meaning, the flavour of the teaching, the flavour of liberation are flavour, not the flavour sense base. The flavour sense base is both flavour and the flavour sense base.

Is the flavour sense base flavour? Yes.

Is tangible object the touch sense base? Yes.

Is the touch sense base tangible object? Yes.

Is mind the mind sense base? Yes.

Is the mind sense base mind? Yes.

Is mental phenomenon the mind-object sense base?

Setting aside the mind-object sense base, the remaining mental phenomenon is not the mind-object sense base. The mind-object sense base is both mental phenomenon and the mind-object sense base.

Is the mind-object sense base mental phenomenon? Yes.

Opposite

11. Is what is not eye not the eye sense base? Yes.

Is what is not the eye sense base not eye?

The divine eye and the eye of wisdom are not the eye sense base, but are eye. Setting aside eye and the eye sense base, the remainder is neither eye nor the eye sense base.

Is what is not ear not the ear sense base? Yes.

Is what is not the ear sense base not ear?

The divine ear and the stream of craving are not the ear sense base, but are ear. Setting aside ear and the ear sense base, the remainder is neither ear nor the ear sense base.

Is what is not nose not the nose sense base? Yes.

Is what is not the nose sense base not nose? Yes.

Is what is not tongue not the tongue sense base? Yes.

Is what is not the tongue sense base not tongue? Yes.

Is what is not body not the body sense base? Yes.

Is what is not the body sense base not body?

Setting aside the body sense base, the remaining body is not the body sense base. Setting aside body and the body sense base, the remainder is neither body nor the body sense base.

Is what is not matter not the visible form sense base? Yes.

Is what is not the visible form sense base not matter?

Setting aside the visible form sense base, the remaining matter is not the visible form sense base. Setting aside matter and the visible form sense base, the remainder is neither matter nor the visible form sense base.

Is what is not sound not the sound sense base? Yes.

Is what is not the sound sense base not sound? Yes.

Is what is not odour not the odour sense base? Yes.

Is what is not the odour sense base not odour?

The odour of morality, the odour of concentration, the odour of wisdom are not the odour sense base, but are odour. Setting aside odour and the odour sense base, the remainder is neither odour nor the odour sense base.

Is what is not flavour not the flavour sense base? Yes.

Is what is not the flavour sense base not flavour?

The flavour of meaning, the flavour of the teaching, the flavour of liberation are not the flavour sense base, but are flavour. Setting aside flavour and the flavour sense base, the remainder is neither flavour nor the flavour sense base.

Is what is not tangible object not the touch sense base? Yes.

Is what is not the touch sense base not tangible object? Yes.

Is what is not mind not the mind sense base? Yes.

Is what is not the mind sense base not mind? Yes.

Is what is not mental phenomenon not the mind-object sense base? Yes.

Is what is not the mind-object sense base not mental phenomenon?

Setting aside the mind-object sense base, the remainder is not the mind-object sense base, but is mental phenomenon. Setting aside mental phenomenon and the mind-object sense base, the remainder is neither mental phenomenon nor the mind-object sense base.

2.

The Section on Term Clarification Root Wheel

Conformity

12. Is eye the eye sense base?

The divine eye and the eye of wisdom are eye, not the eye sense base. The eye sense base is both eye and the eye sense base. Etc.

Is a sense base the ear sense base?

The ear sense base is both a sense base and the ear sense base. The remaining sense bases are not the ear sense base.

Is eye the eye sense base?

The divine eye and the eye of wisdom are eye, not the eye sense base. The eye sense base is both eye and the eye sense base. Etc.

Is a sense base the nose sense base? Etc. Is a sense base the mind-object sense base?

The mind-object sense base is both a sense base and the mind-object sense base. The remaining sense bases are not the mind-object sense base.

Is ear the ear sense base? Etc. The remaining sense bases are not the mind-object sense base. Etc.

Is mental phenomenon the mind-object sense base?

Setting aside the mind-object sense base, the remaining mental phenomenon is not the mind-object sense base. The mind-object sense base is both mental phenomenon and the mind-object sense base. Etc.

Is a sense base the eye sense base?

The eye sense base is both a sense base and the eye sense base. The remaining sense bases are not the eye sense base.

Is mental phenomenon the mind-object sense base?

Setting aside the mind-object sense base, the remaining mental phenomenon is not the mind-object sense base. The mind-object sense base is both mental phenomenon and the mind-object sense base.

Is a sense base the ear sense base? Etc. Is a sense base the mind sense base?

The mind sense base is both a sense base and the mind sense base. The remaining sense bases are not the mind sense base.

(A wheel based on each single term should be bound by one without confusion).

Opposite

13. Is what is not eye not the eye sense base? Yes.

Is what is not a sense base not the ear sense base? Yes.

Is what is not eye not the eye sense base? Yes.

Is what is not a sense base not the nose sense base? Yes. Etc.

Is what is not a sense base not the mind-object sense base? Yes.

Is what is not ear not the ear sense base? Yes.

Is what is not a sense base not the eye sense base? Etc. Is what is not a sense base not the mind-object sense base? Yes.

Is what is not nose not the nose sense base? Etc. Is what is not a sense base not the mind-object sense base?

Yes. Etc.

Is what is not mental phenomenon not the mind-object sense base? Yes.

Is what is not a sense base not the eye sense base? Yes.

Is what is not mental phenomenon not the mind-object sense base? Yes.

Is what is not a sense base not the ear sense base? Etc. Is what is not a sense base not the mind sense base? Yes.

(A wheel should be bound with "Yes" everywhere).

3.

The Pure Sense Base Section

Conformity

14. Is the eye a sense base? Yes.

Is a sense base the eye sense base?

The eye sense base is both a sense base and the eye sense base. The remaining sense bases are not the eye sense base.

Is the ear a sense base?

Yes. Etc. The nose... The tongue... The body... matter... Sound... Odour... Flavour... Touch... The mind... Is mental phenomenon a sense base?

Yes.

Is a sense base the mind-object sense base?

The mind-object sense base is both a sense base and the mind-object sense base. The remaining sense bases are not the mind-object sense base.

Opposite

15. Is what is not eye not a sense base?

Setting aside eye, the remaining sense bases are not eye, but are sense bases. Setting aside eye and sense base, the remainder is neither eye nor sense base.

Is what is not a sense base not the eye sense base? Yes.

Is what is not ear not a sense base?

Setting aside ear, etc. Setting aside nose, etc. Setting aside tongue, etc. nor sense base.

Is what is not a sense base not the tongue sense base? Yes.

Is what is not body not a sense base? Yes.

Is what is not a sense base not the body sense base? Yes.

Is what is not matter not a sense base?

Setting aside matter, etc. Setting aside sound, etc. Setting aside odour, etc. Setting aside flavour, etc. Setting aside tangible object, etc. nor sense base. Is what is not a sense base not the touch sense base? Yes.

Is what is not mind not a sense base?

Setting aside mind, the remaining sense bases are not mind, but are sense bases. Setting aside mind and sense base, the remainder is neither mind nor sense base.

Is what is not a sense base not the mind sense base? Yes.

Is what is not mental phenomenon not a sense base? Yes.

Is what is not a sense base not the mind-object sense base? Yes.

4.

The Pure Sense Base Root Wheel Section

Conformity

16. Is the eye a sense base? Yes.

Is a sense base the ear sense base?

The ear sense base is both a sense base and the ear sense base. The remaining sense bases are not the ear sense base.

Is the eye a sense base? Yes.

Is a sense base the nose sense base? Etc. Is a sense base the mind-object sense base?

The mind-object sense base is both a sense base and the mind-object sense base. The remaining sense bases are not the mind-object sense base.

Is the ear a sense base? Yes.

Is a sense base the eye sense base? Etc. not the eye sense base... etc. Is a sense base the mind-object sense base? Etc. not the mind-object sense base.

Is the nose a sense base? Yes.

Is a sense base the eye sense base? Etc. Is a sense base the mind-object sense base? Etc. not the mind-object sense base... etc.

Is mental phenomenon a sense base? Yes.

Is a sense base the eye sense base? Etc. Is a sense base the mind sense base?

The mind sense base is both a sense base and the mind sense base. The remaining sense bases are not the mind sense base.

(A wheel should be bound)

Opposite

17. Is what is not eye not a sense base?

Setting aside eye, the remaining sense bases are not eye, but are sense bases. Setting aside eye and sense base, the remainder is neither eye nor sense base.

Is what is not a sense base not the ear sense base? Yes.

Is what is not eye not a sense base?

Setting aside eye, the remaining sense bases are not eye, but are sense bases. Setting aside eye and sense base, the remainder is neither eye nor sense base.

Is what is not a sense base not the nose sense base? Etc. Is what is not a sense base not the mind-object sense base?

Yes.

Is what is not ear not a sense base?

Setting aside ear, etc. Setting aside nose, etc. Setting aside tongue, etc. nor sense base. Is what is not a sense base not the mind-object sense base? Yes.

Is what is not body not a sense base? Yes.

Is what is not a sense base not the eye sense base? Yes. Etc. Is what is not a sense base not the mind-object sense base? Yes. Etc.

Is what is not mental phenomenon not a sense base? Yes.

Is what is not a sense base not the eye sense base? Yes.

Is what is not mental phenomenon not a sense base? Yes.

Is what is not a sense base not the ear sense base? Yes. Etc.

Is what is not a sense base not the mind sense base? Yes.

(A wheel should be bound)

The Section on Analytic Explanation of Description.

2.

The Section on Occurrence 1.

The Section on Arising

(1) The Section on the Present

Conformity Person

18. For whom the eye sense base arises, does the ear sense base arise for that one?

For those with eyes but without ears being reborn, for them the eye sense base arises, but the ear sense base does not arise for them. For those with eyes and with ears being reborn, for them both the eye sense base arises and the ear sense base arises.

Or else, for whom the ear sense base arises, does the eye sense base arise for that one?

For those with ears but without eyes being reborn, for them the ear sense base arises, but the eye sense base does not arise for them. For those with ears and with eyes being reborn, for them both the ear sense base arises and the eye sense base arises.

For whom the eye sense base arises, does the nose sense base arise for that one?

For those with eyes but without nose being reborn, for them the eye sense base arises, but the nose sense base does not arise for them. For those with eyes and with nose being reborn, for them both the eye sense base arises and the nose sense base arises.

Or else, for whom the nose sense base arises, does the eye sense base arise for that one?

For those with nose but without eyes being reborn, for them the nose sense base arises, but the eye sense base does not arise for them. For those with nose and with eyes being reborn, for them both the nose sense base arises and the eye sense base arises.

For whom the eye sense base arises, does the visible form sense base arise for that one? Yes.

Or else, for whom the visible form sense base arises, does the eye sense base arise for that one?

For those with material form but without eyes being reborn, for them the visible form sense base arises, but the eye sense base does not arise for them. For those with eyes being reborn, for them both the visible form sense base arises and the eye sense base arises.

For whom the eye sense base arises, does the mind sense base arise for that one? Yes.

Or else, for whom the mind sense base arises, does the eye sense base arise for that one?

For those with consciousness but without eyes being reborn, for them the mind sense base arises, but the eye sense base does not arise for them. For those with eyes being reborn, for them both the mind sense base arises and the eye sense base arises.

For whom the eye sense base arises, does the mind-object sense base arise for that one? Yes.

Or else, for whom the mind-object sense base arises, does the eye sense base arise for that one?

For those without eyes being reborn, for them the mind-object sense base arises, but the eye sense base does not arise for them. For those with eyes being reborn, for them both the mind-object sense base arises and the eye sense base arises. (Eye Sense Base as Root)

19. For whom the nose sense base arises, does the visible form sense base arise for that one? Yes.

Or else, for whom the visible form sense base arises, does the nose sense base arise for that one?

For those with material form but without nose being reborn, for them the visible form sense base arises, but the nose sense base does not arise for them. For those with nose being reborn, for them both the visible form sense base arises and the nose sense base arises.

For whom the nose sense base arises, does the mind sense base arise for that one? Yes.

Or else, for whom the mind sense base arises, does the nose sense base arise for that one?

For those with consciousness but without nose being reborn, for them the mind sense base arises, but the nose sense base does not arise for them. For those with nose being reborn, for them both the mind sense base arises and the nose sense base arises.

For whom the nose sense base arises, does the mind-object sense base arise for that one? Yes.

Or else, for whom the mind-object sense base arises, does the nose sense base arise for that one?

For those without nose being reborn, for them the mind-object sense base arises, but the nose sense base does not arise for them. For those with nose being reborn, for them both the mind-object sense base arises and the nose sense base arises. (Nose Sense Base as Root)

20. For whom the visible form sense base arises, does the mind sense base arise for that one?

For those without consciousness being reborn, for them the visible form sense base arises, but the mind sense base does not arise for them. For those with material form and with consciousness being reborn, for them both the visible form sense base arises and the mind sense base arises.

Or else, for whom the mind sense base arises, does the visible form sense base arise for that one?

For immaterial beings being reborn, for them the mind sense base arises, but the visible form sense base does not arise for them. For those with consciousness and with material form being reborn, for them both the mind sense base arises and the visible form sense base arises.

For whom the visible form sense base arises, does the mind-object sense base arise for that one? Yes.

Or else, for whom the mind-object sense base arises, does the visible form sense base arise for that one?

For immaterial beings being reborn, for them the mind-object sense base arises, but the visible form sense base does not arise for them. For those with material form being reborn, for them both the mind-object sense base arises and the visible form sense base arises. (Visible Form Sense Base as Root)

21. For whom the mind sense base arises, does the mind-object sense base arise for that one? Yes.

Or else, for whom the mind-object sense base arises, does the mind sense base arise for that one?

For those without consciousness being reborn, for them the mind-object sense base arises, but the mind sense base does not arise for them. For those with consciousness being reborn, for them both the mind-object sense base arises and the mind sense base arises. (Mind Sense Base as Root)

Conformity Place

22. Where the eye sense base arises, does the ear sense base arise there? Yes.

Or else, where the ear sense base arises, does the eye sense base arise there? Yes.

Where the eye sense base arises, does the nose sense base arise there?

In the fine-material-sphere of existence, there the eye sense base arises, but the nose sense base does not arise there. In the sensual-sphere of existence, there both the eye sense base arises and the nose sense base arises.

Or else, where the nose sense base arises, does the eye sense base arise there? Yes.

Where the eye sense base arises, does the visible form sense base arise there? Yes.

Or else, where the visible form sense base arises, does the eye sense base arise there?

In the non-percipient being realm, there the visible form sense base arises, but the eye sense base does not arise there. In the five-aggregate constituent realm, there both the visible form sense base arises and the eye sense base arises.

Where the eye sense base arises, does the mind sense base arise there? Yes.

Or else, where the mind sense base arises, does the eye sense base arise there?

In the immaterial-sphere of existence, there the mind sense base arises, but the eye sense base does not arise there. In the five-aggregate constituent realm, there both the mind sense base arises and the eye sense base arises.

Where the eye sense base arises, does the mind-object sense base arise there? Yes.

Or else, where the mind-object sense base arises, does the eye sense base arise there?

In the non-percipient being realm and in the immaterial-sphere of existence, there the mind-object sense base arises, but the eye sense base does not arise there. In the five-aggregate constituent realm, there both the mind-object sense base arises and the eye sense base arises. (Eye Sense Base as Root)

23. Where the nose sense base arises, does the visible form sense base arise there? Yes.

Or else, where the visible form sense base arises, does the nose sense base arise there?

In the fine-material-sphere of existence, there the visible form sense base arises, but the nose sense base does not arise there. In the sensual-sphere of existence, there both the visible form sense base arises and the nose sense base arises.

(Where the nose sense base arises, there the mind sense base and the mind-object sense base are similar, there is no difference; but above, it should be known that there is an abridgement of the section.)

Where the nose sense base arises, does the mind-object sense base arise there? Yes.

Or else, where the mind-object sense base arises, does the nose sense base arise there?

In the fine-material-sphere and immaterial-sphere of existence, there the mind-object sense base arises, but the nose sense base does not arise there. In the sensual-sphere of existence, there both the mind-object sense base arises and the nose sense base arises. (Nose Sense Base as Root)

24. Where the visible form sense base arises, does the mind sense base arise there?

In the non-percipient being realm, there the visible form sense base arises, but the mind sense base does not arise there. In the five-aggregate constituent realm, there both the visible form sense base arises and the mind sense base arises.

Or else, where the mind sense base arises, does the visible form sense base arise there?

In the immaterial-sphere of existence, there the mind sense base arises, but the visible form sense base does not arise there. In the five-aggregate constituent realm, there both the mind sense base arises and the visible form sense base arises.

Where the visible form sense base arises, does the mind-object sense base arise there? Yes.

Or else, where the mind-object sense base arises, does the visible form sense base arise there?

In the immaterial-sphere of existence, there the mind-object sense base arises, but the visible form sense base does not arise there. In the five-aggregate constituent realm and in the non-percipient being realm, there both the mind-object sense base arises and the visible form sense base arises. (Visible Form Sense Base as Root)

25. Where the mind sense base arises, does the mind-object sense base arise there? Yes.

Or else, where the mind-object sense base arises, does the mind sense base arise there?

In the non-percipient being realm, there the mind-object sense base arises, but the mind sense base does not arise there. In the four-aggregate constituent realm and in the five-aggregate constituent realm, there both the mind-object sense base arises and the mind sense base arises. (Mind Sense Base as Root)

Conformity - Person - Place

26. For whom and where the eye sense base arises, does the ear sense base arise for that one there?

For those with eyes but without ears being reborn, for them there the eye sense base arises, but the ear sense base does not arise for them there. For those with eyes and with ears being reborn, for them there both the eye sense base arises and the ear sense base arises.

Or else, for whom and where the ear sense base arises, does the eye sense base arise for that one there?

For those with ears but without eyes being reborn, for them there the ear sense base arises, but the eye sense base does not arise for them there. For those with ears and with eyes being reborn, for them there both the ear sense base arises and the eye sense base arises (abbreviated, similar to the 'for whom' section).

27. For whom and where the mind sense base arises, does the mind-object sense base arise for that one there? Yes.

Or else, for whom and where the mind-object sense base arises, does the mind sense base arise for that one there?

For those without consciousness being reborn, for them there the mind-object sense base arises, but the mind sense base does not arise for them there. For those with consciousness being reborn, for them there both the mind-object sense base arises and the mind sense base arises.

Negative Person

28. For whom the eye sense base does not arise, does the ear sense base not arise for that one?

For those without eyes but with ears being reborn, for them the eye sense base does not arise, but the ear sense base does arise for them. For all those passing away, and for those without eyes and without ears being reborn, for them both the eye sense base does not arise and the ear sense base does not arise.

Or else, for whom the ear sense base does not arise, does the eye sense base not arise for that one?

For those without ears but with eyes being reborn, for them the ear sense base does not arise, but the eye sense base does arise for them. For all those passing away, and for those without ears and without eyes being reborn, for them both the ear sense base does not arise and the eye sense base does not arise.

For whom the eye sense base does not arise, does the nose sense base not arise for that one?

For those without eyes but with nose being reborn, for them the eye sense base does not arise, but the nose sense base does arise for them. For all those passing away, and for those without eyes and without nose being reborn, for them both the eye sense base does not arise and the nose sense base does not arise.

Or else, for whom the nose sense base does not arise, does the eye sense base not arise for that one?

For those without nose but with eyes being reborn, for them the nose sense base does not arise, but the eye sense base does arise for them. For all those passing away, and for those without nose and without eyes being reborn, for them both the nose sense base does not arise and the eye sense base does not arise.

For whom the eye sense base does not arise, does the visible form sense base not arise for that one?

For those without eyes but with material form being reborn, for them the eye sense base does not arise, but the visible form sense base does arise for them. For all those passing away, and for immaterial beings being reborn, for them both the eye sense base does not arise and the visible form sense base does not arise.

Or else, for whom the visible form sense base does not arise, does the eye sense base not arise for that one? Yes.

For whom the eye sense base does not arise, does the mind sense base not arise for that one?

For those without eyes but with consciousness being reborn, for them the eye sense base does not arise, but the mind sense base does arise for them. For all those passing away, and for those without consciousness being reborn, for them both the eye sense base does not arise and the mind sense base does not arise.

Or else, for whom the mind sense base does not arise, does the eye sense base not arise for that one? Yes.

For whom the eye sense base does not arise, does the mind-object sense base not arise for that one?

For those without eyes being reborn, for them the eye sense base does not arise, but the mind-object sense base does arise for them. For all those passing away, for them both the eye sense base does not arise and the mind-object sense base does not arise.

Or else, for whom the mind-object sense base does not arise, does the eye sense base not arise for that one? Yes. (Eye Sense Base as Root)

29. For whom the nose sense base does not arise, does the visible form sense base not arise for that one?

For those without nose but with material form being reborn, for them the nose sense base does not arise, but the visible form sense base does arise for them. For all those passing away, and for immaterial beings being reborn, for them both the nose sense base does not arise and the visible form sense base does not arise.

Or else, for whom the visible form sense base does not arise, does the nose sense base not arise for that one? Yes.

For whom the nose sense base does not arise, does the mind sense base not arise for that one?

For those without nose but with consciousness being reborn, for them the nose sense base does not arise, but the mind sense base does arise for them. For all those passing away, and for those without consciousness being reborn, for them both the nose sense base does not arise and the mind sense base does not arise.

Or else, for whom the mind sense base does not arise, does the nose sense base not arise for that one? Yes.

For whom the nose sense base does not arise, does the mind-object sense base not arise for that one?

For those without nose being reborn, for them the nose sense base does not arise, but the mind-object sense base does arise for them. For all those passing away, for them both the nose sense base does not arise and the mind-object sense base does not arise.

Or else, for whom the mind-object sense base does not arise, does the nose sense base not arise for that one? Yes. (Nose Sense Base as Root)

30. For whom the visible form sense base does not arise, does the mind sense base not arise for that one?

For immaterial beings being reborn, for them the visible form sense base does not arise, but the mind sense base does arise for them. For all those passing away, for them both the visible form sense base does not arise and the mind sense base does not arise.

Or else, for whom the mind sense base does not arise, does the visible form sense base not arise for that one?

For those without consciousness being reborn, for them the mind sense base does not arise, but the visible form sense base does arise for them. For all those passing away, for them both the mind sense base does not arise and the visible form sense base does not arise.

For whom the visible form sense base does not arise, does the mind-object sense base not arise for that one?

For immaterial beings being reborn, for them the visible form sense base does not arise, but the mind-object sense base does arise for them. For all those passing away, for them both the visible form sense base does not arise and the mind-object sense base does not arise.

Or else, for whom the mind-object sense base does not arise, does the visible form sense base not arise for that one? Yes. (Visible Form Sense Base as Root)

31. For whom the mind sense base does not arise, does the mind-object sense base not arise for that one?

For those without consciousness being reborn, for them the mind sense base does not arise, but the mind-object sense base does arise for them. For all those passing away, for them both the mind sense base does not arise and the mind-object sense base does not arise.

Or else, for whom the mind-object sense base does not arise, does the mind sense base not arise for that one? Yes. (Mind Sense Base as Root)

The Negative Section on Place

32. Where the eye sense base does not arise, does the ear sense base not arise there? Yes.

Or else, where the ear sense base does not arise, does the eye sense base not arise there? Yes.

Where the eye sense base does not arise, does the nose sense base not arise there? Yes.

Or else, where the nose sense base does not arise, does the eye sense base not arise there?

In the fine-material-sphere of existence, there the nose sense base does not arise, but the eye sense base does arise there. In the non-percipient being realm and in the immaterial-sphere of existence, there both the nose sense base does not arise and the eye sense base does not arise.

Where the eye sense base does not arise, does the visible form sense base not arise there?

In the non-percipient being realm, there the eye sense base does not arise, but the visible form sense base does arise there. In the immaterial-sphere of existence, there both the eye sense base does not arise and the visible form sense base does not arise.

Or else, where the visible form sense base does not arise, does the eye sense base not arise there? Yes.

Where the eye sense base does not arise, does the mind sense base not arise there?

In the immaterial-sphere of existence, there the eye sense base does not arise, but the mind sense base does arise there. In the non-percipient being realm, there both the eye sense base does not arise and the mind sense base does not arise.

Or else, where the mind sense base does not arise, does the eye sense base not arise there? Yes.

Where the eye sense base does not arise, does the mind-object sense base not arise there? It arises.

Or else, where the mind-object sense base does not arise, does the eye sense base not arise there? There is not. (Eye Sense Base as Root)

33. Where the nose sense base does not arise, does the visible form sense base not arise there?

In the fine-material-sphere of existence, there the nose sense base does not arise, but the visible form sense base does arise there. In the immaterial-sphere of existence, there both the nose sense base does not arise and the visible form sense base does not arise.

Or else, where the visible form sense base does not arise, does the nose sense base not arise there? Yes.

Where the nose sense base does not arise, does the mind sense base not arise there?

In the fine-material-sphere and immaterial-sphere of existence, there the nose sense base does not arise, but the mind sense base does arise there. In the non-percipient being realm, there both the nose sense base does not arise and the mind sense base does not arise.

Or else, where the mind sense base does not arise, does the nose sense base not arise there? Yes.

Where the nose sense base does not arise, does the mind-object sense base not arise there? It arises.

Or else, where the mind-object sense base does not arise, does the nose sense base not arise there? There is not. (Nose Sense Base as Root)

34. Where the visible form sense base does not arise, does the mind sense base not arise there? It arises.

Or else, where the mind sense base does not arise, does the visible form sense base not arise there? It arises.

Where the visible form sense base does not arise, does the mind-object sense base not arise there? It arises.

Or else, where the mind-object sense base does not arise, does the visible form sense base not arise there? There is not. (Visible Form Sense Base as Root)

35. Where the mind sense base does not arise, does the mind-object sense base not arise there? It arises.

Or else, where the mind-object sense base does not arise, does the mind sense base not arise there? There is not. (Mind Sense Base as Root)

Negative - Person - Place

36. For whom and where the eye sense base does not arise, does the ear sense base not arise for that one there?

For those without eyes but with ears being reborn, for them there the eye sense base does not arise, but the ear sense base does arise for them there. For all those passing away, and for those without eyes and without ears being reborn, for them there both the eye sense base does not arise and the ear sense base does not arise.

Or else, for whom and where the ear sense base does not arise, does the eye sense base not arise for that one there?

For those without ears but with eyes being reborn, for them there the ear sense base does not arise, but the eye sense base does arise for them there. For all those passing away, and for those without ears and without eyes being reborn, for them there both the ear sense base does not arise and the eye sense base does not arise. Etc.

37. For whom and where the mind sense base does not arise, does the mind-object sense base not arise for that one there?

For those without consciousness being reborn, for them there the mind sense base does not arise, but the mind-object sense base does arise for them there. For all those passing away, for them there both the mind sense base does not arise and the mind-object sense base does not arise.

Or else, for whom and where the mind-object sense base does not arise, does the mind sense base not arise for that one there? Yes.

(2) The Section on the Past

Conformity Person

38. For whom the eye sense base arose, did the ear sense base arise for that one? Yes.

Or else, for whom the ear sense base arose, did the eye sense base arise for that one? Yes.

For whom the eye sense base arose, did the nose sense base arise for that one? Etc. the visible form sense base... the mind sense base... did the mind-object sense base arise for that one? Yes.

Or else, for whom the mind-object sense base arose, did the eye sense base arise for that one? Yes.

39. For whom the nose sense base... etc. the visible form sense base... the mind sense base arose, did the mind-object sense base arise for that one? Yes.

Or else, for whom the mind-object sense base arose, did the mind sense base arise for that one? Yes.

Conformity Place

40. Where the eye sense base arose... etc. (The 'where' section in the present, in the past, in the future, in the present-past, in the present-future, in the past-future, everywhere is similar; the name 'arises' and 'arose' should be made extra).

Conformity - Person - Place

41. For whom and where the eye sense base arose, did the ear sense base arise for that one there? Yes.

Or else, for whom and where the ear sense base arose, did the eye sense base arise for that one there? Yes.

For whom and where the eye sense base arose, did the nose sense base arise for that one there?

For fine-material-sphere beings, for them there the eye sense base arose, but the nose sense base did not arise for them there. For sensual-sphere beings, for them there both the eye sense base arose and the nose sense base arose.

Or else, for whom and where the nose sense base arose, did the eye sense base arise for that one there? Yes.

For whom and where the eye sense base arose, did the visible form sense base arise for that one there? Yes.

Or else, for whom and where the visible form sense base arose, did the eye sense base arise for that one there?

For non-percipient beings, for them there the visible form sense base arose, but the eye sense base did not arise for them there. For five-aggregate constituent beings, for them there both the visible form sense base arose and the eye sense base arose.

For whom and where the eye sense base arose, did the mind sense base arise for that one there? Yes.

Or else, for whom and where the mind sense base arose, did the eye sense base arise for that one there?

For immaterial beings, for them there the mind sense base arose, but the eye sense base did not arise for them there. For five-aggregate constituent beings, for them there both the mind sense base arose and the eye sense base arose.

For whom and where the eye sense base arose, did the mind-object sense base arise for that one there? Yes.

Or else, for whom and where the mind-object sense base arose, did the eye sense base arise for that one there?

For non-percipient beings and immaterial beings, for them there the mind-object sense base arose, but the eye sense base did not arise for them there. For five-aggregate constituent beings, for them there both the mind-object sense base arose and the eye sense base arose. (Eye Sense Base as Root)

42. For whom and where the nose sense base arose, did the visible form sense base arise for that one there? Yes.

Or else, for whom and where the visible form sense base arose, did the nose sense base arise for that one there?

For fine-material-sphere beings, for them there the visible form sense base arose, but the nose sense base did not arise for them there. For sensual-sphere beings, for them there both the visible form sense base arose and the nose sense base arose.

For whom and where the nose sense base arose, did the mind sense base arise for that one there? Yes.

Or else, for whom and where the mind sense base arose, did the nose sense base arise for that one there?

For fine-material-sphere and immaterial-sphere beings, for them there the mind sense base arose, but the nose sense base did not arise for them there. For sensual-sphere beings, for them there both the mind sense base arose and the nose sense base arose.

For whom and where the nose sense base arose, did the mind-object sense base arise for that one there? Yes.

Or else, for whom and where the mind-object sense base arose, did the nose sense base arise for that one there?

For fine-material-sphere and immaterial-sphere beings, for them there the mind-object sense base arose, but the nose sense base did not arise for them there. For sensual-sphere beings, for them there both the mind-object sense base arose and the nose sense base arose. (Nose Sense Base as Root)

43. For whom and where the visible form sense base arose, did the mind sense base arise for that one there?

For non-percipient beings, for them there the visible form sense base arose, but the mind sense base did not arise for them there. For five-aggregate constituent beings, for them there both the visible form sense base arose and the mind sense base arose.

Or else, for whom and where the mind sense base arose, did the visible form sense base arise for that one there?

For immaterial beings, for them there the mind sense base arose, but the visible form sense base did not arise for them there. For five-aggregate constituent beings, for them there both the mind sense base arose and the visible form sense base arose.

For whom and where the visible form sense base arose, did the mind-object sense base arise for that one there? Yes.

Or else, for whom and where the mind-object sense base arose, did the visible form sense base arise for that one there?

For immaterial beings, for them there the mind-object sense base arose, but the visible form sense base did not arise for them there. For five-aggregate constituent beings and non-percipient beings, for them there both the mind-object sense base arose and the visible form sense base arose. (Visible Form Sense Base as Root).

44. For whom and where the mind sense base arose, did the mind-object sense base arise for that one there? Yes.

Or else, for whom and where the mind-object sense base arose, did the mind sense base arise for that one there?

For non-percipient beings, for them there the mind-object sense base arose, but the mind sense base did not arise for them there. For four-aggregate constituent beings and five-aggregate constituent beings, for them there both the mind-object sense base arose and the mind sense base arose. (Mind Sense Base as Root)

Negative Person

45. For whom the eye sense base had not arisen, had the ear sense base not arisen for that one? There is not.

Or else, for whom the ear sense base had not arisen, had the eye sense base not arisen for that one? There is not. (Abbreviated)

46. For whom the mind sense base had not arisen, had the mind-object sense base not arisen for that one? There is not.

Or else, for whom the mind-object sense base had not arisen, had the mind sense base not arisen for that one? There is not. Etc.

The Negative Section on Place

47. Where the eye sense base had not arisen... etc.

Negative - Person - Place

48. For whom and where the eye sense base had not arisen, had the ear sense base not arisen for that one there? Yes.

Or else, for whom and where the ear sense base had not arisen, had the eye sense base not arisen for that one there? Yes.

For whom and where the eye sense base had not arisen, had the nose sense base not arisen for that one there? Yes.

Or else, for whom and where the nose sense base had not arisen, had the eye sense base not arisen for that one there?

For fine-material-sphere beings, for them there the nose sense base had not arisen, but the eye sense base had not not arisen for them there. For those in the Pure Abodes, for non-percipient beings, and for immaterial beings, for them there both the nose sense base had not arisen and the eye sense base had not arisen.

For whom and where the eye sense base had not arisen, had the visible form sense base not arisen for that one there?

For non-percipient beings, for them there the eye sense base had not arisen, but the visible form sense base had not not arisen for them there. For those in the Pure Abodes and for immaterial beings, for them there both the eye sense base had not arisen and the visible form sense base had not arisen.

Or else, for whom and where the visible form sense base had not arisen, had the eye sense base not arisen for that one there? Yes.

For whom and where the eye sense base had not arisen, had the mind sense base not arisen for that one there?

For immaterial beings, for them there the eye sense base had not arisen, but the mind sense base had not not arisen for them there. For those in the Pure Abodes and for non-percipient beings, for them there both the eye sense base had not arisen and the mind sense base had not arisen.

Or else, for whom and where the mind sense base had not arisen, had the eye sense base not arisen for that one there? Yes.

For whom and where the eye sense base had not arisen, had the mind-object sense base not arisen for that one there?

For non-percipient beings and for immaterial beings, for them there the eye sense base had not arisen, but the mind-object sense base had not not arisen for them there. For those in the Pure Abodes, for them there both the eye sense base had not arisen and the mind-object sense base had not arisen.

Or else, for whom and where the mind-object sense base had not arisen, had the eye sense base not arisen for that one there? Yes. (Eye Sense Base as Root)

49. For whom and where the nose sense base had not arisen, had the visible form sense base not arisen for that one there?

For fine-material-sphere beings, for them there the nose sense base had not arisen, but the visible form sense base had not not arisen for them there. For those in the Pure Abodes and for immaterial beings, for them there both the nose sense base had not arisen and the visible form sense base had not arisen.

Or else, for whom and where the visible form sense base had not arisen, had the nose sense base not arisen for that one there? Yes.

For whom and where the nose sense base had not arisen, had the mind sense base not arisen for that one there?

For fine-material-sphere and immaterial-sphere beings, for them there the nose sense base had not arisen, but the mind sense base had not not arisen for them there. For those in the Pure Abodes and for non-percipient beings, for them there both the nose sense base had not arisen and the mind sense base had not arisen.

Or else, for whom and where the mind sense base had not arisen, had the nose sense base not arisen for that one there? Yes.

For whom and where the nose sense base had not arisen, had the mind-object sense base not arisen for that one there?

For fine-material-sphere and immaterial-sphere beings, for them there the nose sense base had not arisen, but the mind-object sense base had not not arisen for them there. For those in the Pure Abodes, for them there both the nose sense base had not arisen and the mind-object sense base had not arisen.

Or else, for whom and where the mind-object sense base had not arisen, had the nose sense base not arisen for that one there? Yes. (Nose Sense Base as Root)

50. For whom and where the visible form sense base had not arisen, had the mind sense base not arisen for that one there?

For immaterial beings, for them there the visible form sense base had not arisen, but the mind sense base had not not arisen for them there. For those in the Pure Abodes, for them there both the visible form sense base had not arisen and the mind sense base had not arisen.

Or else, for whom and where the mind sense base had not arisen, had the visible form sense base not arisen for that one there?

For non-percipient beings, for them there the mind sense base had not arisen, but the visible form sense base had not not arisen for them there. For those in the Pure Abodes, for them there both the mind sense base had not arisen and the visible form sense base had not arisen.

For whom and where the visible form sense base had not arisen, had the mind-object sense base not arisen for that one there?

For immaterial beings, for them there the visible form sense base had not arisen, but the mind-object sense base had not not arisen for them there. For those in the Pure Abodes, for them there both the visible form sense base had not arisen and the mind-object sense base had not arisen.

Or else, for whom and where the mind-object sense base had not arisen, had the visible form sense base not arisen for that one there? Yes. (Visible Form Sense Base as Root)

51. For whom and where the mind sense base had not arisen, had the mind-object sense base not arisen for that one there?

For non-percipient beings, for them there the mind sense base had not arisen, but the mind-object sense base had not not arisen for them there. For those in the Pure Abodes, for them there both the mind sense base had not arisen and the mind-object sense base had not arisen.

Or else, for whom and where the mind-object sense base had not arisen, had the mind sense base not arisen for that one there? Yes. (Mind Sense Base as Root)

(3) The Section on the Future

Conformity Person

52. For whom the eye sense base will arise, will the ear sense base arise for that one? Yes.

Or else, for whom the ear sense base will arise, will the eye sense base arise for that one? Yes.

For whom the eye sense base will arise, will the nose sense base arise for that one?

For those who, having been reborn in the fine-material-sphere, will attain final nibbāna, for them the eye sense base will arise, but the nose sense base will not arise for them. For the others, for them both the eye sense base will arise and the nose sense base will arise.

Or else, for whom the nose sense base will arise, will the eye sense base arise for that one? Yes.

For whom the eye sense base will arise, will the visible form sense base arise for that one? Yes.

Or else, for whom the visible form sense base will arise, will the eye sense base arise for that one? Yes.

For whom the eye sense base will arise (the mind sense base and the mind-object sense base for that one are similar, these two are indeed similar).

For whom the eye sense base will arise, will the mind-object sense base arise for that one? Yes.

Or else, for whom the mind-object sense base will arise, will the eye sense base arise for that one?

For those who, having been reborn in the immaterial realm, will attain final nibbāna, for them the mind-object sense base will arise, but the eye sense base will not arise for them. For the others, for them both the mind-object sense base will arise and the eye sense base will arise. (Eye Sense Base as Root)

53. For whom the nose sense base will arise, will the visible form sense base arise for that one? Yes.

Or else, for whom the visible form sense base will arise, will the nose sense base arise for that one?

For those who, having been reborn in the fine-material-sphere, will attain final nibbāna, for them the visible form sense base will arise, but the nose sense base will not arise for them. For the others, for them both the visible form sense base will arise and the nose sense base will arise.

For whom the nose sense base will arise, will the mind sense base... etc. the mind-object sense base arise for that one? Yes.

Or else, for whom the mind-object sense base will arise, will the nose sense base arise for that one?

For those who, having been reborn in the fine-material-sphere and immaterial-sphere, will attain final nibbāna, for them the mind-object sense base will arise, but the nose sense base will not arise for them. For the others, for them both the mind-object sense base will arise and the nose sense base will arise. (Nose Sense Base as Root)

54. For whom the visible form sense base will arise, will the mind sense base... etc. the mind-object sense base arise for that one? Yes.

Or else, for whom the mind-object sense base will arise, will the visible form sense base arise for that one?

For those who, having been reborn in the immaterial realm, will attain final nibbāna, for them the mind-object sense base will arise, but the visible form sense base will not arise for them. For the others, for them both the mind-object sense base will arise and the visible form sense base will arise. (Visible Form Sense Base as Root).

55. For whom the mind sense base will arise, will the mind-object sense base arise for that one? Yes.

Or else, for whom the mind-object sense base will arise, will the mind sense base arise for that one? Yes. (Mind Sense Base as Root)

Conformity Place

56. Where the eye sense base will arise... etc.

Conformity - Person - Place

57. For whom and where the eye sense base will arise, will the ear sense base arise for that one there? Yes.

Or else, for whom and where the ear sense base will arise, will the eye sense base arise for that one there? Yes.

For whom and where the eye sense base will arise, will the nose sense base arise for that one there?

For fine-material-sphere beings, for them there the eye sense base will arise, but the nose sense base will not arise for them there. For sensual-sphere beings, for them there both the eye sense base will arise and the nose sense base will arise.

Or else, for whom and where the nose sense base will arise, will the eye sense base arise for that one there? Yes.

For whom and where the eye sense base will arise, will the visible form sense base arise for that one there? Yes.

Or else, for whom and where the visible form sense base will arise, will the eye sense base arise for that one there?

For non-percipient beings, for them there the visible form sense base will arise, but the eye sense base will not arise for them there. For five-aggregate constituent beings, for them there both the visible form sense base will arise and the eye sense base will arise.

For whom and where the eye sense base will arise, will the mind sense base arise for that one there? Yes.

Or else, for whom and where the mind sense base will arise, will the eye sense base arise for that one there?

For immaterial beings, for them there the mind sense base will arise, but the eye sense base will not arise for them there. For five-aggregate constituent beings, for them there both the mind sense base will arise and the eye sense base will arise.

For whom and where the eye sense base will arise, will the mind-object sense base arise for that one there? Yes.

Or else, for whom and where the mind-object sense base will arise, will the eye sense base arise for that one there?

For non-percipient beings and immaterial beings, for them there the mind-object sense base will arise, but the eye sense base will not arise for them there. For five-aggregate constituent beings, for them there both the mind-object sense base will arise and the eye sense base will arise. (Eye Sense Base as Root)

58. For whom and where the nose sense base will arise, will the visible form sense base arise for that one there? Yes.

Or else, for whom and where the visible form sense base will arise, will the nose sense base arise for that one there?

For fine-material-sphere beings, for them there the visible form sense base will arise, but the nose sense base will not arise for them there. For sensual-sphere beings, for them there both the visible form sense base will arise and the nose sense base will arise.

For whom and where the nose sense base will arise, will the mind sense base... etc. the mind-object sense base arise for that one? Yes.

Or else, for whom and where the mind-object sense base will arise, will the nose sense base arise for that one there?

For fine-material-sphere and immaterial-sphere beings, for them there the mind-object sense base will arise, but the nose sense base will not arise for them there. For sensual-sphere beings, for them there both the mind-object sense base will arise and the nose sense base will arise. (Nose Sense Base as Root)

59. For whom and where the visible form sense base will arise, will the mind sense base arise for that one there?

For non-percipient beings, for them there the visible form sense base will arise, but the mind sense base will not arise for them there. For five-aggregate constituent beings, for them there both the visible form sense base will arise and the mind sense base will arise.

Or else, for whom and where the mind sense base will arise, will the visible form sense base arise for that one there?

For immaterial beings, for them there the mind sense base will arise, but the visible form sense base will not arise for them there. For five-aggregate constituent beings, for them there both the mind sense base will arise and the visible form sense base will arise.

For whom and where the visible form sense base will arise, will the mind-object sense base arise for that one there? Yes.

Or else, for whom and where the mind-object sense base will arise, will the visible form sense base arise for that one there?

For immaterial beings, for them there the mind-object sense base will arise, but the visible form sense base will not arise for them there. For five-aggregate constituent beings and non-percipient beings, for them there both the mind-object sense base will arise and the visible form sense base will arise. (Visible Form Sense Base as Root)

60. For whom and where the mind sense base will arise, will the mind-object sense base arise for that one there? Yes.

Or else, for whom and where the mind-object sense base will arise, will the mind sense base arise for that one there?

For non-percipient beings, for them there the mind-object sense base will arise, but the mind sense base will not arise for them there. For four-aggregate constituent beings and five-aggregate constituent beings, for them there both the mind-object sense base will arise and the mind sense base will arise. (Mind Sense Base as Root)

Negative Person

61. For whom the eye sense base will not arise, will the ear sense base not arise for that one? Yes.

Or else, for whom the ear sense base will not arise, will the eye sense base not arise for that one? Yes.

For whom the eye sense base will not arise, will the nose sense base not arise for that one? Yes.

Or else, for whom the nose sense base will not arise, will the eye sense base not arise for that one?

For those who, having been reborn in the fine-material-sphere, will attain final nibbāna, for them the nose sense base will not arise, but the eye sense base will not fail to arise for them. For those in their last existence and for those who, having been reborn in the immaterial realm, will attain final nibbāna, for them both the nose sense base will not arise and the eye sense base will not arise.

For whom the eye sense base will not arise, will the visible form sense base not arise for that one? Yes.

Or else, for whom the visible form sense base will not arise, will the eye sense base not arise for that one? Yes.

For whom the eye sense base will not arise, will the mind sense base... etc. will the mind-object sense base not arise?

For those who, having been reborn in the immaterial realm, will attain final nibbāna, for them the eye sense base will not arise, but the mind-object sense base will not fail to arise for them. For those in their last existence, for them both the eye sense base will not arise and the mind-object sense base will not arise.

Or else, for whom the mind-object sense base will not arise, will the eye sense base not arise for that one? Yes. (Eye Sense Base as Root)

62. For whom the nose sense base will not arise, will the visible form sense base not arise for that one?

For those who, having been reborn in the fine-material-sphere, will attain final nibbāna, for them the nose sense base will not arise, but the visible form sense base will not fail to arise for them. For those in their last existence and for those who, having been reborn in the immaterial realm, will attain final nibbāna, for them both the nose sense base will not arise and the visible form sense base will not arise.

Or else, for whom the visible form sense base will not arise, will the nose sense base not arise for that one? Yes.

For whom the nose sense base will not arise, will the mind sense base... etc. will the mind-object sense base not arise?

For those who, having been reborn in the fine-material-sphere and immaterial-sphere, will attain final nibbāna, for them the nose sense base will not arise, but the mind-object sense base will not fail to arise for them. For those in their last existence, for them both the nose sense base will not arise and the mind-object sense base will not arise.

Or else, for whom the mind-object sense base will not arise, will the nose sense base not arise for that one? Yes. (Nose Sense Base as Root)

63. For whom the visible form sense base will not arise, will the mind sense base... etc. will the mind-object sense base not arise?

For those who, having been reborn in the immaterial realm, will attain final nibbāna, for them the visible form sense base will not arise, but the mind-object sense base will not fail to arise for them. For those in their last existence, for them both the visible form sense base will not arise and the mind-object sense base will not arise.

Or else, for whom the mind-object sense base will not arise, will the visible form sense base not arise for that one? Yes. (Visible Form Sense Base as Root)

64. For whom the mind sense base will not arise, will the mind-object sense base not arise for that one? Yes.

Or else, for whom the mind-object sense base will not arise, will the mind sense base not arise for that one? Yes. (Mind Sense Base as Root)

The Negative Section on Place

65. Where the eye sense base will not arise... etc.

Negative - Person - Place

66. For whom and where the eye sense base will not arise, will the ear sense base not arise for that one there? Yes.

Or else, for whom and where the ear sense base will not arise, will the eye sense base not arise for that one there? Yes.

For whom and where the eye sense base will not arise, will the nose sense base not arise for that one there? Yes.

Or else, for whom and where the nose sense base will not arise, will the eye sense base not arise for that one there?

For fine-material-sphere beings, for them there the nose sense base will not arise, but the eye sense base will not fail to arise for them there. For beings in their last existence in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for non-percipient beings, and for immaterial beings, for them there both the nose sense base will not arise and the eye sense base will not arise.

For whom and where the eye sense base will not arise, will the visible form sense base not arise for that one there?

For non-percipient beings, for them there the eye sense base will not arise, but the visible form sense base will not fail to arise for them there. For beings in their last existence in the five-aggregate constituent realm and for immaterial beings, for them there both the eye sense base will not arise and the visible form sense base will not arise.

Or else, for whom and where the visible form sense base will not arise, will the eye sense base not arise for that one there? Yes.

For whom and where the eye sense base will not arise, will the mind sense base not arise for that one there?

For immaterial beings, for them there the eye sense base will not arise, but the mind sense base will not fail to arise for them there. For beings in their last existence and for non-percipient beings, for them there both the eye sense base will not arise and the mind sense base will not arise.

Or else, for whom and where the mind sense base will not arise, will the eye sense base not arise for that one there? Yes.

For whom and where the eye sense base will not arise, will the mind-object sense base not arise for that one there?

For non-percipient beings and for immaterial beings, for them there the eye sense base will not arise, but the mind-object sense base will not fail to arise for them there. For beings in their last existence, for them there both the eye sense base will not arise and the mind-object sense base will not arise.

Or else, for whom and where the mind-object sense base will not arise, will the eye sense base not arise for that one there? Yes. (Eye Sense Base as Root)

67. For whom and where the nose sense base will not arise, will the visible form sense base not arise for that one there?

For fine-material-sphere beings, for them there the nose sense base will not arise, but the visible form sense base will not fail to arise for them there. For beings in their last existence in the five-aggregate constituent realm and for immaterial beings, for them there both the nose sense base will not arise and the visible form sense base will not arise.

Or else, for whom and where the visible form sense base will not arise, will the nose sense base not arise for that one there? Yes.

For whom and where the nose sense base will not arise, will the mind sense base not arise for that one there?

For fine-material-sphere and immaterial-sphere beings, for them there the nose sense base will not arise, but the mind sense base will not fail to arise for them there. For beings in their last existence and for non-percipient beings, for them there both the nose sense base will not arise and the mind sense base will not arise.

Or else, for whom and where the mind sense base will not arise, will the nose sense base not arise for that one there? Yes.

For whom and where the nose sense base will not arise, will the mind-object sense base not arise for that one there?

For fine-material-sphere and immaterial-sphere beings, for them there the nose sense base will not arise, but the mind-object sense base will not fail to arise for them there. For those in their last existence, for them there both the nose sense base will not arise and the mind-object sense base will not arise.

Or else, for whom and where the mind-object sense base will not arise, will the nose sense base not arise for that one there? Yes. (Nose Sense Base as Root)

68. For whom and where the visible form sense base will not arise, will the mind sense base not arise for that one there?

For immaterial beings, for them there the visible form sense base will not arise, but the mind sense base will not fail to arise for them there. For those in their last existence, for them there both the visible form sense base will not arise and the mind sense base will not arise.

Or else, for whom and where the mind sense base will not arise, will the visible form sense base not arise for that one there?

For non-percipient beings, for them there the mind sense base will not arise, but the visible form sense base will not fail to arise for them there. For those in their last existence, for them there both the mind sense base will not arise and the visible form sense base will not arise.

For whom and where the visible form sense base will not arise, will the mind-object sense base not arise for that one there?

For immaterial beings, for them there the visible form sense base will not arise, but the mind-object sense base will not fail to arise for them there. For those in their last existence, for them there both the visible form sense base will not arise and the mind-object sense base will not arise.

Or else, for whom and where the mind-object sense base will not arise, will the visible form sense base not arise for that one there? Yes. (Visible Form Sense Base as Root)

69. For whom and where the mind sense base will not arise, will the mind-object sense base not arise for that one there?

For non-percipient beings, for them there the mind sense base will not arise, but the mind-object sense base will not fail to arise for them there. For those in their last existence, for them there both the mind sense base will not arise and the mind-object sense base will not arise.

Or else, for whom and where the mind-object sense base will not arise, will the mind sense base not arise for that one there? Yes. (Mind Sense Base as Root)

(4) The Section on Present and Past

Conformity Person

70. For whom the eye sense base arises, did the ear sense base arise for that one? Yes.

Or else, for whom the ear sense base arose, does the eye sense base arise for that one?

For all those passing away, and for those without eyes being reborn, for them the ear sense base arose, but the eye sense base does not arise for them. For those with eyes being reborn, for them both the ear sense base arose and the eye sense base arises.

For whom the eye sense base arises, does the nose sense base... etc. the visible form sense base... the mind sense base... did the mind-object sense base arise for that one? Yes.

Or else, for whom the mind-object sense base arose, does the eye sense base arise for that one?

For all those passing away, and for those without eyes being reborn, for them the mind-object sense base arose, but the eye sense base does not arise for them. For those with eyes being reborn, for them both the mind-object sense base arose and the eye sense base arises. (Eye Sense Base as Root)

71. For whom the nose sense base arises, does the visible form sense base... etc. the mind sense base... did the mind-object sense base arise for that one? Yes.

Or else, for whom the mind-object sense base arose, does the nose sense base arise for that one?

For all those passing away, and for those without nose being reborn, for them the mind-object sense base arose, but the nose sense base does not arise for them. For those with nose being reborn, for them both the mind-object sense base arose and the nose sense base arises. (Nose Sense Base as Root)

72. For whom the visible form sense base arises, does the mind sense base... etc. did the mind-object sense base arise for that one? Yes.

Or else, for whom the mind-object sense base arose, does the visible form sense base arise for that one?

For all those passing away, and for immaterial beings being reborn, for them the mind-object sense base arose, but the visible form sense base does not arise for them. For those with material form being reborn, for them both the mind-object sense base arose and the visible form sense base arises. (Visible Form Sense Base as Root)

73. For whom the mind sense base arises, did the mind-object sense base arise for that one? Yes.

Or else, for whom the mind-object sense base arose, does the mind sense base arise for that one?

For all those passing away, and for those without consciousness being reborn, for them the mind-object sense base arose, but the mind sense base does not arise for them. For those with consciousness being reborn, for them both the mind-object sense base arose and the mind sense base arises. (Mind Sense Base as Root)

Conformity Place

74. Where the eye sense base arises, did the ear sense base arise there? Yes. Etc.

Conformity - Person - Place

75. For whom and where the eye sense base arises, did the ear sense base arise for that one there?

For those being reborn in the pure abode, for them there the eye sense base arises, but the ear sense base did not arise for them there. For the others with eyes being reborn, for them there both the eye sense base arises and the ear sense base arose.

Or else, for whom and where the ear sense base arose, does the eye sense base arise for that one there?

For those passing away from the five-aggregate constituent realm, without eyes, being reborn in the sensual-sphere of existence, for them there the ear sense base arose, but the eye sense base does not arise for them there. For those with eyes being reborn, for them there both the ear sense base arose and the eye sense base arises.

For whom and where the eye sense base arises, did the nose sense base arise for that one there?

For those being reborn in the fine-material-sphere, for them there the eye sense base arises, but the nose sense base did not arise for them there. For those with eyes being reborn in the sensual-sphere of existence, for them there both the eye sense base arises and the nose sense base arose.

Or else, for whom and where the nose sense base arose, does the eye sense base arise for that one there?

For those passing away from the sensual-sphere of existence, without eyes, being reborn in the sensual-sphere of existence, for them there the nose sense base arose, but the eye sense base does not arise for them there. For those with eyes being reborn in the sensual-sphere of existence, for them there both the nose sense base arose and the eye sense base arises.

For whom and where the eye sense base arises, did the visible form sense base arise for that one there?

For those being reborn in the pure abode, for them there the eye sense base arises, but the visible form sense base did not arise for them there. For the others with eyes being reborn, for them there both the eye sense base arises and the visible form sense base arose.

Or else, for whom and where the visible form sense base arose, does the eye sense base arise for that one there?

For those passing away from the five-aggregate constituent realm, without eyes, being reborn in the sensual-sphere of existence, and for non-percipient beings, for them there the visible form sense base arose, but the eye sense base does not arise for them there. For those with eyes being reborn, for them there both the visible form sense base arose and the eye sense base arises.

For whom and where the eye sense base arises, did the mind sense base arise for that one there?

For those being reborn in the pure abode, for them there the eye sense base arises, but the mind sense base did not arise for them there. For the others with eyes being reborn, for them there both the eye sense base arises and the mind sense base arose.

Or else, for whom and where the mind sense base arose, does the eye sense base arise for that one there?

For those passing away from the five-aggregate constituent realm, without eyes, being reborn in the sensual-sphere of existence, and for immaterial beings, for them there the mind sense base arose, but the eye sense base does not arise for them there. For those with eyes being reborn, for them there both the mind sense base arose and the eye sense base arises.

For whom and where the eye sense base arises, did the mind-object sense base arise for that one there?

For those being reborn in the pure abode, for them there the eye sense base arises, but the mind-object sense base did not arise for them there. For the others with eyes being reborn, for them there both the eye sense base arises and the mind-object sense base arose.

Or else, for whom and where the mind-object sense base arose, does the eye sense base arise for that one there?

For all those passing away, and for those without eyes being reborn, for them there the mind-object sense base arose, but the eye sense base does not arise for them there. For those with eyes being reborn, for them there both the mind-object sense base arose and the eye sense base arises. (Eye Sense Base as Root)

76. For whom and where the nose sense base arises, did the visible form sense base arise for that one there? Yes.

Or else, for whom and where the visible form sense base arose, does the nose sense base arise for that one there?

For those passing away from the sensual-sphere of existence, without nose, being reborn in the sensual-sphere of existence, and for fine-material-sphere beings, for them there the visible form sense base arose, but the nose sense base does not arise for them there. For those with nose being reborn, for them there both the visible form sense base arose and the nose sense base arises.

For whom and where the nose sense base arises, did the mind sense base arise for that one there? Yes.

Or else, for whom and where the mind sense base arose, does the nose sense base arise for that one there?

For those passing away from the sensual-sphere of existence, without nose, being reborn in the sensual-sphere of existence, and for fine-material-sphere and immaterial-sphere beings, for them there the mind sense base arose, but the nose sense base does not arise for them there. For those with nose being reborn, for them there both the mind sense base arose and the nose sense base arises.

For whom and where the nose sense base arises, did the mind-object sense base arise for that one there? Yes.

Or else, for whom and where the mind-object sense base arose, does the nose sense base arise for that one there?

For all those passing away, and for those without nose being reborn, for them there the mind-object sense base arose, but the nose sense base does not arise for them there. For those with nose being reborn, for them there both the mind-object sense base arose and the nose sense base arises. (Nose Sense Base as Root)

77. For whom and where the visible form sense base arises, did the mind sense base arise for that one there?

For those being reborn in the pure abode, for those being reborn in the non-percipient being realm, for them there the visible form sense base arises, but the mind sense base did not arise for them there. For the others being reborn in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them there both the visible form sense base arises and the mind sense base arose.

Or else, for whom and where the mind sense base arose, does the visible form sense base arise for that one there?

For those passing away from the five-aggregate constituent realm to the immaterial realm, for them there the mind sense base arose, but the visible form sense base does not arise for them there. For those being reborn in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them there both the mind sense base arose and the visible form sense base arises.

For whom and where the visible form sense base arises, did the mind-object sense base arise for that one there?

For those being reborn in the pure abode, for them there the visible form sense base arises, but the mind-object sense base did not arise for them there. For the others with material form being reborn, for them there both the visible form sense base arises and the mind-object sense base arose.

Or else, for whom and where the mind-object sense base arose, does the visible form sense base arise for that one there?

For all those passing away, and for immaterial beings being reborn, for them there the mind-object sense base arose, but the visible form sense base does not arise for them there. For those with material form being reborn, for them there both the mind-object sense base arose and the visible form sense base arises. (Visible Form Sense Base as Root)

78. For whom and where the mind sense base arises, did the mind-object sense base arise for that one there?

For those being reborn in the pure abode, for them there the mind sense base arises, but the mind-object sense base did not arise for them there. For the others with consciousness being reborn, for them there both the mind sense base arises and the mind-object sense base arose.

Or else, for whom and where the mind-object sense base arose, does the mind sense base arise for that one there?

For all those passing away, and for those without consciousness being reborn, for them there the mind-object sense base arose, but the mind sense base does not arise for them there. For those with consciousness being reborn, for them there both the mind-object sense base arose and the mind sense base arises. (Mind Sense Base as Root)

Negative Person

79. For whom the eye sense base does not arise, had the ear sense base not arisen for that one? It had arisen.

Or else, for whom the ear sense base had not arisen, does the eye sense base not arise for that one? There is not.

For whom the eye sense base does not arise, the nose sense base... etc. the visible form sense base... the mind sense base... had the mind-object sense base not arisen? It had arisen.

Or else, for whom the mind-object sense base had not arisen, does the eye sense base not arise for that one? There is not.

80. For whom the nose sense base... etc. the visible form sense base... For whom the mind sense base does not arise, had the mind-object sense base not arisen for that one? It had arisen.

Or else, for whom the mind-object sense base had not arisen, does the mind sense base not arise for that one? There is not.

The Negative Section on Place

81. Where the eye sense base does not arise, etc.

Negative - Person - Place

82. For whom and where the eye sense base does not arise, had the ear sense base not arisen for that one there?

For those passing away from the five-aggregate constituent realm, without eyes, being reborn in the sensual-sphere of existence, for them there the eye sense base does not arise, but the ear sense base had arisen for them there. For those attaining final nibbana in the Pure Abodes, for non-percipient beings, and for immaterial beings, for them there both the eye sense base does not arise and the ear sense base had not arisen.

Or else, for whom and where the ear sense base had not arisen, does the eye sense base not arise for that one there?

For those being reborn in the Pure Abodes, for them there the ear sense base had not arisen, but the eye sense base does arise for them there. For those attaining final nibbana in the Pure Abodes, for non-percipient beings, and for immaterial beings, for them there both the ear sense base had not arisen and the eye sense base does not arise.

For whom and where the eye sense base does not arise, had the nose sense base not arisen for that one there?

For those passing away from the sensual-sphere of existence, without eyes, being reborn in the sensual-sphere of existence, for them there the eye sense base does not arise, but the nose sense base had arisen for them there. For those passing away from the fine-material-sphere, for non-percipient beings, and for immaterial beings, for them there both the eye sense base does not arise and the nose sense base had not arisen.

Or else, for whom and where the nose sense base had not arisen, does the eye sense base not arise for that one there?

For those being reborn in the fine-material-sphere, for them there the nose sense base had not arisen, but the eye sense base does arise for them there. For those passing away from the fine-material-sphere, for non-percipient beings, and for immaterial beings, for them there both the nose sense base had not arisen and the eye sense base does not arise.

For whom and where the eye sense base does not arise, had the visible form sense base not arisen for that one there?

For those passing away from the five-aggregate constituent realm, without eyes, being reborn in the sensual-sphere of existence, and for non-percipient beings, for them there the eye sense base does not arise, but the visible form sense base had arisen for them there. For those attaining final nibbana in the Pure Abodes and for immaterial beings, for them there both the eye sense base does not arise and the visible form sense base had not arisen.

Or else, for whom and where the visible form sense base had not arisen, does the eye sense base not arise for that one there?

For those being reborn in the Pure Abodes, for them there the visible form sense base had not arisen, but the eye sense base does arise for them there. For those attaining final nibbana in the Pure Abodes and for immaterial beings, for them there both the visible form sense base had not arisen and the eye sense base does not arise.

For whom and where the eye sense base does not arise, had the mind sense base not arisen for that one there?

For those passing away from the five-aggregate constituent realm, without eyes, being reborn in the sensual-sphere of existence, and for immaterial beings, for them there the eye sense base does not arise, but the mind sense base had arisen for them there. For those attaining final nibbana in the Pure Abodes and for non-percipient beings, for them there both the eye sense base does not arise and the mind sense base had not arisen.

Or else, for whom and where the mind sense base had not arisen, does the eye sense base not arise for that one there?

For those being reborn in the Pure Abodes, for them there the mind sense base had not arisen, but the eye sense base does arise for them there. For those attaining final nibbana in the Pure Abodes and for non-percipient beings, for them there both the mind sense base had not arisen and the eye sense base does not arise.

For whom and where the eye sense base does not arise, had the mind-object sense base not arisen for that one there?

For all those passing away, and for those without eyes being reborn, for them there the eye sense base does not arise, but the mind-object sense base had arisen for them there. For those attaining final nibbana in the Pure Abodes, for them there both the eye sense base does not arise and the mind-object sense base had not arisen.

Or else, for whom and where the mind-object sense base had not arisen, does the eye sense base not arise for that one there?

For those being reborn in the Pure Abodes, for them there the mind-object sense base had not arisen, but the eye sense base does arise for them there. For those attaining final nibbana in the Pure Abodes, for them there both the mind-object sense base had not arisen and the eye sense base does not arise. (Eye Sense Base as Root)

83. For whom and where the nose sense base does not arise, had the visible form sense base not arisen for that one there?

For those passing away from the sensual-sphere of existence, without nose, being reborn in the sensual-sphere of existence, and for fine-material-sphere beings, for them there the nose sense base does not arise, but the visible form sense base had arisen for them there. For those in the Pure Abodes and for immaterial beings, for them there both the nose sense base does not arise and the visible form sense base had not arisen.

Or else, for whom and where the visible form sense base had not arisen, does the nose sense base not arise for that one there? Yes.

For whom and where the nose sense base does not arise, had the mind sense base not arisen for that one there?

For those passing away from the sensual-sphere of existence, without nose, being reborn in the sensual-sphere of existence, and for fine-material-sphere and immaterial-sphere beings, for them there the nose sense base does not arise, but the mind sense base had arisen for them there. For those in the Pure Abodes and for non-percipient beings, for them there both the nose sense base does not arise and the mind sense base had not arisen.

Or else, for whom and where the mind sense base had not arisen, does the nose sense base not arise for that one there? Yes.

For whom and where the nose sense base does not arise, had the mind-object sense base not arisen for that one there?

For all those passing away, and for those without nose being reborn, for them there the nose sense base does not arise, but the mind-object sense base had arisen for them there. For those in the Pure Abodes, for them there both the nose sense base does not arise and the mind-object sense base had not arisen.

Or else, for whom and where the mind-object sense base had not arisen, does the nose sense base not arise for that one there? Yes. (Nose Sense Base as Root)

84. For whom and where the visible form sense base does not arise, had the mind sense base not arisen for that one there?

For those passing away from the five-aggregate constituent realm to the immaterial realm, for them there the visible form sense base does not arise, but the mind sense base had arisen for them there. For those attaining final nibbana in the Pure Abodes, for those passing away from the non-percipient being realm, for them there both the visible form sense base does not arise and the mind sense base had not arisen.

Or else, for whom and where the mind sense base had not arisen, does the visible form sense base not arise for that one there?

For those being reborn in the Pure Abodes, for those being reborn in the non-percipient being realm, for them there the mind sense base had not arisen, but the visible form sense base does arise for them there. For those attaining final nibbana in the Pure Abodes, for those passing away from the non-percipient being realm, for them there both the mind sense base had not arisen and the visible form sense base does not arise.

For whom and where the visible form sense base does not arise, had the mind-object sense base not arisen for that one there?

For all those passing away, and for immaterial beings being reborn, for them there the visible form sense base does not arise, but the mind-object sense base had arisen for them there. For those attaining final nibbana in the Pure Abodes, for them there both the visible form sense base does not arise and the mind-object sense base had not arisen.

Or else, for whom and where the mind-object sense base had not arisen, does the visible form sense base not arise for that one there?

For those being reborn in the Pure Abodes, for them there the mind-object sense base had not arisen, but the visible form sense base does arise for them there. For those attaining final nibbana in the Pure Abodes, for them there both the mind-object sense base had not arisen and the visible form sense base does not arise. (Visible Form Sense Base as Root)

85. For whom and where the mind sense base does not arise, had the mind-object sense base not arisen for that one there?

For all those passing away, for those without consciousness being reborn, for them there the mind sense base does not arise, but the mind-object sense base had arisen for them there. For those attaining final nibbana in the Pure Abodes, for them there both the mind sense base does not arise and the mind-object sense base had not arisen.

Or else, for whom and where the mind-object sense base had not arisen, does the mind sense base not arise for that one there?

For those being reborn in the Pure Abodes, for them there the mind-object sense base had not arisen, but the mind sense base does arise for them there. For those attaining final nibbana in the Pure Abodes, for them there both the mind-object sense base had not arisen and the mind sense base does not arise. (Mind Sense Base as Root)

(5) The Section on Present and Future

Conformity Person

86. For whom the eye sense base arises, will the ear sense base arise for that one?

For those in their last existence being reborn in the five-aggregate constituent realm, and for those who, having been reborn in the immaterial realm, will attain final nibbāna, for them being reborn, for them the eye sense base arises, but the ear sense base will not arise for them. For the others with eyes being reborn, for them both the eye sense base arises and the ear sense base will arise.

Or else, for whom the ear sense base will arise, does the eye sense base arise for that one?

For all those passing away, and for those without eyes being reborn, for them the ear sense base will arise, but the eye sense base does not arise for them. For those with eyes being reborn, for them both the ear sense base will arise and the eye sense base arises.

For whom the eye sense base arises, will the nose sense base arise for that one?

For those in their last existence being reborn in the five-aggregate constituent realm, and for those who, having been reborn in the fine-material-sphere and immaterial-sphere of existence, will attain final nibbāna, for them being reborn, for them the eye sense base arises, but the nose sense base will not arise for them. For the others with eyes being reborn, for them both the eye sense base arises and the nose sense base will arise.

Or else, for whom the nose sense base will arise, does the eye sense base arise for that one?

For all those passing away, and for those without eyes being reborn, for them the nose sense base will arise, but the eye sense base does not arise for them. For those with eyes being reborn, for them both the nose sense base will arise and the eye sense base arises.

For whom the eye sense base arises, will the visible form sense base arise for that one?

For those in their last existence being reborn in the five-aggregate constituent realm, and for those who, having been reborn in the immaterial realm, will attain final nibbāna, for them being reborn, for them the eye sense base arises, but the visible form sense base will not arise for them. For the others with eyes being reborn, for them both the eye sense base arises and the visible form sense base will arise.

Or else, for whom the visible form sense base will arise, does the eye sense base arise for that one?

For all those passing away, and for those without eyes being reborn, for them the visible form sense base will arise, but the eye sense base does not arise for them. For those with eyes being reborn, for them both the visible form sense base will arise and the eye sense base arises.

For whom the eye sense base arises, will the mind sense base arise for that one?

For those in their last existence being reborn in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them the eye sense base arises, but the mind sense base will not arise for them. For the others with eyes being reborn, for them both the eye sense base arises and the mind sense base will arise.

Or else, for whom the mind sense base will arise, does the eye sense base arise for that one?

For all those passing away, and for those without eyes being reborn, for them the mind sense base will arise, but the eye sense base does not arise for them. For those with eyes being reborn, for them both the mind sense base will arise and the eye sense base arises.

For whom the eye sense base arises, will the mind-object sense base arise for that one?

For those in their last existence being reborn in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them the eye sense base arises, but the mind-object sense base will not arise for them. For the others with eyes being reborn, for them both the eye sense base arises and the mind-object sense base will arise.

Or else, for whom the mind-object sense base will arise, does the eye sense base arise for that one?

For all those passing away, and for those without eyes being reborn, for them the mind-object sense base will arise, but the eye sense base does not arise for them. For those with eyes being reborn, for them both the mind-object sense base will arise and the eye sense base arises. (Eye Sense Base as Root)

87. For whom the nose sense base arises, will the visible form sense base arise for that one?

For those in their last existence being reborn in the sensual-sphere of existence, and for those who, having been reborn in the immaterial realm, will attain final nibbāna, for them being reborn, for them the nose sense base arises, but the visible form sense base will not arise for them. For the others with nose being reborn, for them both the nose sense base arises and the visible form sense base will arise.

Or else, for whom the visible form sense base will arise, does the nose sense base arise for that one?

For all those passing away, and for those without nose being reborn, for them the visible form sense base will arise, but the nose sense base does not arise for them. For those with nose being reborn, for them both the visible form sense base will arise and the nose sense base arises.

For whom the nose sense base arises, will the mind sense base arise for that one?

For those in their last existence being reborn in the sensual-sphere of existence, for them the nose sense base arises, but the mind sense base will not arise for them. For the others with nose being reborn, for them both the nose sense base arises and the mind sense base will arise.

Or else, for whom the mind sense base will arise, does the nose sense base arise for that one?

For all those passing away, and for those without nose being reborn, for them the mind sense base will arise, but the nose sense base does not arise for them. For those with nose being reborn, for them both the mind sense base will arise and the nose sense base arises.

For whom the nose sense base arises, will the mind-object sense base arise for that one?

For those in their last existence being reborn in the sensual-sphere of existence, for them the nose sense base arises, but the mind-object sense base will not arise for them. For the others with nose being reborn, for them both the nose sense base arises and the mind-object sense base will arise.

Or else, for whom the mind-object sense base will arise, does the nose sense base arise for that one?

For all those passing away, and for those without nose being reborn, for them the mind-object sense base will arise, but the nose sense base does not arise for them. For those with nose being reborn, for them both the mind-object sense base will arise and the nose sense base arises. (Nose Sense Base as Root)

88. For whom the visible form sense base arises, will the mind sense base arise for that one?

For those in their last existence being reborn in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them the visible form sense base arises, but the mind sense base will not arise for them. For the others with material form being reborn, for them both the visible form sense base arises and the mind sense base will arise.

Or else, for whom the mind sense base will arise, does the visible form sense base arise for that one?

For all those passing away, and for immaterial beings being reborn, for them the mind sense base will arise, but the visible form sense base does not arise for them. For those with material form being reborn, for them both the mind sense base will arise and the visible form sense base arises.

For whom the visible form sense base arises, will the mind-object sense base arise for that one?

For those in their last existence being reborn in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them the visible form sense base arises, but the mind-object sense base will not arise for them. For the others with material form being reborn, for them both the visible form sense base arises and the mind-object sense base will arise.

Or else, for whom the mind-object sense base will arise, does the visible form sense base arise for that one?

For all those passing away, and for immaterial beings being reborn, for them the mind-object sense base will arise, but the visible form sense base does not arise for them. For those with material form being reborn, for them both the mind-object sense base will arise and the visible form sense base arises. (Visible Form Sense Base as Root)

89. For whom the mind sense base arises, will the mind-object sense base arise for that one?

For those in their last existence being reborn, for them the mind sense base arises, but the mind-object sense base will not arise for them. For the others with consciousness being reborn, for them both the mind sense base arises and the mind-object sense base will arise.

Or else, for whom the mind-object sense base will arise, does the mind sense base arise for that one?

For all those passing away, and for those without consciousness being reborn, for them the mind-object sense base will arise, but the mind sense base does not arise for them. For those with consciousness being reborn, for them both the mind-object sense base will arise and the mind sense base arises.

Conformity Place

90. Where the eye sense base arises... etc.

Conformity - Person - Place

91. For whom and where the eye sense base arises, will the ear sense base arise for that one there?

For those in their last existence being reborn in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them there the eye sense base arises, but the ear sense base will not arise for them there. For the others with eyes being reborn, for them there both the eye sense base arises and the ear sense base will arise.

Or else, for whom and where the ear sense base will arise, does the eye sense base arise for that one there?

For those passing away from the five-aggregate constituent realm, without eyes, being reborn in the sensual-sphere of existence, for them there the ear sense base will arise, but the eye sense base does not arise for them there. For those with eyes being reborn, for them there both the ear sense base will arise and the eye sense base arises.

For whom and where the eye sense base arises, will the nose sense base arise for that one there?

For those in their last existence being reborn in the sensual-sphere of existence, and for those being reborn in the fine-material-sphere, for them there the eye sense base arises, but the nose sense base will not arise for them there. For the others with eyes being reborn in the sensual-sphere of existence, for them there both the eye sense base arises and the nose sense base will arise.

Or else, for whom and where the nose sense base will arise, does the eye sense base arise for that one there?

For those passing away from the sensual-sphere of existence, without eyes, being reborn in the sensual-sphere of existence, for them there the nose sense base will arise, but the eye sense base does not arise for them there. For those with eyes being reborn in the sensual-sphere of existence, for them there both the nose sense base will arise and the eye sense base arises.

For whom and where the eye sense base arises, will the visible form sense base arise for that one there?

For those in their last existence being reborn in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them there the eye sense base arises, but the visible form sense base will not arise for them there. For the others with eyes being reborn, for them there both the eye sense base arises and the visible form sense base will arise.

Or else, for whom and where the visible form sense base will arise, does the eye sense base arise for that one there?

For those passing away from the five-aggregate constituent realm, without eyes, being reborn in the sensual-sphere of existence, and for non-percipient beings, for them there the visible form sense base will arise, but the eye sense base does not arise for them there. For those with eyes being reborn, for them there both the visible form sense base will arise and the eye sense base arises.

For whom and where the eye sense base arises, will the mind sense base arise for that one there?

For those in their last existence being reborn in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them there the eye sense base arises, but the mind sense base will not arise for them there. For the others with eyes being reborn, for them there both the eye sense base arises and the mind sense base will arise.

Or else, for whom and where the mind sense base will arise, does the eye sense base arise for that one there?

For those passing away from the five-aggregate constituent realm, without eyes, being reborn in the sensual-sphere of existence, and for immaterial beings, for them there the mind sense base will arise, but the eye sense base does not arise for them there. For those with eyes being reborn, for them there both the mind sense base will arise and the eye sense base arises.

For whom and where the eye sense base arises, will the mind-object sense base arise for that one there?

For those in their last existence being reborn in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them there the eye sense base arises, but the mind-object sense base will not arise for them there. For the others with eyes being reborn, for them there both the eye sense base arises and the mind-object sense base will arise.

Or else, for whom and where the mind-object sense base will arise, does the eye sense base arise for that one there?

For all those passing away, and for those without eyes being reborn, for them there the mind-object sense base will arise, but the eye sense base does not arise for them there. For those with eyes being reborn, for them there both the mind-object sense base will arise and the eye sense base arises. (Eye Sense Base as Root)

92. For whom and where the nose sense base arises, will the visible form sense base arise for that one there?

For those in their last existence being reborn in the sensual-sphere of existence, for them there the nose sense base arises, but the visible form sense base will not arise for them there. For the others with nose being reborn, for them there both the nose sense base arises and the visible form sense base will arise.

Or else, for whom and where the visible form sense base will arise, does the nose sense base arise for that one there?

For those passing away from the sensual-sphere of existence, without nose, being reborn in the sensual-sphere of existence, and for fine-material-sphere beings, for them there the visible form sense base will arise, but the nose sense base does not arise for them there. For those with nose being reborn, for them there both the visible form sense base will arise and the nose sense base arises.

For whom and where the nose sense base arises, will the mind sense base arise for that one there?

For those in their last existence being reborn in the sensual-sphere of existence, for them there the nose sense base arises, but the mind sense base will not arise for them there. For the others with nose being reborn, for them there both the nose sense base arises and the mind sense base will arise.

Or else, for whom and where the mind sense base will arise, does the nose sense base arise for that one there?

For those passing away from the sensual-sphere of existence, without nose, being reborn in the sensual-sphere of existence, and for fine-material-sphere and immaterial-sphere beings, for them there the mind sense base will arise, but the nose sense base does not arise for them there. For those with nose being reborn, for them there both the mind sense base will arise and the nose sense base arises.

For whom and where the nose sense base arises, will the mind-object sense base arise for that one there?

For those in their last existence being reborn in the sensual-sphere of existence, for them there the nose sense base arises, but the mind-object sense base will not arise for them there. For the others with nose being reborn, for them there both the nose sense base arises and the mind-object sense base will arise.

Or else, for whom and where the mind-object sense base will arise, does the nose sense base arise for that one there?

For all those passing away, and for those without nose being reborn, for them there the mind-object sense base will arise, but the nose sense base does not arise for them there. For those with nose being reborn, for them there both the mind-object sense base will arise and the nose sense base arises. (Nose Sense Base as Root)

93. For whom and where the visible form sense base arises, will the mind sense base arise for that one there?

For those in their last existence being reborn in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for those being reborn in the non-percipient being realm, for them there the visible form sense base arises, but the mind sense base will not arise for them there. For the others being reborn in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them there both the visible form sense base arises and the mind sense base will arise.

Or else, for whom and where the mind sense base will arise, does the visible form sense base arise for that one there?

For those passing away from the five-aggregate constituent realm to the immaterial realm, for them there the mind sense base will arise, but the visible form sense base does not arise for them there. For those being reborn in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them there both the mind sense base will arise and the visible form sense base arises.

For whom and where the visible form sense base arises, will the mind-object sense base arise for that one there?

For those in their last existence being reborn in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them there the visible form sense base arises, but the mind-object sense base will not arise for them there. For the others with material form being reborn, for them there both the visible form sense base arises and the mind-object sense base will arise.

Or else, for whom and where the mind-object sense base will arise, does the visible form sense base arise for that one there?

For all those passing away, and for immaterial beings being reborn, for them there the mind-object sense base will arise, but the visible form sense base does not arise for them there. For those with material form being reborn, for them there both the mind-object sense base will arise and the visible form sense base arises. (Visible Form Sense Base as Root)

94. For whom and where the mind sense base arises, will the mind-object sense base arise for that one there?

For those in their last existence being reborn, for them there the mind sense base arises, but the mind-object sense base will not arise for them there. For the others with consciousness being reborn, for them there both the mind sense base arises and the mind-object sense base will arise.

Or else, for whom and where the mind-object sense base will arise, does the mind sense base arise for that one there?

For all those passing away, and for those without consciousness being reborn, for them there the mind-object sense base will arise, but the mind sense base does not arise for them there. For those with consciousness being reborn, for them there both the mind-object sense base will arise and the mind sense base arises. (Mind Sense Base as Root)

Negative Person

95. For whom the eye sense base does not arise, will the ear sense base not arise for that one?

For all those passing away, for those without eyes being reborn, for them the eye sense base does not arise, but the ear sense base will not fail to arise for them. For those attaining final nibbāna in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for those in their last existence in the immaterial-sphere of existence, and for those who, having been reborn in the immaterial realm, will attain final nibbāna, for them passing away, for them both the eye sense base does not arise and the ear sense base will not arise.

Or else, for whom the ear sense base will not arise, does the eye sense base not arise for that one?

For those in their last existence being reborn in the five-aggregate constituent realm, and for those who, having been reborn in the immaterial realm, will attain final nibbāna, for them being reborn, for them the ear sense base will not arise, but the eye sense base does arise for them. For those attaining final nibbāna in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for those in their last existence in the immaterial-sphere of existence, and for those who, having been reborn in the immaterial realm, will attain final nibbāna, for them passing away, for them both the ear sense base will not arise and the eye sense base does not arise.

For whom the eye sense base does not arise, will the nose sense base not arise for that one?

For all those passing away, for those without eyes being reborn, for them the eye sense base does not arise, but the nose sense base will not fail to arise for them. For those attaining final nibbāna in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for those in their last existence in the immaterial-sphere of existence, and for those who, having been reborn in the fine-material-sphere and immaterial-sphere of existence, will attain final nibbāna, for them passing away, for them both the eye sense base does not arise and the nose sense base will not arise.

Or else, for whom the nose sense base will not arise, does the eye sense base not arise for that one?

For those in their last existence being reborn in the five-aggregate constituent realm, and for those who, having been reborn in the fine-material-sphere and immaterial-sphere of existence, will attain final nibbāna, for them being reborn, for them the nose sense base will not arise, but the eye sense base does arise for them. For those attaining final nibbāna in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for those in their last existence in the immaterial-sphere of existence, and for those who, having been reborn in the fine-material-sphere and immaterial-sphere of existence, will attain final nibbāna, for them passing away, for them both the nose sense base will not arise and the eye sense base does not arise.

For whom the eye sense base does not arise, will the visible form sense base not arise for that one?

For all those passing away, for those without eyes being reborn, for them the eye sense base does not arise, but the visible form sense base will not fail to arise for them. For those attaining final nibbāna in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for those in their last existence in the immaterial-sphere of existence, and for those who, having been reborn in the immaterial realm, will attain final nibbāna, for them passing away, for them both the eye sense base does not arise and the visible form sense base will not arise.

Or else, for whom the visible form sense base will not arise, does the eye sense base not arise for that one?

For those in their last existence being reborn in the five-aggregate constituent realm, and for those who, having been reborn in the immaterial realm, will attain final nibbāna, for them being reborn, for them the visible form sense base will not arise, but the eye sense base does arise for them. For those attaining final nibbāna in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for those in their last existence in the immaterial-sphere of existence, and for those who, having been reborn in the immaterial realm, will attain final nibbāna, for them passing away, for them both the visible form sense base will not arise and the eye sense base does not arise.

For whom the eye sense base does not arise, will the mind sense base not arise for that one?

For all those passing away, for those without eyes being reborn, for them the eye sense base does not arise, but the mind sense base will not fail to arise for them. For those attaining final nibbāna in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for those in their last existence in the immaterial-sphere of existence, for them both the eye sense base does not arise and the mind sense base will not arise.

Or else, for whom the mind sense base will not arise, does the eye sense base not arise for that one?

For those in their last existence being reborn in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them the mind sense base will not arise, but the eye sense base does arise for them. For those attaining final nibbāna in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for those in their last existence in the immaterial-sphere of existence, for them both the mind sense base will not arise and the eye sense base does not arise.

For whom the eye sense base does not arise, will the mind-object sense base not arise for that one?

For all those passing away, for those without eyes being reborn, for them the eye sense base does not arise, but the mind-object sense base will not fail to arise for them. For those attaining final nibbāna in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for those in their last existence in the immaterial-sphere of existence, for them both the eye sense base does not arise and the mind-object sense base will not arise.

Or else, for whom the mind-object sense base will not arise, does the eye sense base not arise for that one?

For those in their last existence being reborn in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them the mind-object sense base will not arise, but the eye sense base does arise for them. For those attaining final nibbāna in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for those in their last existence in the immaterial-sphere of existence, for them both the mind-object sense base will not arise and the eye sense base does not arise. (Eye Sense Base as Root)

96. For whom the nose sense base does not arise, will the visible form sense base not arise for that one?

For all those passing away, and for those without nose being reborn, for them the nose sense base does not arise, but the visible form sense base will arise for them. For those attaining final nibbāna in the sensual-sphere of existence, for those in their last existence in the fine-material-sphere and immaterial-sphere of existence, and for those who, having been reborn in the immaterial realm, will attain final nibbāna, for them passing away, for them both the nose sense base does not arise and the visible form sense base will not arise.

Or else, for whom the visible form sense base will not arise, does the nose sense base not arise for that one?

For those in their last existence being reborn in the sensual-sphere of existence, and for those who, having been reborn in the immaterial realm, will attain final nibbāna, for them being reborn, for them the visible form sense base will not arise, but the nose sense base does arise for them. For those attaining final nibbāna in the sensual-sphere of existence, for those in their last existence in the fine-material-sphere and immaterial-sphere of existence, and for those who, having been reborn in the immaterial realm, will attain final nibbāna, for them passing away, for them both the visible form sense base will not arise and the nose sense base does not arise.

For whom the nose sense base does not arise, the mind sense base... etc. will the mind-object sense base not arise?

For all those passing away, and for those without nose being reborn, for them the nose sense base does not arise, but the mind-object sense base will arise for them. For those attaining final nibbāna in the sensual-sphere of existence, for those in their last existence in the fine-material-sphere and immaterial-sphere of existence, for them both the nose sense base does not arise and the mind-object sense base will not arise.

Or else, for whom the mind-object sense base will not arise, does the nose sense base not arise for that one?

For those in their last existence being reborn in the sensual-sphere of existence, for them the mind-object sense base will not arise, but the nose sense base does arise for them. For those attaining final nibbāna in the sensual-sphere of existence, for those in their last existence in the fine-material-sphere and immaterial-sphere of existence, for them both the mind-object sense base will not arise and the nose sense base does not arise. (Nose Sense Base as Root)

97. For whom the visible form sense base does not arise, does the mind sense base... etc. will the mind-object sense base not arise?

For all those passing away, for immaterial beings being reborn, for them the visible form sense base does not arise, but the mind-object sense base will arise for them. For those attaining final nibbāna in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for those in their last existence in the immaterial-sphere of existence, for them both the visible form sense base does not arise and the mind-object sense base will not arise.

Or else, for whom the mind-object sense base will not arise, does the visible form sense base not arise for that one?

For those in their last existence being reborn in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them the mind-object sense base will not arise, but the visible form sense base does arise for them. For those attaining final nibbāna in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for those in their last existence in the immaterial-sphere of existence, for them both the mind-object sense base will not arise and the visible form sense base does not arise. (Visible Form Sense Base as Root)

98. For whom the mind sense base does not arise, will the mind-object sense base not arise for that one?

For all those passing away, for those without consciousness being reborn, for them the mind sense base does not arise, but the mind-object sense base will arise for them. For those attaining final nibbāna, for them both the mind sense base does not arise and the mind-object sense base will not arise.

Or else, for whom the mind-object sense base will not arise, does the mind sense base not arise for that one?

For those in their last existence being reborn, for them the mind-object sense base will not arise, but the mind sense base does arise for them. For those attaining final nibbāna, for them both the mind-object sense base will not arise and the mind sense base does not arise. (Mind Sense Base as Root)

The Negative Section on Place

99. Where the eye sense base does not arise, etc.

Negative - Person - Place

100. For whom and where the eye sense base does not arise, will the ear sense base not arise for that one there?

For those passing away from the five-aggregate constituent realm, without eyes, being reborn in the sensual-sphere of existence, for them there the eye sense base does not arise, but the ear sense base will not fail to arise for them there. For those attaining final nibbana in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for non-percipient beings, and for immaterial beings, for them there both the eye sense base does not arise and the ear sense base will not arise.

Or else, for whom and where the ear sense base will not arise, does the eye sense base not arise for that one there?

For those in their last existence being reborn in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them there the ear sense base will not arise, but the eye sense base does not fail to arise for them there. For those attaining final nibbana in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for non-percipient beings, and for immaterial beings, for them there both the ear sense base will not arise and the eye sense base does not arise.

For whom and where the eye sense base does not arise, will the nose sense base not arise for that one there?

For those passing away from the sensual-sphere of existence, without eyes, being reborn in the sensual-sphere of existence, for them there the eye sense base does not arise, but the nose sense base will not fail to arise for them there. For those attaining final nibbana in the sensual-sphere of existence, for those passing away from the fine-material-sphere, for non-percipient beings, and for immaterial beings, for them there both the eye sense base does not arise and the nose sense base will not arise.

Or else, for whom and where the nose sense base will not arise, does the eye sense base not arise for that one there?

For those in their last existence being reborn in the sensual-sphere of existence, and for those being reborn in the fine-material-sphere, for them there the nose sense base will not arise, but the eye sense base does not fail to arise for them there. For those attaining final nibbana in the sensual-sphere of existence, for those passing away from the fine-material-sphere, for non-percipient beings, and for immaterial beings, for them there both the nose sense base will not arise and the eye sense base does not arise.

For whom and where the eye sense base does not arise, will the visible form sense base not arise for that one there?

For those passing away from the five-aggregate constituent realm, without eyes, being reborn in the sensual-sphere of existence, and for non-percipient beings, for them there the eye sense base does not arise, but the visible form sense base will not fail to arise for them there. For those attaining final nibbana in the five-aggregate constituent realm and for immaterial beings, for them there both the eye sense base does not arise and the visible form sense base will not arise.

Or else, for whom and where the visible form sense base will not arise, does the eye sense base not arise for that one there?

For those in their last existence being reborn in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them there the visible form sense base will not arise, but the eye sense base does not fail to arise for them there. For those attaining final nibbana in the five-aggregate constituent realm and for immaterial beings, for them there both the visible form sense base will not arise and the eye sense base does not arise.

For whom and where the eye sense base does not arise, will the mind sense base not arise for that one there?

For those passing away from the five-aggregate constituent realm, without eyes, being reborn in the sensual-sphere of existence, and for immaterial beings, for them there the eye sense base does not arise, but the mind sense base will not fail to arise for them there. For those attaining final nibbana in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for those in their last existence in the immaterial-sphere of existence, and for non-percipient beings, for them there both the eye sense base does not arise and the mind sense base will not arise.

Or else, for whom and where the mind sense base will not arise, does the eye sense base not arise for that one there?

For those in their last existence being reborn in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them there the mind sense base will not arise, but the eye sense base does not fail to arise for them there. For those attaining final nibbana in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for those in their last existence in the immaterial-sphere of existence, and for non-percipient beings, for them there the mind sense base will not arise and the eye sense base does not arise.

For whom and where the eye sense base does not arise, will the mind-object sense base not arise for that one there?

For all those passing away, and for those without eyes being reborn, for them there the eye sense base does not arise, but the mind-object sense base will not fail to arise for them there. For those attaining final nibbana in the five-aggregate constituent realm and for those in their last existence in the immaterial-sphere of existence, for them there both the eye sense base does not arise and the mind-object sense base will not arise.

Or else, for whom and where the mind-object sense base will not arise, does the eye sense base not arise for that one there?

For those in their last existence being reborn in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them there the mind-object sense base will not arise, but the eye sense base does not fail to arise for them there. For those attaining final nibbana in the five-aggregate constituent realm and for those in their last existence in the immaterial-sphere of existence, for them there both the mind-object sense base will not arise and the eye sense base does not arise. (Eye Sense Base as Root)

101. For whom and where the nose sense base does not arise, will the visible form sense base not arise for that one there?

For those passing away from the sensual-sphere of existence, without nose, being reborn in the sensual-sphere of existence, and for fine-material-sphere beings, for them there the nose sense base does not arise, but the visible form sense base will arise for them there. For those attaining final nibbāna in the sensual-sphere of existence, for those in their last existence in the fine-material-sphere, and for immaterial beings, for them there both the nose sense base does not arise and the visible form sense base will not arise.

Or else, for whom and where the visible form sense base will not arise, does the nose sense base not arise for that one there?

For those in their last existence being reborn in the sensual-sphere of existence, for them there the visible form sense base will not arise, but the nose sense base does arise for them there. For those attaining final nibbāna in the sensual-sphere of existence, for those in their last existence in the fine-material-sphere, and for immaterial beings, for them there both the visible form sense base will not arise and the nose sense base does not arise.

For whom and where the nose sense base does not arise, will the mind sense base not arise for that one there?

For those passing away from the sensual-sphere of existence, without nose, being reborn in the sensual-sphere of existence, and for fine-material-sphere and immaterial-sphere beings, for them there the nose sense base does not arise, but the mind sense base will arise for them there. For those attaining final nibbāna in the sensual-sphere of existence, for those in their last existence in the fine-material-sphere and immaterial-sphere of existence, and for non-percipient beings, for them there both the nose sense base does not arise and the mind sense base will not arise.

Or else, for whom and where the mind sense base will not arise, does the nose sense base not arise for that one there?

For those in their last existence being reborn in the sensual-sphere of existence, for them there the mind sense base will not arise, but the nose sense base does arise for them there. For those attaining final nibbāna in the sensual-sphere of existence, for those in their last existence in the fine-material-sphere and immaterial-sphere of existence, and for non-percipient beings, for them there both the mind sense base will not arise and the nose sense base does not arise.

For whom and where the nose sense base does not arise, will the mind-object sense base not arise for that one there?

For all those passing away, and for those without nose being reborn, for them there the nose sense base does not arise, but the mind-object sense base will arise for them there. For those attaining final nibbāna in the sensual-sphere of existence, for those in their last existence in the fine-material-sphere and immaterial-sphere of existence, for them there both the nose sense base does not arise and the mind-object sense base will not arise.

Or else, for whom and where the mind-object sense base will not arise, does the nose sense base not arise for that one there?

For those in their last existence being reborn in the sensual-sphere of existence, for them there the mind-object sense base will not arise, but the nose sense base does arise for them there. For those attaining final nibbāna in the sensual-sphere of existence, for those in their last existence in the fine-material-sphere and immaterial-sphere of existence, for them there both the mind-object sense base will not arise and the nose sense base does not arise. (Nose Sense Base as Root)

102. For whom and where the visible form sense base does not arise, will the mind sense base not arise for that one there?

For those passing away from the five-aggregate constituent realm to the immaterial realm, for them there the visible form sense base does not arise, but the mind sense base will arise for them there. For those attaining final nibbāna in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for those in their last existence in the immaterial-sphere of existence, for those passing away from the non-percipient being realm, for them there both the visible form sense base does not arise and the mind sense base will not arise.

Or else, for whom and where the mind sense base will not arise, does the visible form sense base not arise for that one there?

For those in their last existence being reborn in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for those being reborn in the non-percipient being realm, for them there the mind sense base will not arise, but the visible form sense base does arise for them there. For those attaining final nibbāna in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for those in their last existence in the immaterial-sphere of existence, for those passing away from the non-percipient being realm, for them there both the mind sense base will not arise and the visible form sense base does not arise.

For whom and where the visible form sense base does not arise, will the mind-object sense base not arise for that one there?

For all those passing away, and for immaterial beings being reborn, for them there the visible form sense base does not arise, but the mind-object sense base will arise for them there. For those attaining final nibbāna in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for those in their last existence in the immaterial-sphere of existence, for them there both the visible form sense base does not arise and the mind-object sense base will not arise.

Or else, for whom and where the mind-object sense base will not arise, does the visible form sense base not arise for that one there?

For those in their last existence being reborn in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them there the mind-object sense base will not arise, but the visible form sense base does arise for them there. For those attaining final nibbāna in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for those in their last existence in the immaterial-sphere of existence, for them there both the mind-object sense base will not arise and the visible form sense base does not arise. (Visible Form Sense Base as Root)

103. For whom and where the mind sense base does not arise, will the mind-object sense base not arise for that one there?

For all those passing away, for those without consciousness being reborn, for them there the mind sense base does not arise, but the mind-object sense base will not fail to arise for them there. For those attaining final nibbana, for them there both the mind sense base does not arise and the mind-object sense base will not arise.

Or else, for whom and where the mind-object sense base will not arise, does the mind sense base not arise for that one there?

For those in their last existence being reborn, for them there the mind-object sense base will not arise, but the mind sense base does not fail to arise for them there. For those attaining final nibbana, for them there both the mind-object sense base will not arise and the mind sense base does not arise. (Mind Sense Base as Root)

(6) The Section on Past and Future

Conformity Person

104. For whom the eye sense base arose, will the ear sense base arise for that one?

For those in their last existence and for those who, having been reborn in the immaterial realm, will attain final nibbāna, for them the eye sense base arose, but the ear sense base will not arise for them. For the others, for them both the eye sense base arose and the ear sense base will arise.

Or else, for whom the ear sense base will arise, did the eye sense base arise for that one? Yes.

For whom the eye sense base arose, will the nose sense base arise for that one?

For those in their last existence and for those who, having been reborn in the fine-material-sphere and immaterial-sphere of existence, will attain final nibbāna, for them the eye sense base arose, but the nose sense base will not arise for them. For the others, for them both the eye sense base arose and the nose sense base will arise.

Or else, etc. did it arise? Yes.

For whom the eye sense base arose, will the visible form sense base arise for that one?

For those in their last existence and for those who, having been reborn in the immaterial realm, will attain final nibbāna, for them the eye sense base arose, but the visible form sense base will not arise for them. For the others, for them both the eye sense base arose and the visible form sense base will arise.

Or else, etc. did it arise? Yes.

For whom the eye sense base arose, the mind sense base... etc. the mind-object sense base arise for that one?

For those in their last existence, for them the eye sense base arose, but the mind-object sense base will not arise for them. For the others, for them both the eye sense base arose and the mind-object sense base will arise. Or else, etc. did it arise? Yes. (Eye Sense Base as Root)

105. For whom the nose sense base arose, will the visible form sense base arise for that one?

For those in their last existence and for those who, having been reborn in the immaterial realm, will attain final nibbāna, for them the nose sense base arose, but the visible form sense base will not arise for them. For the others, for them both the nose sense base arose and the visible form sense base will arise.

Or else, etc. did it arise? Yes.

For whom the nose sense base arose, the mind sense base... etc. the mind-object sense base arise for that one?

For those in their last existence, for them the nose sense base arose, but the mind-object sense base will not arise for them. For the others, for them both the nose sense base arose and the mind-object sense base will arise.

Or else, the mind-object sense base... etc. did it arise? Yes.

106. For whom the visible form sense base arose, the mind sense base... etc. the mind-object sense base arise for that one?

For those in their last existence, for them the visible form sense base arose, but the mind-object sense base will not arise for them. For the others, for them both the visible form sense base arose and the mind-object sense base will arise.

Or else, etc. did it arise? Yes.

107. For whom the mind sense base arose, will the mind-object sense base arise for that one?

For those in their last existence, for them the mind sense base arose, but the mind-object sense base will not arise for them. For the others, for them both the mind sense base arose and the mind-object sense base will arise.

Or else, for whom the mind-object sense base will arise, did the mind sense base arise for that one? Yes.

Conformity Place

108. Where the eye sense base arose... etc.

Conformity - Person - Place

109. For whom and where the eye sense base arose, will the ear sense base arise for that one there?

For beings in their last existence in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them there the eye sense base arose, but the ear sense base will not arise for them there. For the other five-aggregate constituent beings, for them there both the eye sense base arose and the ear sense base will arise.

Or else, for whom and where the ear sense base will arise, did the eye sense base arise for that one there? Yes.

For whom and where the eye sense base arose, will the nose sense base arise for that one there?

For beings in their last existence in the sensual-sphere of existence and for fine-material-sphere beings, for them there the eye sense base arose, but the nose sense base will not arise for them there. For the other sensual-sphere beings, for them there both the eye sense base arose and the nose sense base will arise.

Or else, for whom and where etc. did it arise? Yes.

For whom and where the eye sense base arose, will the visible form sense base arise for that one there?

For beings in their last existence in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them there the eye sense base arose, but the visible form sense base will not arise for them there. For the other five-aggregate constituent beings, for them there both the eye sense base arose and the visible form sense base will arise.

Or else, for whom and where the visible form sense base will arise, did the eye sense base arise for that one there?

For non-percipient beings, for them there the visible form sense base will arise, but the eye sense base did not arise for them there. For five-aggregate constituent beings, for them there both the visible form sense base will arise and the eye sense base arose.

For whom and where the eye sense base arose, will the mind sense base arise for that one there?

For beings in their last existence in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them there the eye sense base arose, but the mind sense base will not arise for them there. For the other five-aggregate constituent beings, for them there both the eye sense base arose and the mind sense base will arise.

Or else, for whom and where the mind sense base will arise, did the eye sense base arise for that one there?

For immaterial beings, for them there the mind sense base will arise, but the eye sense base did not arise for them there. For five-aggregate constituent beings, for them there both the mind sense base will arise and the eye sense base arose.

For whom and where the eye sense base arose, will the mind-object sense base arise for that one there?

For beings in their last existence in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them there the eye sense base arose, but the mind-object sense base will not arise for them there. For the other five-aggregate constituent beings, for them there both the eye sense base arose and the mind-object sense base will arise.

Or else, for whom and where the mind-object sense base will arise, did the eye sense base arise for that one there?

For non-percipient beings and immaterial beings, for them there the mind-object sense base will arise, but the eye sense base did not arise for them there. For five-aggregate constituent beings, for them there both the mind-object sense base will arise and the eye sense base arose. (Eye Sense Base as Root)

110. For whom and where the nose sense base arose, will the visible form sense base arise for that one there?

For beings in their last existence in the sensual-sphere of existence, for them there the nose sense base arose, but the visible form sense base will not arise for them there. For the other sensual-sphere beings, for them there both the nose sense base arose and the visible form sense base will arise.

Or else, for whom and where the visible form sense base will arise, did the nose sense base arise for that one there?

For fine-material-sphere beings, for them there the visible form sense base will arise, but the nose sense base did not arise for them there. For sensual-sphere beings, for them there both the visible form sense base will arise and the nose sense base arose.

For whom and where the nose sense base arose, for that one there the mind sense base... etc. the mind-object sense base arise for that one?

For beings in their last existence in the sensual-sphere of existence, for them there the nose sense base arose, but the mind-object sense base will not arise for them there. For the other sensual-sphere beings, for them there both the nose sense base arose and the mind-object sense base will arise.

Or else, for whom and where the mind-object sense base will arise, did the nose sense base arise for that one there?

For fine-material-sphere and immaterial-sphere beings, for them there the mind-object sense base will arise, but the nose sense base did not arise for them there. For sensual-sphere beings, for them there both the mind-object sense base will arise and the nose sense base arose. (Nose Sense Base as Root)

111. For whom and where the visible form sense base arose, will the mind sense base arise for that one there?

For beings in their last existence among non-percipient beings in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them there the visible form sense base arose, but the mind sense base will not arise for them there. For the other five-aggregate constituent beings, for them there both the visible form sense base arose and the mind sense base will arise.

Or else, for whom and where the mind sense base will arise, did the visible form sense base arise for that one there?

For immaterial beings, for them there the mind sense base will arise, but the visible form sense base did not arise for them there. For five-aggregate constituent beings, for them there both the mind sense base will arise and the visible form sense base arose.

For whom and where the visible form sense base arose, will the mind-object sense base arise for that one there?

For beings in their last existence in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them there the visible form sense base arose, but the mind-object sense base will not arise for them there. For the other five-aggregate constituent beings and non-percipient beings, for them there both the visible form sense base arose and the mind-object sense base will arise.

Or else, for whom and where the mind-object sense base will arise, did the visible form sense base arise for that one there?

For immaterial beings, for them there the mind-object sense base will arise, but the visible form sense base did not arise for them there. For five-aggregate constituent beings and non-percipient beings, for them there both the mind-object sense base will arise and the visible form sense base arose. (Visible Form Sense Base as Root)

112. For whom and where the mind sense base arose, will the mind-object sense base arise for that one there?

For those in their last existence, for them there the mind sense base arose, but the mind-object sense base will not arise for them there. For the others, the four-aggregate constituent beings and the five-aggregate constituent beings, for them there both the mind sense base arose and the mind-object sense base will arise.

Or else, for whom and where the mind-object sense base will arise, did the mind sense base arise for that one there?

For non-percipient beings, for them there the mind-object sense base will arise, but the mind sense base did not arise for them there. For four-aggregate constituent beings and five-aggregate constituent beings, for them there both the mind-object sense base will arise and the mind sense base arose. (Mind Sense Base as Root)

Negative Person

113. For whom the eye sense base had not arisen, will the ear sense base not arise for that one? There is not.

Or else, for whom the ear sense base will not arise, had the eye sense base not arisen for that one? It had arisen.

For whom the eye sense base had not arisen, the nose sense base... etc. the visible form sense base... the mind sense base... will the mind-object sense base not arise? There is not.

Or else, for whom the mind-object sense base will not arise, had the eye sense base not arisen for that one? It had arisen.

114. For whom the nose sense base... etc. the visible form sense base... For whom the mind sense base had not arisen, will the mind-object sense base not arise for that one? There is not. Or else, for whom the mind-object sense base will not arise, had the mind sense base not arisen for that one? It had arisen.

The Negative Section on Place

115. Where the eye sense base had not arisen... etc.

Negative - Person - Place

116. For whom and where the eye sense base had not arisen, will the ear sense base not arise for that one there? Yes.

Or else, for whom and where the ear sense base will not arise, had the eye sense base not arisen for that one there?

For beings in their last existence in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them there the ear sense base will not arise, but the eye sense base had not not arisen for them there. For those in the Pure Abodes, for non-percipient beings, and for immaterial beings, for them there both the ear sense base will not arise and the eye sense base had not arisen.

For whom and where the eye sense base had not arisen, will the nose sense base not arise for that one there? Yes.

Or else, for whom and where the nose sense base will not arise, had the eye sense base not arisen for that one there?

For beings in their last existence in the sensual-sphere of existence and for fine-material-sphere beings, for them there the nose sense base will not arise, but the eye sense base had not not arisen for them there. For those in the Pure Abodes, for non-percipient beings, and for immaterial beings, for them there both the nose sense base will not arise and the eye sense base had not arisen.

For whom and where the eye sense base had not arisen, will the visible form sense base not arise for that one there?

For non-percipient beings, for them there the eye sense base had not arisen, but the visible form sense base will not not arise for them there. For those in the Pure Abodes and for immaterial beings, for them there both the eye sense base had not arisen and the visible form sense base will not arise.

Or else, for whom and where the visible form sense base will not arise, had the eye sense base not arisen for that one there?

For beings in their last existence in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them there the visible form sense base will not arise, but the eye sense base had not not arisen for them there. For those in the Pure Abodes and for immaterial beings, for them there both the visible form sense base will not arise and the eye sense base had not arisen.

For whom and where the eye sense base had not arisen, will the mind sense base not arise for that one there?

For immaterial beings, for them there the eye sense base had not arisen, but the mind sense base will not not arise for them there. For those in the Pure Abodes, for those in their last existence in the immaterial-sphere of existence, and for non-percipient beings, for them there both the eye sense base had not arisen and the mind sense base will not arise.

Or else, for whom and where the mind sense base will not arise, had the eye sense base not arisen for that one there?

For beings in their last existence in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them there the mind sense base will not arise, but the eye sense base had not not arisen for them there. For those in the Pure Abodes, for those in their last existence in the immaterial-sphere of existence, and for non-percipient beings, for them there both the mind sense base will not arise and the eye sense base had not arisen.

For whom and where the eye sense base had not arisen, will the mind-object sense base not arise for that one there?

For non-percipient beings and for immaterial beings, for them there the eye sense base had not arisen, but the mind-object sense base will not not arise for them there. For those in the Pure Abodes and for those in their last existence in the immaterial-sphere of existence, for them there both the eye sense base had not arisen and the mind-object sense base will not arise.

Or else, for whom and where the mind-object sense base will not arise, had the eye sense base not arisen for that one there?

For beings in their last existence in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them there the mind-object sense base will not arise, but the eye sense base had not not arisen for them there. For those in the Pure Abodes and for those in their last existence in the immaterial-sphere of existence, for them there both the mind-object sense base will not arise and the eye sense base had not arisen. (Eye Sense Base as Root)

117. For whom and where the nose sense base had not arisen, will the visible form sense base not arise for that one there?

For fine-material-sphere beings, for them there the nose sense base had not arisen, but the visible form sense base will not fail to arise for them there. For those in their last existence in the fine-material-sphere and for immaterial beings, for them there both the nose sense base had not arisen and the visible form sense base will not arise.

Or else, for whom and where the visible form sense base will not arise, had the nose sense base not arisen for that one there?

For those in their last existence in the sensual-sphere of existence, for them there the visible form sense base will not arise, but the nose sense base had not not arisen for them there. For those in their last existence in the fine-material-sphere and for immaterial beings, for them there both the visible form sense base will not arise and the nose sense base had not arisen.

For whom and where the nose sense base had not arisen, will the mind sense base not arise for that one there?

For fine-material-sphere and immaterial-sphere beings, for them there the nose sense base had not arisen, but the mind sense base will not fail to arise for them there. For those in their last existence in the fine-material-sphere and immaterial-sphere of existence, and for non-percipient beings, for them there both the nose sense base had not arisen and the mind sense base will not arise.

Or else, for whom and where the mind sense base will not arise, had the nose sense base not arisen for that one there?

For those in their last existence in the sensual-sphere of existence, for them there the mind sense base will not arise, but the nose sense base had not not arisen for them there. For those in their last existence in the fine-material-sphere and immaterial-sphere of existence, and for non-percipient beings, for them there both the mind sense base will not arise and the nose sense base had not arisen.

For whom and where the nose sense base had not arisen, will the mind-object sense base not arise for that one there?

For fine-material-sphere and immaterial-sphere beings, for them there the nose sense base had not arisen, but the mind-object sense base will not fail to arise for them there. For those in their last existence in the fine-material-sphere and immaterial-sphere of existence, for them there both the nose sense base had not arisen and the mind-object sense base will not arise.

Or else, for whom and where the mind-object sense base will not arise, had the nose sense base not arisen for that one there?

For those in their last existence in the sensual-sphere of existence, for them there the mind-object sense base will not arise, but the nose sense base had not not arisen for them there. For those in their last existence in the fine-material-sphere and immaterial-sphere of existence, for them there both the mind-object sense base will not arise and the nose sense base had not arisen. (Nose Sense Base as Root)

118. For whom and where the visible form sense base had not arisen, will the mind sense base not arise for that one there?

For immaterial beings, for them there the visible form sense base had not arisen, but the mind sense base will not fail to arise for them there. For those in the Pure Abodes and for those in their last existence in the immaterial-sphere of existence, for them there both the visible form sense base had not arisen and the mind sense base will not arise.

Or else, for whom and where the mind sense base will not arise, had the visible form sense base not arisen for that one there?

For beings in their last existence in the five-aggregate constituent realm and for non-percipient beings, for them there the mind sense base will not arise, but the visible form sense base had not not arisen for them there. For those in the Pure Abodes and for those in their last existence in the immaterial-sphere of existence, for them there both the mind sense base will not arise and the visible form sense base had not arisen.

For whom and where the visible form sense base had not arisen, will the mind-object sense base not arise for that one there?

For immaterial beings, for them there the visible form sense base had not arisen, but the mind-object sense base will not fail to arise for them there. For those in the Pure Abodes and for those in their last existence in the immaterial-sphere of existence, for them there both the visible form sense base had not arisen and the mind-object sense base will not arise.

Or else, for whom and where the mind-object sense base will not arise, had the visible form sense base not arisen for that one there?

For beings in their last existence in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them there the mind-object sense base will not arise, but the visible form sense base had not not arisen for them there. For those in the Pure Abodes and for those in their last existence in the immaterial-sphere of existence, for them there both the mind-object sense base will not arise and the visible form sense base had not arisen. (Visible Form Sense Base as Root)

119. For whom and where the mind sense base had not arisen, will the mind-object sense base not arise for that one there?

For non-percipient beings, for them there the mind sense base had not arisen, but the mind-object sense base will not fail to arise for them there. For those in the Pure Abodes, for them there both the mind sense base had not arisen and the mind-object sense base will not arise.

Or else, for whom and where the mind-object sense base will not arise, had the mind sense base not arisen for that one there?

For beings in their last existence, for them there the mind-object sense base will not arise, but the mind sense base had not not arisen for them there. For those in the Pure Abodes, for them there both the mind-object sense base will not arise and the mind sense base had not arisen.

The Section on Arising.

2.

Occurrence 2.

The Section on Cessation

(1) The Section on the Present

Conformity Person

120. For whom the eye sense base ceases, does the ear sense base cease for that one?

For those with eyes but without ears passing away, for them the eye sense base ceases, but the ear sense base does not cease for them. For those with eyes and with ears passing away, for them both the eye sense base ceases and the ear sense base ceases.

Or else, for whom the ear sense base ceases, does the eye sense base cease for that one?

For those with ears but without eyes passing away, for them the ear sense base ceases, but the eye sense base does not cease for them. For those with ears and with eyes passing away, for them both the ear sense base ceases and the eye sense base ceases.

For whom the eye sense base ceases, does the nose sense base cease for that one?

For those with eyes but without nose passing away, for them the eye sense base ceases, but the nose sense base does not cease for them. For those with eyes and with nose passing away, for them both the eye sense base ceases and the nose sense base ceases.

Or else, for whom the nose sense base ceases, does the eye sense base cease for that one?

For those with nose but without eyes passing away, for them the nose sense base ceases, but the eye sense base does not cease for them. For those with nose and with eyes passing away, for them both the nose sense base ceases and the eye sense base ceases.

For whom the eye sense base ceases, does the visible form sense base cease for that one? Yes.

Or else, for whom the visible form sense base ceases, does the eye sense base cease for that one?

For those with material form but without eyes passing away, for them the visible form sense base ceases, but the eye sense base does not cease for them. For those with eyes passing away, for them both the visible form sense base ceases and the eye sense base ceases.

For whom the eye sense base ceases, does the mind sense base cease for that one? Yes.

Or else, for whom the mind sense base ceases, does the eye sense base cease for that one?

For those with consciousness but without eyes passing away, for them the mind sense base ceases, but the eye sense base does not cease for them. For those with eyes passing away, for them both the mind sense base ceases and the eye sense base ceases.

For whom the eye sense base ceases, does the mind-object sense base cease for that one? Yes.

Or else, for whom the mind-object sense base ceases, does the eye sense base cease for that one?

For those without eyes passing away, for them the mind-object sense base ceases, but the eye sense base does not cease for them. For those with eyes passing away, for them both the mind-object sense base ceases and the eye sense base ceases. (Eye Sense Base as Root)

121. For whom the nose sense base ceases, does the visible form sense base cease for that one? Yes.

Or else, for whom the visible form sense base ceases, does the nose sense base cease for that one?

For those with material form but without nose passing away, for them the visible form sense base ceases, but the nose sense base does not cease for them. For those with nose passing away, for them both the visible form sense base ceases and the nose sense base ceases.

For whom the nose sense base ceases, does the mind sense base cease for that one? Yes.

Or else, for whom the mind sense base ceases, does the nose sense base cease for that one?

For those with consciousness but without nose passing away, for them the mind sense base ceases, but the nose sense base does not cease for them. For those with nose passing away, for them both the mind sense base ceases and the nose sense base ceases.

For whom the nose sense base ceases, does the mind-object sense base cease for that one? Yes.

Or else, for whom the mind-object sense base ceases, does the nose sense base cease for that one?

For those without nose passing away, for them the mind-object sense base ceases, but the nose sense base does not cease for them. For those with nose passing away, for them both the mind-object sense base ceases and the nose sense base ceases. (Nose Sense Base as Root)

122. For whom the visible form sense base ceases, does the mind sense base cease for that one?

For those without consciousness passing away, for them the visible form sense base ceases, but the mind sense base does not cease for them. For those with material form and with consciousness passing away, for them both the visible form sense base ceases and the mind sense base ceases.

Or else, for whom the mind sense base ceases, does the visible form sense base cease for that one?

For immaterial beings passing away, for them the mind sense base ceases, but the visible form sense base does not cease for them. For those with material form and with consciousness passing away, for them both the mind sense base ceases and the visible form sense base ceases.

For whom the visible form sense base ceases, does the mind-object sense base cease for that one? Yes.

Or else, for whom the mind-object sense base ceases, does the visible form sense base cease for that one?

For immaterial beings passing away, for them the mind-object sense base ceases, but the visible form sense base does not cease for them. For those with material form passing away, for them both the mind-object sense base ceases and the visible form sense base ceases.

123. For whom the mind sense base ceases, does the mind-object sense base cease for that one? Yes.

Or else, for whom the mind-object sense base ceases, does the mind sense base cease for that one?

For those without consciousness passing away, for them the mind-object sense base ceases, but the mind sense base does not cease for them. For those with consciousness passing away, for them both the mind-object sense base ceases and the mind sense base ceases.

Conformity Place

124. Where the eye sense base ceases... etc. (In arising, in cessation, in arising-cessation, the 'where' section everywhere is similar).

Conformity - Person - Place

125. For whom and where the eye sense base ceases, does the ear sense base cease for that one there? Etc. the nose sense base... the visible form sense base... the mind sense base... does the mind-object sense base cease? (For whom and where, also similar, should be expanded).

Negative Person

126. For whom the eye sense base does not cease, does the ear sense base not cease for that one?

For those without eyes but with ears passing away, for them the eye sense base does not cease, but the ear sense base does cease for them. For all those being reborn, for those without eyes and without ears passing away, for them both the eye sense base does not cease and the ear sense base does not cease.

Or else, for whom the ear sense base does not cease, does the eye sense base not cease for that one?

For those without ears but with eyes passing away, for them the ear sense base does not cease, but the eye sense base does cease for them. For all those being reborn, for those without ears and without eyes passing away, for them both the ear sense base does not cease and the eye sense base does not cease.

For whom the eye sense base does not cease, does the nose sense base not cease for that one?

For those without eyes but with nose passing away, for them the eye sense base does not cease, but the nose sense base does cease for them. For all those being reborn, for those without eyes and without nose passing away, for them both the eye sense base does not cease and the nose sense base does not cease.

Or else, for whom the nose sense base does not cease, does the eye sense base not cease for that one?

For those without nose but with eyes passing away, for them the nose sense base does not cease, but the eye sense base does cease for them. For all those being reborn, for those without nose and without eyes passing away, for them both the nose sense base does not cease and the eye sense base does not cease.

For whom the eye sense base does not cease, does the visible form sense base not cease for that one?

For those without eyes but with material form passing away, for them the eye sense base does not cease, but the visible form sense base does cease for them. For all those being reborn, for immaterial beings passing away, for them both the eye sense base does not cease and the visible form sense base does not cease.

Or else, for whom the visible form sense base does not cease, does the eye sense base not cease for that one? Yes.

For whom the eye sense base does not cease, does the mind sense base not cease for that one?

For those without eyes but with consciousness passing away, for them the eye sense base does not cease, but the mind sense base does cease for them. For all those being reborn, for those without consciousness passing away, for them both the eye sense base does not cease and the mind sense base does not cease.

Or else, for whom the mind sense base does not cease, does the eye sense base not cease for that one? Yes.

For whom the eye sense base does not cease, does the mind-object sense base not cease for that one?

For those without eyes passing away, for them the eye sense base does not cease, but the mind-object sense base does cease for them. For all those being reborn, for them both the eye sense base does not cease and the mind-object sense base does not cease.

Or else, for whom the mind-object sense base does not cease, does the eye sense base not cease for that one? Yes. (Eye Sense Base as Root)

127. For whom the nose sense base does not cease, does the visible form sense base not cease for that one?

For those without nose but with material form passing away, for them the nose sense base does not cease, but the visible form sense base does cease for them. For all those being reborn, for immaterial beings passing away, for them both the nose sense base does not cease and the visible form sense base does not cease.

Or else, for whom the visible form sense base does not cease, does the nose sense base not cease for that one? Yes.

For whom the nose sense base does not cease, does the mind sense base not cease for that one?

For those without nose but with consciousness passing away, for them the nose sense base does not cease, but the mind sense base does cease for them. For all those being reborn, for those without consciousness passing away, for them both the nose sense base does not cease and the mind sense base does not cease.

Or else, for whom the mind sense base does not cease, does the nose sense base not cease for that one? Yes.

For whom the nose sense base does not cease, does the mind-object sense base not cease for that one?

For those without nose passing away, for them the nose sense base does not cease, but the mind-object sense base does cease for them. For all those being reborn, for them both the nose sense base does not cease and the mind-object sense base does not cease.

Or else, for whom the mind-object sense base does not cease, does the nose sense base not cease for that one? Yes. (Nose Sense Base as Root)

128. For whom the visible form sense base does not cease, does the mind sense base not cease for that one?

For immaterial beings passing away, for them the visible form sense base does not cease, but the mind sense base does cease for them. For all those being reborn, for them both the visible form sense base does not cease and the mind sense base does not cease.

Or else, for whom the mind sense base does not cease, does the visible form sense base not cease for that one?

For those without consciousness passing away, for them the mind sense base does not cease, but the visible form sense base does cease for them. For all those being reborn, for them both the mind sense base does not cease and the visible form sense base does not cease.

For whom the visible form sense base does not cease, does the mind-object sense base not cease for that one?

For immaterial beings passing away, for them the visible form sense base does not cease, but the mind-object sense base does cease for them. For all those being reborn, for them both the visible form sense base does not cease and the mind-object sense base does not cease.

Or else, for whom the mind-object sense base does not cease, does the visible form sense base not cease for that one? Yes. (Visible Form Sense Base as Root)

129. For whom the mind sense base does not cease, does the mind-object sense base not cease for that one?

For those without consciousness passing away, for them the mind sense base does not cease, but the mind-object sense base does cease for them. For all those being reborn, for them both the mind sense base does not cease and the mind-object sense base does not cease.

Or else, for whom the mind-object sense base does not cease, does the mind sense base not cease for that one? Yes.

The Negative Section on Place

130. Where the eye sense base does not cease, etc.

Negative - Person - Place

131. For whom and where the eye sense base does not cease, does the ear sense base not cease for that one there? Etc. (For whom and where, also similar to the 'for whom' section).

(2) The Section on the Past

Conformity Person

132. For whom the eye sense base had ceased, did the ear sense base cease for that one?

Yes. (In the arising section, in the cessation section, in the arising-cessation section, the past questions in conformity and in reverse are similar.)

(3) The Section on the Future

Conformity Person

133. For whom the eye sense base will cease, will the ear sense base cease for that one? Yes.

Or else, for whom the ear sense base will cease, will the eye sense base cease for that one? Yes.

For whom the eye sense base will cease, will the nose sense base cease for that one?

For those in their last existence being reborn in the fine-material-sphere, and for those who, having been reborn in the fine-material-sphere, will attain final nibbāna, for them passing away, for them the eye sense base will cease, but the nose sense base will not cease for them. For the others, for them both the eye sense base will cease and the nose sense base will cease.

Or else, for whom the nose sense base will cease, will the eye sense base cease for that one? Yes.

For whom the eye sense base will cease, will the visible form sense base cease for that one? Yes.

Or else, for whom the visible form sense base will cease, will the eye sense base cease for that one? Yes.

For whom the eye sense base will cease, will the mind sense base... etc. will the mind-object sense base cease? Yes.

Or else, for whom the mind-object sense base will cease, will the eye sense base cease for that one?

For those in their last existence being reborn in the immaterial realm, and for those who, having been reborn in the immaterial realm, will attain final nibbāna, for them passing away, for them the mind-object sense base will cease, but the eye sense base will not cease for them. For the others, for them both the mind-object sense base will cease and the eye sense base will cease. (Eye Sense Base as Root)

134. For whom the nose sense base will cease, will the visible form sense base cease for that one? Yes.

Or else, for whom the visible form sense base will cease, will the nose sense base cease for that one?

For those in their last existence being reborn in the fine-material-sphere, and for those who, having been reborn in the fine-material-sphere, will attain final nibbāna, for them passing away, for them the visible form sense base will cease, but the nose sense base will not cease for them. For the others, for them both the visible form sense base will cease and the nose sense base will cease.

For whom the nose sense base will cease, will the mind sense base... etc. will the mind-object sense base cease? Yes.

Or else, for whom the mind-object sense base will cease, will the nose sense base cease for that one?

For those in their last existence being reborn in the fine-material-sphere and immaterial-sphere of existence, and for those who, having been reborn in the fine-material-sphere and immaterial-sphere of existence, will attain final nibbāna, for them passing away, for them the mind-object sense base will cease, but the nose sense base will not cease for them. For the others, for them both the mind-object sense base will cease and the nose sense base will cease. (Nose Sense Base as Root)

135. For whom the visible form sense base will cease, will the mind sense base... etc. will the mind-object sense base cease? Yes.

Or else, for whom the mind-object sense base will cease, will the visible form sense base cease for that one?

For those in their last existence being reborn in the immaterial realm, and for those who, having been reborn in the immaterial realm, will attain final nibbāna, for them passing away, for them the mind-object sense base will cease, but the visible form sense base will not cease for them. For the others, for them both the mind-object sense base will cease and the visible form sense base will cease.

136. For whom the mind sense base will cease, will the mind-object sense base cease for that one? Yes.

Or else, for whom the mind-object sense base will cease, will the mind sense base cease for that one? Yes.

Conformity Place

137. Where the eye sense base will cease... etc.

Conformity - Person - Place

138. For whom and where the eye sense base will cease, will the ear sense base cease for that one there? Yes.

Or else, for whom and where etc.? Yes.

For whom and where the eye sense base will cease, will the nose sense base cease for that one there?

For fine-material-sphere beings etc. For sensual-sphere beings etc.

Or else, for whom and where etc.? Yes.

For whom and where the eye sense base will cease, will the visible form sense base cease for that one there? Yes.

Or else, for whom and where the visible form sense base will cease, will the eye sense base cease for that one there?

For non-percipient beings etc. For five-aggregate constituent beings etc.

For whom and where the eye sense base will cease, will the mind sense base cease for that one there? Yes.

Or else, for whom and where etc.?

For immaterial beings etc. For five-aggregate constituent beings etc.

For whom and where the eye sense base will cease, will the mind-object sense base cease for that one there? Yes.

Or else, for whom and where etc.?

For non-percipient beings and immaterial beings etc. For five-aggregate constituent beings etc. (Eye Sense Base as Root)

139. For whom and where the nose sense base will cease, will the visible form sense base cease for that one there? Yes.

Or else, for whom and where etc.?

For fine-material-sphere beings etc. For sensual-sphere beings etc.

For whom and where the nose sense base will cease, will the mind sense base cease for that one there? Yes.

Or else, for whom and where etc.?

For fine-material-sphere and immaterial-sphere beings etc. For sensual-sphere beings etc.

For whom and where the nose sense base will cease, will the mind-object sense base cease for that one there? Yes.

Or else, for whom and where etc.?

For fine-material-sphere and immaterial-sphere beings etc. For sensual-sphere beings etc. (Nose Sense Base as Root)

140. For whom and where the visible form sense base will cease, will the mind sense base cease for that one there?

For non-percipient beings etc. For five-aggregate constituent beings etc.

Or else, for whom and where etc.?

For immaterial beings etc. For five-aggregate constituent beings etc.

For whom and where the visible form sense base will cease, will the mind-object sense base cease for that one there? Yes.

Or else, for whom and where etc.?

For immaterial beings etc. For five-aggregate constituent beings and non-percipient beings etc. (Visible Form Sense Base as Root)

141. For whom and where the mind sense base etc.? Yes.

Or else, for whom and where etc.?

For non-percipient beings etc. For four-aggregate constituent beings and five-aggregate constituent beings, for them there both the mind-object sense base will cease and the mind sense base will cease. (As the future questions for whom and where have been expanded in the arising section, so they should be expanded in cessation also).

Negative Person

142. For whom the eye sense base will not cease, will the ear sense base not cease for that one? Yes.

Or else, for whom the ear sense base will not cease, will the eye sense base not cease for that one? Yes.

For whom the eye sense base will not cease, will the nose sense base not cease for that one? Yes.

Or else, for whom the nose sense base will not cease, will the eye sense base not cease for that one?

For those in their last existence being reborn in the fine-material-sphere, and for those who, having been reborn in the fine-material-sphere, will attain final nibbāna, for them passing away, for them the nose sense base will not cease, but the eye sense base will cease for them. For those attaining final nibbāna in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for those in their last existence in the immaterial-sphere of existence, and for those who, having been reborn in the immaterial realm, will attain final nibbāna, for them passing away, for them both the nose sense base will not cease and the eye sense base will not cease.

For whom the eye sense base will not cease, will the visible form sense base not cease for that one? Yes.

Or else, for whom the visible form sense base will not cease, will the eye sense base not cease for that one? Yes.

For whom the eye sense base will not cease, will the mind sense base... etc. will the mind-object sense base not cease for that one?

For those in their last existence being reborn in the immaterial realm, and for those who, having been reborn in the immaterial realm, will attain final nibbāna, for them passing away, for them the eye sense base will not cease, but the mind-object sense base will cease for them. For those attaining final nibbāna, for them both the eye sense base will not cease and the mind-object sense base will not cease.

Or else, for whom the mind-object sense base will not cease, will the eye sense base not cease for that one? Yes. (Eye Sense Base as Root)

143. For whom the nose sense base will not cease, will the visible form sense base not cease for that one?

For those in their last existence being reborn in the fine-material-sphere, and for those who, having been reborn in the fine-material-sphere, will attain final nibbāna, for them passing away, for them the nose sense base will not cease, but the visible form sense base will cease for them. For those attaining final nibbāna in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for those in their last existence in the immaterial-sphere of existence, and for those who, having been reborn in the immaterial realm, will attain final nibbāna, for them passing away, for them both the nose sense base will not cease and the visible form sense base will not cease.

Or else, for whom the visible form sense base will not cease, will the nose sense base not cease for that one? Yes.

For whom the nose sense base will not cease, will the mind sense base... etc. will the mind-object sense base not cease for that one?

For those in their last existence being reborn in the fine-material-sphere and immaterial-sphere of existence, and for those who, having been reborn in the fine-material-sphere and immaterial-sphere of existence, will attain final nibbāna, for them passing away, for them the nose sense base will not cease, but the mind-object sense base will cease for them. For those attaining final nibbāna, for them both the nose sense base will not cease and the mind-object sense base will not cease.

Or else, for whom the mind-object sense base will not cease, will the nose sense base not cease for that one? Yes.

144. For whom the visible form sense base will not cease, will the mind sense base... etc. will the mind-object sense base not cease for that one?

For those in their last existence being reborn in the immaterial realm, and for those who, having been reborn in the immaterial realm, will attain final nibbāna, for them passing away, for them the visible form sense base will not cease, but the mind-object sense base will cease for them. For those attaining final nibbāna, for them both the visible form sense base will not cease and the mind-object sense base will not cease.

Or else, for whom the mind-object sense base will not cease, will the visible form sense base not cease for that one? Yes.

145. For whom the mind sense base will not cease, will the mind-object sense base not cease for that one? Yes.

Or else, for whom the mind-object sense base will not cease, will the mind sense base not cease for that one? Yes.

The Negative Section on Place

146. Where the eye sense base will not cease, etc.

Negative - Person - Place

147. For whom and where the eye sense base will not cease, will the ear sense base not cease for that one there? Yes.

Or else, for whom and where the ear sense base will not cease, will the eye sense base not cease for that one there? Yes.

For whom and where the eye sense base will not cease, will the nose sense base not cease for that one there? Yes.

Or else, for whom and where the nose sense base will not cease, will the eye sense base not cease for that one there?

For fine-material-sphere beings, for them there the nose sense base will not cease, but the eye sense base will cease for them there. For those attaining final nibbana in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for non-percipient beings, and for immaterial beings, for them there both the nose sense base will not cease and the eye sense base will not cease.

For whom and where the eye sense base will not cease, will the visible form sense base not cease for that one there?

For non-percipient beings, for them there the eye sense base will not cease, but the visible form sense base will cease for them there. For those attaining final nibbana in the five-aggregate constituent realm and for immaterial beings, for them there both the eye sense base will not cease and the visible form sense base will not cease.

Or else, for whom and where the visible form sense base will not cease, will the eye sense base not cease for that one there? Yes.

For whom and where the eye sense base will not cease, will the mind sense base not cease for that one there?

For immaterial beings, for them there the eye sense base will not cease, but the mind sense base will cease for them there. For those attaining final nibbana and for non-percipient beings, for them there both the eye sense base will not cease and the mind sense base will not cease.

Or else, for whom and where the mind sense base will not cease, will the eye sense base not cease for that one there? Yes.

For whom and where the eye sense base will not cease, will the mind-object sense base not cease for that one there?

For non-percipient beings and immaterial beings, for them there the eye sense base will not cease, but the mind-object sense base will cease for them there. For those attaining final nibbana, for them there both the eye sense base will not cease and the mind-object sense base will not cease.

Or else, for whom and where the mind-object sense base will not cease, will the eye sense base not cease for that one there? Yes. (Eye Sense Base as Root)

148. For whom and where the nose sense base will not cease, will the visible form sense base not cease for that one there?

For fine-material-sphere beings, for them there the nose sense base will not cease, but the visible form sense base will cease for them there. For those attaining final nibbana in the five-aggregate constituent realm and for immaterial beings, for them there both the nose sense base will not cease and the visible form sense base will not cease.

Or else, for whom and where the visible form sense base will not cease, will the nose sense base not cease for that one there? Yes.

For whom and where the nose sense base will not cease, will the mind sense base not cease for that one there?

For fine-material-sphere and immaterial-sphere beings, for them there the nose sense base will not cease, but the mind sense base will cease for them there; for those attaining final nibbana and for non-percipient beings, for them there both the nose sense base will not cease and the mind sense base will not cease.

Or else, for whom and where the mind sense base will not cease, will the nose sense base not cease for that one there? Yes.

For whom and where the nose sense base will not cease, will the mind-object sense base not cease for that one there?

For fine-material-sphere and immaterial-sphere beings, for them there the nose sense base will not cease, but the mind-object sense base will cease for them there. For those attaining final nibbana, for them there both the nose sense base will not cease and the mind-object sense base will not cease.

Or else, for whom and where the mind-object sense base will not cease, will the nose sense base not cease for that one there?

Yes. (Nose Sense Base as Root)

149. For whom and where the visible form sense base will not cease, will the mind sense base not cease for that one there?

For immaterial beings, for them there the visible form sense base will not cease, but the mind sense base will cease for them there. For those attaining final nibbana, for them there both the visible form sense base will not cease and the mind sense base will not cease.

Or else, for whom and where the mind sense base will not cease, will the visible form sense base not cease for that one there?

For non-percipient beings, for them there the mind sense base will not cease, but the visible form sense base will cease for them there. For those attaining final nibbana, for them there both the mind sense base will not cease and the visible form sense base will not cease.

For whom and where the visible form sense base will not cease, will the mind-object sense base not cease for that one there?

For immaterial beings, for them there the visible form sense base will not cease, but the mind-object sense base will cease for them there. For those attaining final nibbana, for them there both the visible form sense base will not cease and the mind-object sense base will not cease.

Or else, for whom and where the mind-object sense base will not cease, will the visible form sense base not cease for that one there? Yes. (Visible Form Sense Base as Root)

150. For whom and where the mind sense base will not cease, will the mind-object sense base not cease for that one there?

For non-percipient beings, for them there the mind sense base will not cease, but the mind-object sense base will cease for them there. For those attaining final nibbana, for them there both the mind sense base will not cease and the mind-object sense base will not cease.

Or else, for whom and where the mind-object sense base will not cease, will the mind sense base not cease for that one there? Yes.

(4) The Section on Present and Past

Conformity Person

151. For whom the eye sense base ceases, had the ear sense base ceased for that one? Yes.

Or else, for whom the ear sense base had ceased, does the eye sense base cease for that one?

For all those being reborn, for those without eyes passing away, for them the ear sense base had ceased, but the eye sense base does not cease for them. For those with eyes passing away, for them both the ear sense base had ceased and the eye sense base ceases.

For whom the eye sense base ceases, does the nose sense base... etc. the visible form sense base... etc. the mind sense base... etc. had the mind-object sense base ceased? Yes.

Or else, for whom the mind-object sense base had ceased, does the eye sense base cease for that one?

For all those being reborn, for those without eyes passing away, for them the mind-object sense base had ceased, but the eye sense base does not cease for them. For those with eyes passing away, for them both the mind-object sense base had ceased and the eye sense base ceases.

152. For whom the nose sense base ceases, does the visible form sense base... etc. the mind sense base... etc. had the mind-object sense base ceased? Yes.

Or else, for whom the mind-object sense base had ceased, does the nose sense base cease for that one?

For all those being reborn, for those without nose passing away, for them the mind-object sense base had ceased, but the nose sense base does not cease for them. For those with nose passing away, for them both the mind-object sense base had ceased and the nose sense base ceases.

153. For whom the visible form sense base ceases, does the mind sense base... etc. had the mind-object sense base ceased? Yes.

Or else, for whom the mind-object sense base had ceased, does the visible form sense base cease for that one?

For all those being reborn, for immaterial beings passing away, for them the mind-object sense base had ceased, but the visible form sense base does not cease for them. For those with material form passing away, for them both the mind-object sense base had ceased and the visible form sense base ceases.

154. For whom the mind sense base ceases, did the mind-object sense base cease for that one? Yes.

Or else, for whom the mind-object sense base had ceased, does the mind sense base cease for that one?

For all those being reborn, for those without consciousness passing away, for them the mind-object sense base had ceased, but the mind sense base does not cease for them. For those with consciousness passing away, for them both the mind-object sense base had ceased and the mind sense base ceases.

Conformity Place

155. Where the eye sense base ceases... etc.

Conformity - Person - Place

156. For whom and where the eye sense base ceases, did the ear sense base cease for that one there?

For those attaining final nibbana in the Pure Abodes, for them there the eye sense base ceases, but the ear sense base had not ceased for them there. For the others with eyes passing away, for them there both the eye sense base ceases and the ear sense base had ceased.

Or else, for whom and where the ear sense base had ceased, does the eye sense base cease for that one there?

For those being reborn in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for those without eyes passing away from the sensual-sphere of existence, for them there the ear sense base had ceased, but the eye sense base does not cease for them there. For those with eyes passing away, for them there both the ear sense base had ceased and the eye sense base ceases.

For whom and where the eye sense base ceases, did the nose sense base cease for that one there?

For those passing away from the fine-material-sphere, for them there the eye sense base ceases, but the nose sense base had not ceased for them there. For those with eyes passing away from the sensual-sphere of existence, for them there both the eye sense base ceases and the nose sense base had ceased.

Or else, for whom and where the nose sense base had ceased, does the eye sense base cease for that one there?

For those being reborn in the sensual-sphere of existence, for those without eyes passing away from the sensual-sphere of existence, for them there the nose sense base had ceased, but the eye sense base does not cease for them there. For those with eyes passing away from the sensual-sphere of existence, for them there both the nose sense base had ceased and the eye sense base ceases.

For whom and where the eye sense base ceases, did the visible form sense base cease for that one there?

For those attaining final nibbana in the Pure Abodes, for them there the eye sense base ceases, but the visible form sense base had not ceased for them there. For the others with eyes passing away, for them there both the eye sense base ceases and the visible form sense base had ceased.

Or else, for whom and where the visible form sense base had ceased, does the eye sense base cease for that one there?

For those being reborn in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for those without eyes passing away from the sensual-sphere of existence, for non-percipient beings, for them there the visible form sense base had ceased, but the eye sense base does not cease for them there. For those with eyes passing away, for them there both the visible form sense base had ceased and the eye sense base ceases.

For whom and where the eye sense base ceases, did the mind sense base cease for that one there?

For those attaining final nibbana in the Pure Abodes, for them there the eye sense base ceases, but the mind sense base had not ceased for them there. For the others with eyes passing away, for them there both the eye sense base ceases and the mind sense base had ceased.

Or else, for whom and where the mind sense base had ceased, does the eye sense base cease for that one there?

For those being reborn in the five-aggregate constituent realm, for those without eyes passing away from the sensual-sphere of existence, for immaterial beings, for them there the mind sense base had ceased, but the eye sense base does not cease for them there. For those with eyes passing away, for them there both the mind sense base had ceased and the eye sense base ceases.

For whom and where the eye sense base ceases, did the mind-object sense base cease for that one there?

For those attaining final nibbana in the Pure Abodes, for them there the eye sense base ceases, but the mind-object sense base had not ceased for them there. For the others with eyes passing away, for them there both the eye sense base ceases and the mind-object sense base had ceased.

Or else, for whom and where the mind-object sense base had ceased, does the eye sense base cease for that one there?

For all those being reborn, for those without eyes passing away, for them there the mind-object sense base had ceased, but the eye sense base does not cease for them there. For those with eyes passing away, for them there both the mind-object sense base had ceased and the eye sense base ceases. (Eye Sense Base as Root)

157. For whom and where the nose sense base ceases, did the visible form sense base cease for that one there? Yes.

Or else, for whom and where the visible form sense base had ceased, does the nose sense base cease for that one there?

For those without nose being reborn in the sensual-sphere of existence, for those passing away from the sensual-sphere of existence, for fine-material-sphere beings, for them there the visible form sense base had ceased, but the nose sense base does not cease for them there. For those with nose passing away, for them there both the visible form sense base had ceased and the nose sense base ceases.

For whom and where the nose sense base ceases, did the mind sense base cease for that one there? Yes.

Or else, for whom and where the mind sense base had ceased, does the nose sense base cease for that one there?

For those without nose being reborn in the sensual-sphere of existence, for those passing away from the sensual-sphere of existence, for fine-material-sphere and immaterial-sphere beings, for them there the mind sense base had ceased, but the nose sense base does not cease for them there. For those with nose passing away, for them there both the mind sense base had ceased and the nose sense base ceases.

For whom and where the nose sense base ceases, did the mind-object sense base cease for that one there? Yes.

Or else, for whom and where the mind-object sense base had ceased, does the nose sense base cease for that one there?

For all those being reborn, for those without nose passing away, for them there the mind-object sense base had ceased, but the nose sense base does not cease for them there. For those with nose passing away, for them there both the mind-object sense base had ceased and the nose sense base ceases. (Nose Sense Base as Root)

158. For whom and where the visible form sense base ceases, did the mind sense base cease for that one there?

For those attaining final nibbana in the Pure Abodes, for those passing away from the non-percipient being realm, for them there the visible form sense base ceases, but the mind sense base had not ceased for them there. For the others passing away from the five-aggregate constituent realm, for them there both the visible form sense base ceases and the mind sense base had ceased.

Or else, for whom and where the mind sense base had ceased, does the visible form sense base cease for that one there?